I don't look down on people that prefer the documentary or doing the wedding video, I just think it's an entirely different temperament or interest. I haven't seen good wedding video producers that are also great at sci fi, fantasy, horror or really into those genres of narrative film making. And the opposite is true, the really good indie film makers that are doing cool shorts or features in those genres generally suck at the documentary or wedding video.
One is not better than the other, but IMO there's not a lot of overlap. Both use a camera and similar camera moves, and that's about it. Everything else is the opposite. For example in a wedding, you control nothing and must react to capture the event. In a narrative you control everything, right down to what shoes your actor will wear if you think that's important.
And IMO, that's how those two different artists begin to think the more they do these different tasks.
The wedding videographer has to capture that wedding the way it is so he works to adapt to the situation. The narrative film maker is trying to tell a story. The film maker can decide, you know what? For my story to work and keep the narrative flowing we don't even have to show the wedding. Let's skip that scene entirely and move on. Or perhaps we just need the feeling of a wedding and that's enough. A shot of the bride and groom eating cake and getting in the car and we're done. It's two different ways of thinking.
Yes, you may be the awesome exception that is fantastic at both, and loves to do both. That's just generally not what I have experienced.
One is not better than the other, but IMO there's not a lot of overlap. Both use a camera and similar camera moves, and that's about it. Everything else is the opposite. For example in a wedding, you control nothing and must react to capture the event. In a narrative you control everything, right down to what shoes your actor will wear if you think that's important.
And IMO, that's how those two different artists begin to think the more they do these different tasks.
The wedding videographer has to capture that wedding the way it is so he works to adapt to the situation. The narrative film maker is trying to tell a story. The film maker can decide, you know what? For my story to work and keep the narrative flowing we don't even have to show the wedding. Let's skip that scene entirely and move on. Or perhaps we just need the feeling of a wedding and that's enough. A shot of the bride and groom eating cake and getting in the car and we're done. It's two different ways of thinking.
Yes, you may be the awesome exception that is fantastic at both, and loves to do both. That's just generally not what I have experienced.