Versatile Lighting kit under 1000

arnohist

Member
I am trying to put together a led lighting kit for general videography work, for cinematography for a coming indy documentary (talking heads and action), as well as a minimum set up for a micro budget fiction short film to be lit by me or a cinematographer. It should be under 1000 euros and include the following:

at least one hard light that can be diffused with a soft box (or possibly an amaran 672w instead of the above combination)
at least one hard light that can be modified more accurately perhaps with barn doors. (fresnel add on - worth it?)

This should resemble the basic 800watt redhead kit that has been used in film schools and almost everywhere and be versatile for paid work and also micro-budget creative lighting as I want to learn to light my own shorts.

I am currently torn between 3 x Godox ml-60 or 3 x Nanlite Forza 60. Without any add ons, they cost less than 1000 which leaves some money for a soft box.

Any ideas?
 
You probably researched and know more than anyone else about the differences. I think these lights aren't very powerful with diffusion and you'll quickly out grown them. I'd spend most of my budget on the most powerful key you can afford (150-300w).
 
Last edited:
Hi Peter, thanks for your suggestion. I would love to get my hands on a UL150 for example. That would be a great key light. But it would be impossible (or at least very hard) to carry it around for interviews, not to mention any travelling.

Since my main concern at the moment is sitting interviews (talking heads/medium shots) for corporate use and my upcoming documentary I would first need to fill that gap. The problem is I am going in circles with all the various reviews. Although it seemed that the forza 60 and ml-60 were good options, I saw a review saying they are not powerful enough for key light in interviews after they are put behind diffusion.

So I am going back to square one and thinking if it would be wiser to purchase a set of 3 panels like amaran 672 (spots or wide angled), or perhaps a combination of 2 panels and one hard light.

Any thoughts on that?
 
It might be worth pointing out that a Nanlite Forza 60, or similar, really isn't a particularly powerful light. It depends entirely what you're intending to do with it, of course, but the company's claim that it's the equivalent of a 500W tungsten-halogen light is probably a bit ambitious, and redheads are (were) traditionally 800W to begin with.
 
If I look over my 'evloution' of lighting.

You can do good things with a 60w - basically shooting through a 1.1 softbox/white sheet indoors or direct unmodified in the sun (from 24in away - head shot only) both these things will get the (hand/air/subway) travelling videographer out of jail

A 60 will only do headshots in the main. (50-80mm head fills frame)

A 200 godox will get one into pretty good places when shooting a heands to head shot.

Id look to have a 60 that runs off a couple of little sony batts that will and also a 200, youve got a bit of money left there for another 60 and a couple of bits of grip.

When you have to travel light take the 60 and understand its limitations.

I dont see that Apture is worth the extra cash over Godox.

S
 
Fwiw when I’m planning a simple travel kit (or for here, a low-dollar versatile kit), I typically base it off one strong fixture and 1-2 less expensive fixtures. There are plenty of things you can do with one punchy bicolor light that are a total time-killing PITA to rig with three weaker single-color lights.
 
I would recommend one powerful bi color key light (panel 150w or better) and then a more spotty/directional light like a fresnel/COB LED type light (daylight only is fine) you can dim way down as your edge light in interviews (gel it for tungsten if needed), or crank up for the "action" shots you're talking about (bounce off the ceiling to bring up ambient, shoot through a window to mimic the sun, etc).

You don't have to get a panel as your key, lots of options for non panel lights kitted with a softbox/octobank/etc. I think people are really enjoying the Godox lights and accessories, lots of bang for your buck.
 
I would buy a Godox VL150 on sale ($299.00), a Godox VL300 on sale ($499.00). The remaining $200.00 for a pair pf used,
good quality Beefy Babys or the like (there are amazing bargains on used grip gear lately, I picked up an American Grip a
few weeks ago for $40.00. That was $400.00 stand when new) and pick up a pair of the Chinese Nice Foto or similar parabolic softboxes with the grids.

Why bother with one trick pony LED panels, or fragile, plastic junky lights that will fall apart? The VL150 and 300 give you serious
lighting horsepower, you can stick on barndoors or a fresnel attachment later when you have a little more money so you can make
cuts, BG patterns, spots and you'll have two powerful, reliable and quality sources. I used these new lights all last year on a variety of
shoots and I am convinced they are best bang for the buck on the market. They are not that large or heavy yet are MUCH more useful/versatile
than LED panels.

I am done with my panels except for very specific tasks like lighting a car interior by velcroing my Kamerar Brightcasts
to the headliner. Can't understand why people are even using panels anymore, they are wimpy output compared to COBs
unless you spend a lot of money for a Gemini or Nova, they mostly cannot be used bare on talent so you put them through diffusion
which takes more of their meager output. COBs are so much better in the sub $1k category.
I still have my two Aputure Lightstorms, I have not even used them once since stocking up on COBs (I have seven of them).

Also, I am pretty convinced, owning a few, that almost nobody needs bi-color lights. Maybe one RBGWW light for accents but generally
bi-color lights sacrfice power and output for, whoop de doo wow I can do tungsten too. Not bad to have but when you are struggling to
have enough output, can only afford one or two lights, you don't need bi-color, you need horsepower/output and bi-color is a compromise.

Unless you are constantly shooting exteriors or in remote places, VERY few people NEED battery powered lights, they are largely for lazy people
who won't get off their ass to run a stinger, why sacrifice power and run time for laziness? I have four battery powered lights and almost
all of the time when I have gone to use them on real shoots with batteries, they die at the worst possible time, we have to switch out batteries and that can be
nightmare when the light in question is on a Cardellini on a flat, 13' in the air as an accent or hair light.

I shoot documentaries with LONG interview sessions and live streams that often go all day so for my use case, battery powered lights suck. YMMV. If you shoot
outdoor narrative or short comedy bits, battery powered lights may be a life saver, everyone's situation is different. But if you shoot interiors mostly, you don't need
battery powered lights. You might want them because they are convenient but since the batteries die all of the time, I find they blow takes, talent gets annoyed
and when directing, I get annoyed with lights dying in the middle of takes.
 
Last edited:
I agree 1 or 2 vl150 with cheap parabolics will take care of the key and fill. When I have quick headshot interview I shoot one key with large parabolic near center, adding additional light for separation if the situation permits. While pros might scoff, clients often care only about soft flattering lighting and will not pickup on the nuances of 3 point lighting. But if you truly want the easiest quickest setup that would be led panel lights with a built in plastic frosted diffuser. While panel lights are not as nice I know colleagues shooting interviews on professional jobs and getting adequate results. So what type of lighting is needed isn't written in stone. If you need to hop on a plane and fly to a hotel your setup will be different from, I would like a light setup I can pack in my car and carry into a building in one trip. All of this comes down to 1. the situation 2. the client expectations and budget 3. what results you are willing to live with. For example if you need to film at 3 locations at a company, have only 10 minutes setup time, and the client isn't interested in Hollywood quality results then a simple panel light setup might be more appropriate vs this is 10k job that will be used as part of a tv ad campaign or you're being paid well to film to interview the president of a company and you have over an hour to do a great setup and looking to impress to win over a client.
 
Last edited:
Also, I am pretty convinced, owning a few, that almost nobody needs bi-color lights. Maybe one RBGWW light for accents but generally
bi-color lights sacrfice power and output for, whoop de doo wow I can do tungsten too. Not bad to have but when you are struggling to
have enough output, can only afford one or two lights, you don't need bi-color, you need horsepower/output and bi-color is a compromise..

As a run and gunner shooting interviews, having bi-color options on my Area48 panels have saved my butt a bunch. Luckily with the Area48s you don't sacrifice any power going between daylight + tungsten. It's a 120W light but still powerful enough for almost any interior interview key. The advantage of the panel is that it's a really wide throw so I can fill a 4x4 frame of diff without much space at all (4ft?). The The op would need to decide how important bi-color is to him. Gelling a 5600k COB light for tungsten isn't hard, so I see your point there.

As far as horsepower goes, if they are mainly doing interviews, the panel should be fine, but if they want max options to light a "scene," then COBs are the way to go.
 
I would say a quality pair of 1x1 panel lights is your starting point for corporate headshot interviews. A background and/or hair light would be a nice addition.
 
If it were me, I'd probably buy the new Aputure Amaran 200D as my key, and possibly an Amaran 100D as a second light. For interviews, a common difficult situation for an interview shoot is when you can't avoid including a window in the background-- it's then that you need the most powerful possible key light, and daylight balance. Bi-color lights are more flexible, but in situations where you're matching tungsten light, it's usually at a lower level, so you can get away with gelling.

Why Aputure? Only because I have a C300DII. I know the quality of the light is good, and also that there are models you can step up to if you want to upgrade in the same ecosystem later-- your 200D will match the color of light of a 120D or 600D, and the accessories you buy (like softbox or lantern) will still work. I haven't used Nanlite, but you could probably start with that line instead-- it just looks like their 200 watt lamp is more expensive than the Amaran. I also haven't used Godox, but my only concern is that the build quality seems inconsistent from model to model (based on reviews), and I don't see higher end models that you could eventually step up to.

As a third light, you could buy an inexpensive Aputure/Nanlite/Godox bi-color panel. These can be good for a variety of purposes, but I find them versatile and easy for fill light or lighting a broad area quickly (possibly without setting up a softbox), so I'm willing to trade some power for the speed of bi-color operation.

Note: Aputure also makes good inexpensive accessories. You could just get softboxes, but also consider one of their lanterns-- they're great for lighting a broad area from above (handy for setting an ambient light level in a room-- more control than just bouncing into the ceiling), and they also work just like a softbox if you use the included blackout skirt.
 
If it were me, I'd probably buy the new Aputure Amaran 200D as my key, and possibly an Amaran 100D as a second light. For interviews, a common difficult situation for an interview shoot is when you can't avoid including a window in the background-- it's then that you need the most powerful possible key light, and daylight balance. Bi-color lights are more flexible, but in situations where you're matching tungsten light, it's usually at a lower level, so you can get away with gelling.

Why Aputure? Only because I have a C300DII. I know the quality of the light is good, and also that there are models you can step up to if you want to upgrade in the same ecosystem later-- your 200D will match the color of light of a 120D or 600D, and the accessories you buy (like softbox or lantern) will still work. I haven't used Nanlite, but you could probably start with that line instead-- it just looks like their 200 watt lamp is more expensive than the Amaran. I also haven't used Godox, but my only concern is that the build quality seems inconsistent from model to model (based on reviews), and I don't see higher end models that you could eventually step up to.

As a third light, you could buy an inexpensive Aputure/Nanlite/Godox bi-color panel. These can be good for a variety of purposes, but I find them versatile and easy for fill light or lighting a broad area quickly (possibly without setting up a softbox), so I'm willing to trade some power for the speed of bi-color operation.

Note: Aputure also makes good inexpensive accessories. You could just get softboxes, but also consider one of their lanterns-- they're great for lighting a broad area from above (handy for setting an ambient light level in a room-- more control than just bouncing into the ceiling), and they also work just like a softbox if you use the included blackout skirt.

FWIW, I have five of the Godox, two VL150s and three VL300s. IMHO, I think they are actually a bit better built than my three Aputures and two of my three Aputures have broken, one needs a new control box that just stopped working one shoot
and I cannot even figure out how to buy one from Aputure or elsewhere as the only replacement boxes available seem to be for the bi-color version of my daylight panel. I like Aputure but I would buy the Godox all day over the plastic, cheap Aputures. So far, after
about eight months of relatively busy shooting, no hiccups, glitches, breaks or repairs with the Godox. I think they present a better value equation than the Aputures, which are just okay build quality. Same with the Godox, they are fine but they
are not Arri or Creamsource build quality for sure. I think with light construction, you pretty much get what you pay for. If the Godox last me 3-4 years, I think they will have been money well spent.
 
Last edited:
IMHO, I think they are actually a bit better built than my three Aputures...

Thanks for sharing your positive experience-- I guess I should give them a real look next time I need a fixture, maybe save a little money!

I've had better luck with my Aputure units (a C300D and a C300D II) and the ones I've borrowed or rented in recent years-- knock on wood, but no failures or repairs yet.
 
Seriously, 3-4 years life for these LEDs? Oy.

Just wrapped a another shoot using my ~18 year old Lowel kit. Replaced a few globes and soldered some new wires over the years and fried more than a couple sets of fingerprints off, but it makes you wonder the real value of some of these ‘advances.’
 
I think it's a good thing to keep in mind when you're dealing with rapidly advancing tech. For example I bought hot lights 3-4 years ago and even though they work just as good as the day I bought them I haven't used them ever since I got my LED lights. Same goes with cameras and computers. They are tools used to accomplish jobs not assets that gain or retain value. Once they've paid for themselves there is no shame in replacing them if newer better tools are developed. So I wouldn't wring my hands too much over making the perfect purchase. It's hard to say if LED lights have reach most of their potential and only have modest improvements.
 
Last edited:
Yep, lights are now in the same cycle of obsolesence as computers and digital cameras. OG Litepanel 1x1's are laughably bad in comparison to modern 1x1's.

On the plus side, something that puts out the right amount and quality of light will still put out that amount of light 5-10 years later (unless the circuitry fries, which is a distinct possibility with anything sporting a board). It's not like apps or video codecs which change more often than underwear.

Get what will pay itself off, cycle it out when you can or need to upgrade, and move on.

......but FWIW, there's a reason we're still waiting for 3200K LED's to get "as good as tungsten." ;) Running power can be a pain, but so can color correcting in post
 
Seriously, 3-4 years life for these LEDs? Oy.

Just wrapped a another shoot using my ~18 year old Lowel kit. Replaced a few globes and soldered some new wires over the years and fried more than a couple sets of fingerprints off, but it makes you wonder the real value of some of these ‘advances.’

I know, I STILL have and occasionally use my Arri Tungsten Softbank kit I bought in the mid 90s. The Arris will be here after the apocalypse along with the cockroaches.
LEDs are ALL fragile in comparison to tungsten instruments. I can't think of any LEDs, even the Arri Skypanels, that would likely function after hitting the ground from 10' up on a stand whereas with tungsten, replace the globe and keep on working!
 
Last edited:
On the lower LED price level I have one each Godox UL-150, VL-150, SL-60.
The nice thing about the UL-150 is it is completely silent.
 
Back
Top