too much low freq

chi_red

Well-known member
Hello,
I am new to sound recording and editing and it is very fun as I am learning new things.

I have noticed that most dialogues I record have too much low frequency, it sounds like it has too much bass to my untrained ears. If I play around with an equalizer and reduce low frequency, then it sounds very natural and clean.

My recorder has this function called "High Pass" control, and it reduces(or kills) low frequency. My mic also has a Roll-Off
switch(is that the correct term?) that lowers lower frequency.

Here is my question,
should I fix low freq problems during production by using "High Pass" control on my recorder OR turing on the Roll-Off switch?

or
should I do it by doing it post production.
I don't have a sound editing program beside free audio editing programs I donwloaded, but I can use the EQ on Premiere Pro 1.5.
logically thinking, this sounds like a better idea,
but
Is there a disadvantage by doing this way? such as creting more noise etc.

Thank you
 
Re: too much low freq

The first thing you need to determine is if what your hearing is accurate. Most "stereo speakers" including those for computers are not "flat", most are designed to boost bass frequencies (because that's what consumers like - go into any stereo store and you'll surely hear the salesman say, at some point, "listen to that bass"). That's why a pair of good nearfield monitors is invaluable. It's the audio equivalent of having a production monitor. So my first question would be, what are you listening on?

After that, experimentation is the key, each piece of equipment will react differently. Also the environment will effect the sound (both in where it was recorded and where you are monitoring it). But at the end of the day, the only thing that matters is that you have an audio track that sounds the way you want it to sound, assuming that what you are hearing is accurate.

Matt
 
Re: too much low freq

The roll off switch on your mic and/or mixer shouldn't touch touch the human voice except maybe James Earl Jones. It will get rid of some wind and handling noise.

For example, the MKH60 attenuates the bass by 5db at 100Hz. The male human voice has a range of 87Hz to 12Khz. Some very bassy males will be slightly effected by the attenuation but not dramatically.

During the recording process you can play around with mic placement (lavs on the chest tend to be bassy) to improve the audio.

When you are listen to dialog playback and find it to be too bassy, what are you listening with? It very likely could be your speakers/headphones. You really need to have the proper speakers if you want to EQ your dialog.

Good luck. :)
 
Re: too much low freq

thanks alot wabbit and MattC,
you guys are right,
I was using cheap 50 dollar speakers.
I tested with my Sony MDR7506 headphone and it still sounded like it has too much low freq.
I am going to order this when it is in stock,
http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home?O=WishList.jsp&A=details&Q=&sku=321848&is=REG


Anyway, my question is,
What is disadvantage if I use EQ to fix during post production?


and should I have "High Pass" control(reducing low freq) on my recorder
and turn "roll off switch" ON my mic all the time to get rid of wind and handling noise? This setting might be good for untrained sound person like myself.
Do you guys ever turn the roll off switch ON?

thank you :)
 
Re: too much low freq

Chi, I hate to say this but I'm not sure how much those monitors are going to help. I have no experience with them, so I can't say for sure, but I doubt you're going to get much better performance at that price point. I'd rather see you wait and get something in the $200-$300 dollar range. At this price point they may not be great, but at least they'll be functional. I'm afraid if you buy the Behringers you'll just wind up replacing them again in a matter of months....

EQ in post? It's done all the time. In fact I can't think of a single instance where I didn't use at least some EQ in post. What is important is that you start with a good signal/track. If the track is clean, and was recorded well, then there won't be any problems using EQ in post. Now, I'm assuming that you'll be doing this with a plug-in and that you're not using an outboard hardware unit. That's fine, but bear in mind that not all plugs are the same. I'm partial to those made by Waves myself. www.waves.com

Best of luck.

Matt
 
Re: too much low freq

alter your sound in the field when you have to, otherwise record everything in the field flat and fix it in post. there are too many things that can fool you in the field to be making a lot of adjustments there. if the wind rumble is a problem then yes adjust for that. if it's just a matter of taste, wait and work on that in post.
 
Re: too much low freq

MattC and Xort, thanks alot,
any recommendations on cheap Nearfield Monitor speakers?
preferably ones with internal amp powered with 1/8" Mini Input to connect directly to my computer.
 
Re: too much low freq

look at the behringer (thuth moniters) or the Phonic (p8a)
make sure you get the 8 inch. Phonic has some 6 inch studio moniters they are firewood. i would go to a local audio shop and listen to as many as you can. i hope this helps. But i dont think any of these will have 1/8 mini you will have to get 1/8 stereo to 2 1/4 mono (left and right)
 
Re: too much low freq

I have a set of Fostex PM .05 (http://www.samedaymusic.com/product--FOSPM05)and they're real nice little speakers for the price.  They take xlr inputs (and 1/4") which is pretty standard.  Once you upgrade to a quality audio interface (which you should) this won't be a problem.  I know, I know, you don't want to buy more stuff - so then you'll at least have to get an adapter for the short term.  You simply won't find real monitors that take an 1/8" input.

Matt

Edit: I'm not a fan of Behringer's stuff, although others like them.  But for the money, I think the Fostex are better - but again this is subjective.  
 
Back
Top