The Singing Detective

MattinSTL

Sound Modulator
Has anybody else watched any of this?

It's BBC and the pacing isn't like an action flick... but it's amazing that it was done in the 80's and the acting and writing are all first rate. This series was supposed to air on PBS in the states but it was banned due to the occasional breast shot.

I've been so impressed with some of the lines that I almost want to pause the DVD and write them down... just to twist into something I could use later.

Seriously the writing is just brilliant.

If you've noticed it playing on HBO but always clicked passed it you should give it about 10 minutes of your time.

The premise is that this older guy was a detective novelist. He is bed-ridden with eczema or some insane skin flaking disease... so his mind is bent by the pain and fears of hopelessness... and due to this condition all he can do is think about new detective stories which he works out in his mind. He always sees a healthy version of himself as "the singing detective" which is front man for a big band... but is a top detective when he's not performing.

The show moves from hallucinations about the colorful characters in the traditional British hospital ward... to the detective story that's building in his mind (with the ward's characters and doctors in the story)... to memories from his youth which have formed his personality... and back again to reality.

The show unfolds on so many levels and the writing is just amazing. The show includes various comedic premises and funny bumps to the main story.

It's just a great lesson in how to put a show together. I'm sure it's not for many people because you can't just sit there and not listen... or you'll get bored. The pleasure in the show is in the amazing writing.
 
Matt-it did air on PBS in the 1980's, because that's when I saw it. I thought it was relevatory and brilliant. It was pretty stunning compared to the absolute crap surrounding it. Sometimes, something just stands out because it rises so far above everything else. I haven't seen it in years, so I wonder if I'd still feel the same way watching it now.
 
Any connection to the Robert Downey Jr. movie that came out a few years ago?

EDITED TO ADD:
Just looked into it...apparently the movie was a remake of the show.
Interesting, I had no idea.
I obviously haven't seen either one...but the mini series seems to have some pretty high reviews on IMDB.
9.2 out of 10!
 
Luis... yeah I think that was the inspiration for it.

Barry... I was hoping somebody could relate to my feelings about the series. I was just introduced to it recently by a video friend of mine who is a little older then me. She is one of those people who you're thankful to know because they bring things into your life that you'd never find out about any other way.

I think you'd still be very impressed with it.

There are times when I pause it just to ponder the passage of dialog that was just spoken. Like I said the writing is knocking me on my butt. Really it's such a complete package of writing/acting/casting/style that it's WAY more cerebral then anything else that holds my attention.

Remember his indian friend in the bed next to him? How all the nurses think he speaks horrible english but he's just screwing with them for his own, and Marlow's entertainment? Or the beautiful nurse and how Marlow tries so hard to avoid arousal when she's "greasing him down". Or how about how he injects the doctor that he dislikes into his story as a sleazy character?

The show is SO much more complex then anything on TV today. It is seriously brilliant. I also like how the show shocks you in some odd ways. How about when the Russian "escort" chews up the sleazy guy's cash when he thinks he is at first impressing her and then decides that she is nothing more then a tawdry hooker? She shows him that she could care less about money. Talk about a way to mess with a guy's head! What a brilliant scene... it's just genius writing that shows you how to set up ideas under the story.

The show is loaded with new ways to convey something in a completely different style then which you're accustomed.
 
Watched it on PBS (or was it TVO?) when first aired back in the 80's and I too thought it to be brilliant. Michael Gambon is outstanding in it.
 
i just got the bbc box set from my brother for xmas. looking forward to checking it out. i've heard its some of the best television writing ever.
 
Since you guys dig The Singing Detective, check out Steve Martin & Bernadette Peters in "Pennies From Heaven" a movie remake of another BBC series by the same author, Dennis Potter.

http://www.yorksj.ac.uk/potter/

He also wrote "Brimstone & Treacle" with Sting in his first film role, and the 1996 BBC series "Cold Lazarus" starring Albert Finney -- and many many many other things.

And, BTW, ". . .for many years of his life Dennis Potter was in extremely bad health and largely reclusive. . ."
 
Back
Top