I think it's dependent on the project. If it's a narrative, a fictional story, then I'm extremely critical of everything you mentioned and if you don't have good production values I'm not going to watch. But a tutorial? A comedy piece from someone like Jenna Marbles? I don't even look at the production value. I don't expect to see production value, so I don't miss it. In fact in some cases it might even have a negative effect. Would a Jenna Marbles video be as effective on youtube if it did have a high production value? I think it wouldn't. Just to be clear, my gf is a Jenna Marbles fan. I think it's more of a chick thing, but to be fair Jenna Marbles is one of those rare youtubers that has graduated from youtube to Hollywood.
Really? Six seconds into it, if I had been sitting at a table with her, I would have put a hand up in front of her and left.