sound test (3 set-up)

[deleuze3]

Hi,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ksbAwK_H0E&feature=youtu.be

Here is a test i did:

1st sound (0-40sec) : its an oktava mk012 hypercardioid powered by a shure FP23 and recorded in a sony pcm-m10

2nd soud (40sec-1min18) : its a rode lav into the pcm-m10 plugged into the CAMERA T3i (via the mic input)

3rd sound (1min18 to the end) : its a rode lavalier plugged into the sony pcm-m10

1st sound sounds a bit echo and not much bass but the voice is richer. im surprised that my hypercardioid sound echo in this kitchen. its not that good. any thoughts?
2nd sound sounds a bit muffled
3rd sound is a bit muffled but better.

I think the 1st and the 3rd sound sounds better.

What do you guys think ?

Thanks in advance,

 

[GaryNattrass]

It depends what context the sound is to be used on as for drama production they may prefer a more open sound like no 1, I don't know where the mic is placed but in a drama situation a boom operator would be able to get it close and give the best on mic sound.

No 2 is tigher due to the lav mic and 3 is to me the cleanest and most useable as in post I could EQ it and make it what I wish with digital room ambience.