Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

videoshark

Well-known member
i own a SM58 already...how would it work as a boom mic?
cant really go out right now & buy an expensive boom mic!

i also recently bought a CAD E-200..what would that mic be good for?
(i got a sweet deal on it)....

thnx!

e
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

mmmmh, the SM-58 is a dynamic cardiodid mic mainly used by vocalists.
If you use it on a boom, make sure to get as close to the actors mouth
as possible, otherwise you will get very bad sound.
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

Obviously not what you'd get if you had money otherwise - but I shot a short film, and had to use an SM-58 for my boom mic, and the audio turned out great.

I don't have the clip online anymore, but PM me and we can try to find a way to send you a clip so you can judge if it's good enough.
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

I wouldn't say "no and no". Let's be a tad encouraging here.

If you don't have money for more stuff, will booming an sm58 sound better than using the built-in mic on the DVX? You're damn right it will. It'll sound a whole lot better. And depending on the environment might be just fine.

Then again, depending on the environment it'll suck a big %$#@.

Give it a shot... it's free cause you already have it.
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

Yeah, run some tests at home and see if they're satisfactory. I bet you'll be happy, and if you haven't got any more money, it *will* be the best that you can get! Any SM58 that's closer to the talent than the on-board DVX mic will undoubtedly sound better...
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

For an SM 58 to sound really good, it has to be within a few inches of the mouth of your subject. It is also very heaby for it's size. Good reporter and vocal mic for the price but a bad idea for a boom mic.
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

That's the point I was going to make. In order for that mic to work, you literally have to be right on it, which won't work on a boom pole. If you do hear anything, it'll sound very distant and not loud enough. I would argue that the camera mic might work better, but the only way to really know is to do some camera and sound tests. I would borrow or rent a mic for this project. Or, just loop the dialogue, which I know is not optimal.


-Dave
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

When I shot my film, the mic was on average about two or three feet away from the actors mouths - and the audio turned out fine...

Yes, there was background ambience, but it was CLEAN audio, and the dialogue was perfectly audible. I've had no complaints about the audio so far...
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

On a nothing budget, you gotta do what you gotta do. I guess it really depends on where this project is going to go. If you are making a film just for the experience, then you use what works, and the project is a success if you learn something from it. If it's going into festival play, and possible distribution, then I would spring for the semi pro to pro gear.

-Dave
 
Re: Sm58..would it work for a boom mic? (im poor)

thanks guys!!!
ill check it out..how about the CAD E-200?
i did use it for an interview on a mounted boom.
it came out pretty good.
but it is pretty big for carry around...

e
 
Back
Top