Questions about boundry mics

BillWojo

Active member
Has anybody used them before? Can you place one up high and out of site and still get useable audio in an average sized family room?
Thank you
Bill
 
Can you place one up high and out of site and still get useable audio in an average sized family room?

Usable for what? Surveillance? Sure. Dialog for film/video? Not at all.

The same laws of physics that apply to other mics, especially the inverse square law, apply here. Boundary mics can be great as plant mics, but they have to be close.

I find them much more useful for live sound reinforcement than for recorded dialog, but every mic has its time and place. If you have a conversation at a table and the boundary mic is hidden from the camera on the table, it can be useful. Boundary mics can also be good for recording piano.
 
Boundary mics are not magic. If you place them against a reflective boundary (wall, ceiling, floor, etc.) they reduce the effect of near reflections, but they CANNOT make up for being too far away from the subjects (such as your scenario proposes). If you want to borrow one and try it, go for it. But don't hold your breath. I wouldn't go out and buy one for such an application.

IMHO boundary mics are a one-trick pony and were VASTLY over-sold into applications where they are of no value at all. More trouble than they are worth, even. They are not nearly as popular these days, IMHO, an indication that people have seen through the hype and have gone back to using more sensible types of microphones.
 
No more so than considering a shotgun to every recording solution. In rooms with hard walls and parallel surfaces sound can be very troublesome, and a boundary can at least remove the effect on of the planes (walls) produces. So I suppose, that has to be a feature offered by these mics that other don't have. In situations where the plane is not huge - like tables and 8 x 4 sheets, with a mic on the middle - the benefits get weaker. You just do what every sound designer does - looks at the space and choose the most appropriate technique. I do agree with Richard on the fact that they are NOT Magic. For certain uses, they are the best. The most common one is in Police interview rooms where they record conversations. Small, hard surface rooms with washable surfaces. The worst possible combination for any form of mobile microphone. Boundaries are (at least in the UK) the standard microphone used because they produce the best clarity. They could get better with mics that could be positioned properly, aimed and monitored by specialists, but that's just impossible in the circumstances - so boundaries, for this usage, are best. If the scenario was this space for a movie scene, then you'd be in close with something better of course - but if this was impossible ………..
 
Yea, I need it for surveillance for several hours. I have a Tascam DR100 and that's it. So in my research I came across the boundry mics and they looked good. I'm going to have to rent what ever I need and I have a week to set it up. Any ideas? This is very important that I get it right in case something is said that I can use. I don't want to get into the details here on the net.
Thanks
Bill
 
There are some excellent covert boundary mics that can be fixed into floors, walls or ceilings - or pretty well any panel. Cheap condenser elements in small housings can be slid into small drilled holes with cabling hidden, if that's what you want. Other than that - most of the cheaper boundary mics have keyhole slots on the back for fixing - and sound not at all bad really. They're quite cheap - less than $50, so worth giving a go.
 
Please note that the inverse-square law applies whatever kind of microphone you use. And the more reverberant (reflecting) the room, the shorter the practical working distance. The closer you can get the mic to the subject(s), the more intelligible the recording will be. Microphones can be very tiny. For example, the Rode SmartLav is the size of a match-head. And it can be plugged into any smart phone set to record. For that matter you can get several simple voice recorders (complete, microphones, recoder, etc.) for the cost of one boundary mic. And you can hide them around the area to pick up conversations in various parts of the room, etc. And if you have collaborators, they could wear hidden recorders. Anything to get the mics closer to the subjects.
 
Has anybody used them before? Can you place one up high and out of site and still get useable audio in an average sized family room?
Thank you
Bill

A boundary mic. is an excellent device if you know how to use it.

It has a 3dB (or is it 6dB ?) boost due to the boundary effect and does not suffer from the reflections of a mic. placed away from the boundary.

In your case I think it would work very well.
 
Has anybody used them before? Can you place one up high and out of site and still get useable audio in an average sized family room?
Thank you
Bill

Boundary mics by definition use the surface to which they are mounted to gather sound. You would need to mount one to a large flat surface for it to be effective at all and it can't discriminate between different sounds collected at the surface. They work best on a table top within 3' of the talent.

We use them extensively in interview and role play recording systems for law enforcement and educational purposes. For ceiling mount in acoustically treated video conference suites we have shifted to hyper cardioids in a flush ceiling housing instead, but still prefer proper table mics unless the client won't accept them.
 
Last edited:
Boundary mics by definition use the surface to which they are mounted to gather sound. You would need to mount one to a large flat surface for it to be effective at all and it can't discriminate between different sounds collected at the surface. They work best on a table top within 3' of the talent.

We use them extensively in interview and role play recording systems for law enforcement and educational purposes. For ceiling mount in acoustically treated video conference suites we have shifted to hyper cardioids in a flush ceiling housing instead, but still prefer proper table mics unless the client won't accept them.

For video conferencing the best option is often to use a single line-array mic. (like the Gefell KEM 975) by the video monitor.

It picks up the whole room clearly with the delegates forgeting the mic. is theer and just talk naturally.

Being a line-array, it does not pick up reflections from the table or ceiling.

As used by CERN and other places where clarity is a must, as well as the German Parliament.
 
John - is this microphone not around £10,000? It might be magic, but at ten grand or so, it is crazily priced, completely outside of most ordinary mortals budget.
 
John - is this microphone not around £10,000? It might be magic, but at ten grand or so, it is crazily priced, completely outside of most ordinary mortals budget.

It's (KEM 975) actually quite low priced, given the production costs and, for video conferencing, can actually work out cheaper than a delegate microphone system with microphones all around the table. Also, because it makes for a much more natural conference without lots of button-pushing it's cost-effectiveness comes also in a more-effective conference as the delegates are thinking about the information they are discussing, rather than having to push a button to speak and being aware of the mic. in front of them all the time.

So, the price should not be looked at as a mic. cost on its own, but as to what it costs in comparison to the whole video conferencing system - then it works out, generally, as good value.

But - the post was written generically, rather than specifically.
 
Back
Top