question about 5.1 surround and media

morten

Well-known member
I'm having an argument with a coleague regarding 5.1 surround and what media can carry it. Here's the gist of the problem:

Several teams have created shorts for a film festival. Some of them have had professional post houses produce 5.1 surround audio for the shorts. Now the head of the festival wants all movies to be submitted on miniDV tapes. As far as I know if you print a movie onto miniDV you lose the 5.1 surround.

I guess there are two questions I need answers for:

1. can you print a movie with 5.1 surround sound on a miniDV?

2. what media can carry 5.1 surround (other than DVD)?

any help will be greatly appreciated

mor10
 
I would like to hear that as well. How do you make surround sound anyway??? I'm little short about that.
 
MiniDV supports two channels of 16-bit audio (at either 48kHz or 44.1kHz) or four channels of 12-bit audio at 32kHz. No support for surround sound.

If you want to preserve your surround-sound options, the DVD is probably about the only way. AVC-HD will support it but it's not really out yet. Blu-Ray and HD-DVD will support it as well.
 
that's what I thought. now I just have to find a way of telling these people that they are completely clueless without sounding like a total ass.....

great help :o)

mor10
 
DVD definately the best way to carry 5.1. you can encode ac3 interleaved sound files from DAWs.. and I think you can do it on Premiere with a DTS encoder. Then importing it to Authoring software with the picture.

Other ways to play 5.1 is with a computer and multi channels out. Definately not the most portable solution though.

Just tell them there will only be stereo on a MiniDV. they'll probably have to spend money for the 5.1 DVD
 
You could encode a matrixed surround format such as ProLogic or ProLogic-II onto the stereo tracks, but you'd have to have the propper matrix decoder at the exhibition venue (unlikely given that both formats are used for home theatres rather than commercial exhibition).
 
You can also get surround sound on film as well. I used to be a security guard at a film lab when I first moved to L.A., and I saw how they did it. It's printed between the sprocket holes on the film. But, since they don't want film, I guess that's not really an option. DVD is the most convenient way to go, but anything that can playback 6 channels of audio will work as long as it can sync to whatever is showing the picture. Of course that requires a bunch of equipment that costs more than a regular old dvd player, so it's not the best solution.

-Dave
 
Do not forget the licensing fee involved with Dolby surround. It is not cheap and will revival the budget of most indy shorts.

Also, mixing surround to sound decent in theatres is not cheap or easy. Do it poorly and you will wish you hadn't done it at all.

Cheers
 
it's crazy. it's a film festival where all the money is going to charity and several of the participant groups actually managed to convince post houses to donate full sound services including foley, scoring and 5.1 surround mixing. that's why the problem occurred. they have DVDs and the festival is asking for miniDV. I had to talk to them and tell them they were destroying the projects by demanding miniDV. I think they got it.

thanks guys. knew I would find the info here.
 
Back
Top