Movie premise - What do you think?

Maybe the crazy brother should dress up in his/their mother's clothes .... kind fo a spin off "Psycho" ...

Yeah the only reason I wanted the sane brother to was because it would give the insane brother the opportunity to be "deluded" into seeing his mother through a window or something.

I was worried after the idea that I had unconsciously got the idea from Psycho, I even re-looked up the plot to see if I had copied it accidentally
 
I think it is a potentially good story. Especially in exploring the idea of reality vs perception from the mentally ill brother's perspective. Is the mother really being poisoned? What makes him think this? I like the idea of it appearing that the mentally ill brother is insane and is simply imagining all this, then it turns out to be true. And perhaps, once the brother figures out that his brother is on to him, he starts poisoning him too. And the bad brother is trying to assure him that everything is okay when it's not. I like the idea of mentally ill people being more in tune with reality than so-called sane people. I think that's a fascinating idea.
 
"A mentally ill man returns home from the asylum and suspects that his brother is poisoning their mother in his absence. "
An intriguing theme, especially if the movie stays uncertain (and perhaps never even fully resolves) if the poisoning is factually true or merely in the imagination of the mentally ill brother!
After all: "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't after you" and so can it be with poisoning as well.

Or when you take karma17's suggestion you could have a "Keyser Söze" kind of revelation at the end of the move which puts everything in a different perspective!
 
Back
Top