me66 vs. at4073a for outdoors

SeanC.

New member
Yes, I have done a search and found lots of praise for the AT over the ME for the DVX. However I've also heard that the me66 is a very good mic for outdoors, and the shoot Im doing is all outdoors, on sailboats and around the water.
Would the at4073a still come out on top in these conditions?
Im thinking of a rycote softie for either one.

also, does the AT have a power capsule built in, unlike the me66?
 
Sean,

If you go to the AT website and look at the cut sheet for the AT4073 you will see that they recommend that this microphone should not be left in direct sun and high humidity should also be avoided.

Kelly
 
That applies to almost every other mic also.

The 4073a does not have a battery power option. Phantom only.

If you have phantom. I'd get the AT.
 
MattinSTL,

No it does not apply to almost every other mic. This is a characteristic of AF (analogue frequancy) condenser mics. Due to the nature of the capsule design they are more susceptible to humidity and heat fluctuations than both electrets and RF condensers. The AT is an AF condenser and the Sennheiser is an electret. The electret is going to be sensitive to some humidity, but will not be affected by heat. The AT4073 cut sheet gives clear temprature ranges that the mic will operate in due to this technology issue. A pretty big consideration when choosing a shot gun mic for outdoor use.

I would look at the frequency response of both mics as well. The ME66 has a much better bump from 3K out to about 12K. The AT has a bump that begins about 3K that then drops of at about 6K and then takes a ride back up just before 10K. This may make dialogue a little hard to discern in an environmnent filled with plenty of other noise. With the low cut engaged I do like the roll off on the AT better than the Sennheiser though.

I still would go with the ME66.
 
As I guy who OWNED an me66, 4073a, 416, and CK-69... I can tell you that the 4073a is in the league of the last two and the me66 isn't anywhere near them... in sound quality, rear-rejection, or directional characteristics.

Bass response begins to fall off with the me66 at 500hz and by 100hz it's down nearly 6db. The 4073a is almost flat from 50hz to 18kHz. The me66 has a smoother bump from 4kHz to 14kHz... but then drops off 8db by 20kHz.

You can look at the charts for yourself and then you can listen for yourself... your ears will EASILY confirm what your eyes see in the specs. Even the rear rejection on the 4073a is 10db better then the me66. I wouldn't be as worried about abilities of the mic you choose when it comes to what frequencies it BOOSTS as I would about what off-axis and rear sounds that mic ATTENTUATES.

If you plan to push the extremes of your mic as far as punishing humidity and heat... then maybe you should get the me66, but I strongly doubt that the conditions are even an issue. The only mic that's ever prompted discussions of humidity is the Schoeps. Most other times if humidity or heat is a problem for one mic it's a problem for another. I've used my large diaphragm studio condensers to record thunder in a rainstorm... with no humidity problems. That's 100% humidity.

All I'm saying is that if you haven't purchased a mic yet and you have phantom power... I'd go with the best sounding mic you can afford. Of the two you mentioned there is a clear leader in sound quality.

4073a spec sheet... look at frequency response and polar chart.

me66 spec sheet... same exam.

Listen for yourself. Sorry that this is three and a half minutes of boring crap... but this is the difference in these two mics. Indoors OR out.
 
Are there much difference between a ME66 and a ME67? for outdoors which is better?
thanks
 
ME67 is more directional, has a longer form factor, and sounds like crap, as does the ME66.
Long Shotguns were an eighties fad. Nothing more.
 
If you want a Long Shutgun, get an older Sennheiser MKH-816

They sell cheap because many sound mixers have switched to radio lav mics
where they would have traditionally used a long shutgun.
 
I thought I saw someone here (was it Dave_Fisk) say that they used Octava's in places where there was risk to the mic? I think the gist was that because of the lower price point, they were willing to take more risks with them (wet, heat, cold, etc.)
 
Back
Top