Is FCPX automatically applying a LUT to my CineStyle 5D footage?

Oedipax

Well-known member
I imported some 5D clips shot with the Technicolor profile and they are super contrasty/crushed when I look at them in FCPX. They look like an exaggerated version of what the S-curve LUT from Technicolor does.

I've poked around in the Inspector and even if I disable all the effects, I can't seem to return my footage to its neutral, flat state. No idea where to go looking for color management in this new version.

Anyone else had this issue?
 
I'm having similar issue with flat Panasonic GH2 prores footage being extremely dark in the thumbnails and during playback.

FCPX for me today has been terrible to use. I'll wait a few months and try it again so hopefully the money isn't wasted. Back to FCP 7.
 
Yeah, I more or less figured it wouldn't be ready for primetime on day one, but a lot of this stuff is just baffling. I'll have to stick with FCP7/Premiere for now and keep playing with FCPX as it gets updated.
 
Here's what I'm seeing. First clip is Quicktime 7, second is FCPX. Source is a 5D quicktime mov. Not an exact frame match, the exposure is identical in the original clip, the camera just panned a bit.

Quicktime:
INUJ0.png


FCPX:
nPvDO.png
 
I have found out why footage is showing dark. FCPX does not work correctly with certain screen calibration profiles. I use an X-Rite puck and software and calibrate a few times a year. My current calibration for some reason makes FCPX show footage dark. If I select a past calibration profile in the System Prefs app / Display / Color then footage shows correct density and gamma.

I am going to recalibrate and see if FCPX will correctly accept that profile for normal looking footage.
 
Thanks for the follow-up, photonashville. As it happens I have my monitor calibrated with ColorEyes and a Spyder 3, same thing. As soon as I switched to pretty much any other profile, my clips starting looking correct again - even older profiles created in a similar way, oddly enough.
 
I think FCPX has issues using version 4 ICC display profiles. I recalibrated my displays with version 2 ICC profiles and got everything back in line. Worth a shot at least...I've read that SL has had a lot of issues with version 4 ICC profiles. Not sure if its limited to those created by X-rite products or not though.
 
Back
Top