Help me pick!

[Sidderke]

Hi,

I'm entering a kind of contest, where they select you on ground if you are a promising filmmaker. You can submit a short (max about 5 minutes) or a trailer. And if I don't have enough time to make a new short, I'm planning to send one of these, but I can't choose! So, I'm looking for opinions.


First one is this, it's a finished short, I'll give a link to a dvinfo thread because it has the link to the film and a little translation of the dutch voice over:

http://www.dvinfo.net/conf/showthrea...hlight=tunnels


The second one is a loose scene out of a bigger script I wrote. Again, the voice over is Dutch, but it's a pretty short scene in which a character explains how his father once was a professor of an academy, wanted to make clones and got banned by his fellow-professors because of those ideas, but went one making them any way, and taking over a city with them.
This is the link:

http://www.16plus.be/node/1268

Can someone help me pick!
Any feedback will be apreciated, thanks in advance!

 

[Sidderke]

No reactions?

I know this maybe isn't the best place to post it, but I don't know where to post it elsewhere, as it isn't shot with a DVX, and I don't want to really just show them, I want advice about which one would be the best pick.
IF someone wants to move it, I have no problem with that.

Best regards,

 

[Cheesesailor77]

I'll watch them again, but for some reason it's really hard for me to be objective because they're not in english. That's obviously just my thing though, sry. I'll try to go through them again and pick which is better.