Green screen and shutter speed

I have to do a green screen shoot on saturday. I want to shoot 24p. I usally do a shutter speed of 180d. The project will be edited on a 1080i timeline. Someone told me that shooting at 180d angle shutter will cause noise in the key when the subject moves and that I should shoot at a higher shutter speed (like 250 speed). Is this true? What frame rate and shutter speed do you guys shoot at for a clean key?
 
This is my first key. It was done with a 180d shutter. Ignoring the fact that the background is not locked to the foreground, the foreground is soft, and the 'raster' or aliasing issue (that has to do with AVCHD in After Effects), if you look at his arm when he moves the cellophane around, you will see blur that is handled with no issues. I had another shot where he waved his hands and they were a complete blur. It handled it very well. This isn't the best example because of the other issues, but I don't think a 180 shutter is an issue.

You will see noise in the shadows of the brim and face. It is a keying issue, but not a shutter issue.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STmR...DvjVQa1PpcFO6qKZwJ6uRulMtDI2iZcXsXBZiDexA3SE=
 
180d? What is that? Is that a currency? A voltage? A glass of some kind of alcoholic beverage?

Shutter speeds are usually measured in fractions of a second (stills) or degrees (motion). Shutter speeds don't typically make a big difference in keying (although it's typically better to shoot progressive). The biggest differences are in lighting, composition and codec, in that order.

Light your subject and your background very well, and separately. Move them far enough apart that they become separate objects for both lighting and composition. Shoot in a codec that favors keying: a 4:2:2, square pixel, inter frame, high bit rate codec.
 
By 180d the original poster means 180 degrees. But arniepix, I have to disagree with you - shutter speeds do make a huge difference when keying. You want as fast a shutter speed as you can afford with the amount of light you have. You also want to stop down your lens as much as possible with the amount of light you have.

The goal is to reduce motion blur and increase dof. The sharper the image the easier it is to key.
... and of course make sure your green is evenly and correctly lit
 
I have always shot keys ( film, video, digital) at standard camera speeds and shutter angles. Never been an issue.
 
Great tips. So if I shoot in 24p, then I should probably not shoot 180 degrees, but at a shutter speed. I know 1/48 is typically what you want for 24p, but should I go to 250 or higher? Will it start to get strobie? Am I better off shotting 30p? Thanks, guys!
 
It depends what you are shooting. If you have someone wearing a hat sitting motionless and talking then shoot 180 degrees.

If you have someone with soft frizzy hair jumping up and down then stop down your lens and shoot as fast a shutter as possible
 
It depends what you are shooting. If you have someone wearing a hat sitting motionless and talking then shoot 180 degrees.

If you have someone with soft frizzy hair jumping up and down then stop down your lens and shoot as fast a shutter as possible

It's such a different look though shooting with a cut shutter...I totally understand the idea of doing that to get the cleanest key possible, but I almost feel like I'd rather have a less than stellar key and shoot at a regular shutter angle just because of how motion is handled otherwise.

I recently worked on a tv show where we shot a whole lot of green screen and I know we didn't change our shutter angle or anything, have you had a lot of problems with motion blur in the past or something?
 
Great tips. So if I shoot in 24p, then I should probably not shoot 180 degrees, but at a shutter speed. I know 1/48 is typically what you want for 24p, but should I go to 250 or higher? Will it start to get strobie? Am I better off shotting 30p? Thanks, guys!

180 degrees at 24 fps is equivalent to 1/48 shutter speed.

We shoot our green screens at 1/48 (or 180 degrees) and they work just fine with reasonable movement.
 
Back
Top