Five Voice Recorders Internal Microphone Shootout

Taky

Well-known member
I tested 5 audio recorders internal microphone recording. Speaks simultaneously at about 1 foot distance. Recorders are set to 192kbps in MP3 format


1. Zoom H2n $199 Amazon.com: Zoom H2n Handy Recorder: Musical Instruments
2. Zoom H1 $99 Amazon.com: Zoom ZH1 Handy Portable Digital Recorder: Musical Instruments
3. Olympus DM420 $149 Amazon.com: Olympus Digital Voice Recorder With Micro Secure Digital Card Slot- Choose Size: Electronics
4. Olympus WS-803 $145 Amazon.com: Olympus WS-803 Voice Recorder: Electronics
5. Sony ICDUX523 $95 Amazon.com: Sony ICDUX523BLK Digital Flash Voice Recorder: Electronics


 
I tested 5 audio recorders internal microphone recording. Speaks simultaneously at about 1 foot distance. Recorders are set to 192kbps in MP3 format


1. Zoom H2n $199 Amazon.com: Zoom H2n Handy Recorder: Musical Instruments
2. Zoom H1 $99 Amazon.com: Zoom ZH1 Handy Portable Digital Recorder: Musical Instruments
3. Olympus DM420 $149 Amazon.com: Olympus Digital Voice Recorder With Micro Secure Digital Card Slot- Choose Size: Electronics
4. Olympus WS-803 $145 Amazon.com: Olympus WS-803 Voice Recorder: Electronics
5. Sony ICDUX523 $95 Amazon.com: Sony ICDUX523BLK Digital Flash Voice Recorder: Electronics

Personally I would ignore this completely.

These are VOICE RECORDERS - ie: dictaphones and are really not suitable or recording audio for video.

For audio for video the Olympus units are:- LS-12, LS-14 and LS-100

The Sony is the D-10 or PCM-D50

The Zoom is the H4n or the new H6

There are also good units from Tascam, Roland and Marantz as well as a few from Nagra.

But the ones listed by the OP are really dictaphones and I would not advise using these for audio (with the possible exception of the H2).
 
John, while it's fine to remind folk that there are better-quality choices available, it's overly harsh to say "ignore this test completely". All of the units you list are more expensive than the cheaper units tested here - a couple are 3x - 5X more. So this test is what it is - it's useful to hear how these low-cost units sound, if for no other reason that confirming that a better recorder is probably worth investing in.
 
I shoot a lot of weddings. It's always challenging to get good audio at live events. I have worked at church that priests refused to get mic'ed. There're DJs at reception will not provide feed or ask for a fee to tap in to the sound board. Thus I am experimenting different ways. So far, these methods work. They might not get the best sound but they all work.

I opt for H2n instead of H4 because of it's size, and I don't need to have XLR input. I placed an H2n on light stand near the DJ's loud speak to record sound. H4's microphone picked up sound on top but H2n pick up sound in front and back. I set to record 2 channel surround front and back goes to left and right channel. Then at post, I can select which channel to use (by applying the Fill-left or Fill-right filter). If I need more cleaner sound, I use the Left channel facing the speaker. If I need more ambiance sound, I pick the right channel facing the audience. It works very well without the need to deal with DJ.

Here's a clip I recorded using this method.

Just the past saturday, I worked at a catholic church. The priest refused to carry a lav mic. Thus I placed a voice recorder at the podium for all the readings. Then I also placed a voice recorder on light stand close to the ceiling speakers. Not the best sound, but it works.

Now for those small dictation machine. It's another new things I tired. I velcroed a voice recorder to handheld microphone. It looks odd closed up but nobody really noticed it. And again, it works. I also have lav mic on the groom and officiant. This little device is cheap, light weight and very portable.
 
John's reply reminds me of few years ago, videographers using camcorders ignore DSLR as a feasible choice to shoot film or events. :)
 
This is from another wedding cinematographer's work. He gaffe taped a zoom H1 on mic stand he prepared. Then direct all the speakers giving toasting speech with the mic stand. It's a $99 zoom H1. It works very well.

You can see the H1 on mic stand right at the beginning.

 
You might want to add the Olympus LS-7 and the Tascam DR-05 recorders to your test as both of these recorders are comparable to the Zoom H1.

I own a Zoom H1 ( along with another half dozen other recorders ) and find while it has pretty good sound for what it is, it has terrible user controls. I think Zoom could sell a lot more of these units if they made the interface more user friendly. ( Olympus and Tascam have Zoom beat by a mile in this arena )
 
I have used the Tascam DR-05 extensively, and the little thing continues to amaze me even for serious music recording... I often plug a lav into it for interviews as well.
 
Well it certainly shows the two zooms have better audio quality, and the others not even that good for speech - imagine somebody having to use them to transcribe all day long? I've now got another HHB Portadisc, as I love the sound of the one I have had for a while, so getting a spare seemed sensible. Loads of people really hate MD, but it's still working for me!
 
John, while it's fine to remind folk that there are better-quality choices available, it's overly harsh to say "ignore this test completely". All of the units you list are more expensive than the cheaper units tested here - a couple are 3x - 5X more. So this test is what it is - it's useful to hear how these low-cost units sound, if for no other reason that confirming that a better recorder is probably worth investing in.

It's not the price - it's that suggesting that a dictaphone voice recorder is suitable for audio recording for video is a bad thing.

The Zoom suggested was designed for such a use, so that was OK, but the Olympus and Sony unit's are not.

The Olympus LS-12 I suggested as an alternative *was* designed as an audio recorder (rather than a voice recorder) for such a use and is a very inexpensive unit at just £129 and is cheaper than the Zoom H2 that was on the list.
 
It is a feasible solution in some situation using those tiny small dictation machines to record voice at weddings. Some might not like it but I have videos to proof it works. I also connect it with wired lav mic to record vows or toasting speeches instead of using wireless transmitter. It works very well too. This is the Same Day Edit where I use the Olympus recorder. The officant's part at the beginning is using a lav mic. The vows from the couple at 3:01 is recorded with the Olympus WS803.
 
It is a feasible solution in some situation using those tiny small dictation machines to record voice at weddings. Some might not like it but I have videos to proof it works. I also connect it with wired lav mic to record vows or toasting speeches instead of using wireless transmitter. It works very well too. This is the Same Day Edit where I use the Olympus recorder. The officant's part at the beginning is using a lav mic. The vows from the couple at 3:01 is recorded with the Olympus WS803.

But the tiny Tascam DR-05 is very small and only £87 - and it was designed as an inexpensive recording machine - not as a dictaphone.

Sorry - if I was paying someone lots of money to video my wedding, I would not be happy if I knew a dictaphone was used.

And I did notice the graininess in your dictaphone recording in the video.
 
It is a feasible solution in some situation using those tiny small dictation machines to record voice at weddings. Some might not like it but I have videos to proof it works.

I don't think anyone is questioning if voice-recorders can do the job, but rather that actual audio recorders might do a BETTER job.
 
I bought the H2n for ambiance recordings in the first place, and it does an surprisingly good job there, especially when set to the "mid stereo" mics.

Also I use it for ADR and voice over/narrator stuff, but with a proper preamp and mic, just as a recording device - I'm quite happy with what I get out of it, especially for the price point. Dismissing it as a dictaphone is a bit bold IMHO
 
Also I have several recorders and getting direct feed from DJ at weddings. Using a pocket size recorder is just one of the ways to get audio. For the past 12 yrs, I never have a single bride come to me saying they are pissed because I put a dictation recorder in their pocket. Those tiny recorders get the jobs done.
 
There are many ways to get great audio. However, its not a studio shoot under a controlled environment. I can only get the best I can do at an event. Just this Saturday at a catholic wedding, the priest refuses to wear lav mic. Can't tap into the house feed. So I mount a h2n on light stand to get close to the ceiling speaker. Not the best sound, but that's the best I can do.
 
I use the DR-05 regularly as well. It's an awesome little device with excellent recording capability and great build quality.

Dave
 
Back
Top