diffuse vs bounce

andycla

Active member
I'm using a 1.2k Hmi's I always used a 96x96 scrim Jim with a 3/4 Diffuser. I'm thinking in order a full white bounce material just wondered if the light lost will be higher or lower. Thanks
 
You'll get MUCH higher light loss on a white bounce. Beautiful, soft bounce, but your output will be significantly reduced.

When I need punchy bounce, but mirrors or silver reflectors are too strong, I tend to just place light diffusion directly over the top of the silver bounce source. Gets you to a nice middle ground.
 
My personal rule of thumb - many will disagree here - is that when you bounce you loose more or less 2/3 of the light output while when you diffuse the light you loose only 1/3-1/2. So diffusing is usually more efficient. One of the diffusion materials that became recently my personal favorite is Light Frost - ot's like a shower curtain but can be stretched n larger frames. A tad sharper shadows than with Light Grid but WAY more output. Recently i used it on a bank commercial on overcast day - we used 1.2s (normally a waste outside as they don't have enough punch but because it was overcast and i had Light Frost i still could diffuse the light and see its effects).
 
There's a video on YT with DP Eric Kress (DP on the Swedish version of "The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo") where you can get an idea what happens when you bounce…. during a demo on a set with a window he bounces a 4k HMI on an ultrabounce outside the window and still ends up at T 2.3 on the Alexa rated at iso 400.

Then in the oposite end we have DP Deakins who often uses practicals, gag lights or augmented light with tweenies…. check out the b-roll on prisoners or check out his forum.
 
Then in the oposite end we have DP Deakins who often uses practicals, gag lights or augmented light with tweenies…. check out the b-roll on prisoners or check out his forum.

However, Deakins mentions often on there that he'll put up a 20'x12' bounce with a 18K blasting into it from outside a window and that be the only light...
 
Mostly its a 5k or 12k ;-) but the point is valid.... It takes a lot to bounce beautifully. And you cant really make it a smaller source and move it closer because it wont be the same quality of light.
 
When I need punchy bounce, but mirrors or silver reflectors are too strong, I tend to just place light diffusion directly over the top of the silver bounce source. Gets you to a nice middle ground.

Old Silver Lame that's lost most it's luster is one of my favorite surfaces to bounce off of. If it's still too punchy just flip it over as the white side is a bit punchier than Ultrabounce.

Whenever I get a new lame I hang it outside for extended period & let mother nature dull the silver.
 
Back
Top