CRT vs. LCD vs. PLASMA

Rick Meyer

Veteran
Hey guys (and gals)-

I know this is a camera forum but I need some help deciding which direction to steer my mother. This is why I am posting this thread in the CAFE. I realize that it hardly belongs in this forum at all....

My mother and I just spoke and she is feeling generous and wants to purchase my older brother a nice HDTV. I'm all for it. She just now saw one on QVC for $1200.00 dollars. It's a 32" flat screen, flat panel LCD model that is HDTV-ready, meaning it still needs a converter. This TV is $1200.00 dollars during a one day sale only. The brand is MINTEN. I have never heard of them. (To it's credit, the TV is feature rich with lots of jacks and a DVD player). And, I hate QVC and the whole lot of those phony smiley faced cheeseballs. Now, before my mother makes this move, I told her to sit tight, I will do some research and get back to her before the one day sale is over. Needless to say, time is of the essence.

I am usually a research whore. I actually enjoy spending hours upon hours reading about what it is that I am going to buy before I buy it. I once spent hours reading about the differences of LCD vs. PLASMA. So, I understand the shelf-life limitations. But, what I am asking from you guys (and gals) is for real-world information about these technologies so I can steer my mother in the right direction, before 11:59pm Eastern time. I say "real-world" because on paper an LCD model and a Plasma model are neck and neck, but a standard def picture on my buddies High Def LCD looks HORRIBLE. Really fuzzy and noisy. Way worse than a regular old cathode-ray tube television. However, this might be his model OR this might be typical. Like I said, I've read about their specs, I just need to hear about actual performance. I wouldn't spend 500 dollars for his TV. The standard def picture is that bad. Though the High Def yankee game was incredible. For my mother, and ultimately my brother, I want it all. A great image in a High Def TV, for around $1200.00 that handles standard def well. Also, what my mother probably doesn't know is that my brother is going to remodel. He is planning on getting a TV that fits on a wall. So, that is a feature that the eventual TV will have to have.

Sorry to inconvenience you with a long post. But, you guys (and gals) have come through COUNTLESS times before.

So, thanks in advance for any input you might be able to offer!

Rick
 
Hey Rick,

I would be more than a little apprehensive suggesting the purchasing of an unknown model from an unknown manufacturer sight unseen. Is this a combination TV/DVD player or is there a DVD player included. If it is the former (combo) I would be even less inclined to consider this purchase.

It would seem that for most people $1200 is a fairly hefty investment and should warranty a bit of consideration. There are in fact considerable differences between any LCD and a Plasma/CRT based TV/monitor. For a mixed application display (computer and video viewing) I would lean toward a LCD as it is a more versatile device, but if the primary viewing is mixed video (SD / HD) then I would lean toward either a Plasma or CRT. The presence of absence of an internal tuner isn't that big of an issue as many people use cable boxes and therefore, don't necessarily need an on-board tuner.

I would suggest not being pressured by this by it today or else sort of promotion and instead, expend the time to do the research that you indicated would be your normal pre purchasing strategy.
 
I would shop around, for a major brand from a major retailer. You're only setting yourself up for dissapointment buying a non-brand tv.
 
rlm7189 said:
This TV is $1200.00 dollars during a one day sale only. The brand is MINTEN. I have never heard of them.

There is a reason it is a one day sale- and it is not cuz it's a hot item. Sounds like a to good to be ture situation, the TV will probably work for a week, then fail, and have to be shipped to china to be fixed, at your expense ....
 
Yeah. I definitely was not sold on it for many reasons. One being that I've never heard of the brand. Though, I have a 19'' monitor from AG NEOVO and absolutely love the thing. Also, I hate, hate, QVC. I didnt want those cheesy bastards to get my mother's money.

I did find another purchase that is MUCH more TV than this unit. It is at Newegg.com. It is EDTV , but is HDTV ready, and I have actually seen this picture in person. Absolutely stunning.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16824187064

And where I live (in upstate NEW YORK) we are probably about 2-3 years away from full HD service anyway. So, I think I will steer her in this direction. Heck, I might consider one myself for one kick ass computer monitor! If only it were compatible....

Thanks for the input guys!
Rick
 
it is a very easy question. LCD with HDTV codec and input! (sometimes it is missed that there is no HD input...)
 
it is a very easy question. LCD with HDTV codec and input! (sometimes it is missed that there is no HD input...) or wait for the next generation of displays
 
If you or your mother want a cheapTV, let me know. Here in Indy we can get 32" Sony WEGA HDTV's for $650 every day of the week -- Appliance Recyclers... Gotta love 'em.
 
Back
Top