Cheap IFB

Nice. Wi-Fi and built in battery are drawbacks. It's too bad they didn't go with the 32 bit float. Most of the useful features are turned off in the US version.
 
Perhaps the just-announced Deity BP-TRX will be an option. It offers an IEM mode, and a bunch of other stuff. $250.

I saw that yesterday. Looks great on the surface, but there are a few issues that will keep me from investing in it:

19ms delay on audio. Yeah, that’s less than a frame but is still significant. I’ve heard the argument that it’s perfectly fine for cam-hop scratch audio, but when your NLE links files through waveform matching you end up with production sound that is also 19ms off.

The internal battery seems to have a decent run time in most uses, but kick the TX to 100mW and you’re pushing it to make a 12 hour day.

Maximum of 4 receivers connect to a transmitter. May be fine for very small productions, but they tout it as both camera hop w/ TC and client IFB while their diagram shows one camera and three IFBs. I often need 6 or more IFBs, and at least 4 time code boxes, if not more. One show I work has 6 cameras on TC.

WiFi systems still have range issues, and I’ve heard that the Diety Connect mic system is not impervious to that.

At this point, I’m just hesitant. Comments on the JWSound Facebook group yesterday called this the killer for the very common G3/Tentacle combo for camera gak. I just don’t see that happening at this point, except for much smaller productions.
 
19 ms is annoying if you are also hearing acoustical bleed, and totally useless live music application. Only four receivers is a serious limitation for most IFB usage.
 
I agree with your caveats about the Deity BP-TRX. But I don't think it's aimed at you and me. I mean, I don't think I'm going to replace Lectro IFB units, or if I used them Zaxcom's... (maybe I'd replace older Comtek units). However, the price is impressive and I think Diety deserves a bit of props for being open about latency/delay. So a couple more thoughts...

19ms delay on audio:
Yes, not optimal. But I think of all the issues with latency on cameras...we've kinda learned to suck it up and deal with it. Most and probably all NLEs and DAWs let you set audio offsets for specific audio channels. Since Deity publishes a delay/latency spec, you can =probably= dial in that setting and handle the issue. Yes, more work. But I guess a general rule is, if you're saving money on production equipment, you gotta be ready to spend more time in post.

Internal battery life.
I'm using 100mW output less often these days. So perhaps (perhaps!) the BP-TRX will last through a day. But you know, at the low price you could consider just changing out whole units at lunch. Yes, that's kinda silly, but if you're trying to get by with a $250 device, well you gotta expect more hassle.

Edit prompted by Alex's comment below (I replied with this, but now this info is inline):
Ya, that's a pain. But I think my original statement about that might doesn't really capture the issue. Consider that so much of the target market for something like the Deity BP-TRX or Connect is probably currently using Sennheiser G3 or G4 systems or Sony UWP with max 30mW output. So if Deity is accurate about 12Hrs at 50mW, that's not so bad. And drop to 25mW, which might be fine for lots of work, then I presume you're looking at a longer battery life. So perhaps for a set of three to four BP-TRX, you'd want zero to one spare units.

Also: with Connect, you can remotely change output levels if needed for a scene or two, and also sleep TX during lunch and when the talent isn't working. So I think for indies paying attention (IPA), they'll be able to get through a day. And even for those not paying attention, the battery life is probably OK.

Max 4 receivers.
That's totally an issue. But you know, on many of my corp and doc jobs, we get by with 0 to 3 IFBs and one or two hops. For jobs requiring more than that, I'll rent and also get fair rental for all units... And I'm already using other more-expensive IFBs. People who regularly do bigger jobs have way more units than I do. Deity's up front about the limitation, so that's good. But like you, it seems like it's probably not a system for me. Could be for plenty of others, though.

2.4GHz/WiFi transmission
Ya, that's a significant issue, I think. But for some IFBs jobs, you're often fairly line of sight and some dropouts won't kill you. I'm curious about how that all is working out with Diety Connect, and hope that potential customers have easy exposure to solid info on the limitations of the system. And again, I'm not thinking this is a product that I'll buy.

Killing off G3/Tentacle gak
Ya, I don't know if that'll happen since that combo is so entrenched. Not saying it won't; just saying I don't know. Me, I'm in the Denecke JB-1 camp, and if I was to update, I'd probably look at more Lectros or the Zaxcom ERX3TCD (and perhaps buy enough for a price break)... But those are about 2.5 to 3 times as expensive as the Diety stuff. Here are some options: https://www.gothamsound.com/product-category/wireless/ifb-systems


So I think these might be viable options for this Cheap IFB thread, but you gotta accept some tradeoffs. Totally worth discussing those tradeoffs and figuring out if they matter to you...
 
Last edited:
I agree that I’m probably not the target market here, practically speaking, except that I think Deity sees it differently. Not sure if you listen to “The Location Sound Podcast”, but Andrew was interviewed for one episode. Seems like he’s trying to push this stuff for all levels of production.

So perhaps (perhaps!) the BP-TRX will last through a day. But you know, at the low price you could consider just changing out whole units at lunch. Yes, that's kinda silly, but if you're trying to get by with a $250 device, well you gotta expect more hassle.

And this is where things get a little silly. So you need to run a production day that passes the internal battery runtime, so you have a second unit on standby to swap out at lunch or dinner. So you have two units for every one you need. So you’ve basically spent $500 per unit in operation. At that point, any claims of price-per-pound have been blown out of the water.
 
Ya, that's a pain. But I think my original statement about that might doesn't really capture the issue. Consider that so much of the target market for something like the Deity BP-TRX or Connect is probably currently using Sennheiser G3 or G4 systems or Sony UWP with max 30mW output. So if Deity is accurate about 12Hrs at 50mW, that's not so bad. And drop to 25mW, which might be fine for lots of work, then I presume you're looking at a longer battery life. So perhaps for a set of three to four BP-TRX, you'd want zero to one spare units.

Also: with Connect, you can remotely change output levels if needed for a scene or two, and also sleep TX during lunch and when the talent isn't working. So I think for indies paying attention (IPA), they'll be able to get through a day. And even for those not paying attention, the battery life is probably OK.
 
I'm Joe small-budget G3 guy and this thing is no good for me as well. I won't use a product with built-in batteries regardless of run-time. I don't trust it and I have no backup. Plus, I'm guaranteed that at some point in time, the batteries are going to go down and I'll either throw it away or have to wait to get it repaired for $248. Batteries are too unreliable.

Wi-fi is a non-starter even for the G3 crowd. Maybe this works for churches and schools. It's too bad. The concept is really nice.

Does anyone have a European price for it? I'm curious if they pay extra for getting the full feature set that is turned off in the States.
 
I'd guess the European price is the same. My understanding is that the simultaneous record-and-transmit feature is turned off in the US because of Zaxcom's patents on that. I haven't dug into why the other stuff is disabled in the US; probably also Zaxcom patents (but just guessing on that). Here's what Deity says on their website:

*Deity BP-TRX units sold inside the USA will disable audio transmission when you hit record. Only internationally sold units will feature the ability to transmit and record simultaneously.

**Deity BP-TRX units sold inside the USA will only output timecode and audio at the same time during TX setup monitoring or when the unit is set to RX mode or Camera Hop mode.

***Run times vary based on RF Output, if headphones are being used and/or if the unit is recording to the micro SD card. Your battery life may vary. Reducing the RF Output will increase the battery life.

****Deity BP-TRX units sold inside the USA will disable the headphone jack when you press record in TX+Record mode or Audio Recorder Only mode.
 
I'd guess the European price is the same. My understanding is that the simultaneous record-and-transmit feature is turned off in the US because of Zaxcom's patents on that. I haven't dug into why the other stuff is disabled in the US; probably also Zaxcom patents (but just guessing on that). Here's what Deity says on their website:

I'll be very surprised if the European price is the same. In my experience European prices are immediately higher because of taxes (depending on country, add about 20%) but then, almost every time, I find out that there's still some additional increase in price, which I can only guess has to do with higher transport cost and/or slightly inflated prices to protect from currency price fluctuations.
 
I'll be very surprised if the European price is the same. In my experience European prices are immediately higher because of taxes (depending on country, add about 20%) but then, almost every time, I find out that there's still some additional increase in price, which I can only guess has to do with higher transport cost and/or slightly inflated prices to protect from currency price fluctuations.

Taxes out of Deity's control. Don't know about distribution costs, padding, and all that. But it looks like Deity doesn't vary prices by region, even when some regions get more features.

Here are the prices for Deity's plug-on TX that can record and transmit (I didn't quickly finde BP-TRX prices for the UK). Can't do both at the same time in the US, can in at least most of the rest of the world.

Deity HD-TX price in US: $249
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/search?Ntt=Deity HD-TX&N=0&InitialSearch=yes&sts=ma

Deity HD-TX price in the UK (from a dealer I hear good things about): £204.99 Exc. VAT
https://www.pinknoise-systems.co.uk/deity-hd-tx-plug-on-recorder-transmitter.html

So a quick conversion on Google says Deity Connect is about $4US cheaper in the US, at least at those dealers right now. Pretty much a wash.

But the key point for our conversation, I think, is that Deity didn't set a higher price for one of their transmitter-recorders outside the US because those transmitters have more features outside the US.
 
Back
Top