Casting/ Auditions - A guide

jpbankesmercer

Director Mod
Casting/ Auditions.

Casting (The first cut)

If time permits, you should always be at the casting. Directing when boiled down to its essence should revolve around working with the Actors. So if you are present at the casting at least you know what you’ve got to work with. Acting itself is not rocket science, (even though it does get shrouded in mystery), a good Actor is someone who is willing, willing to express himself or herself and be open to suggestion. For this reason it’s better not to cast friends and family, (unless they are jobbing Actors), because their motivation will be different than yours, (they are only doing it to please you), it’s always a problem asking someone you know to do something they might not be comfortable with. If you have that Director/ Actor separation you’ll find it easier to stretch the performer. Unfortunately lots of people THINK that they can act, the truth from sitting on many audition panels is, really good performers are few and far between. Don’t get me wrong acting is a skill you can develop over time but for some the thought of being an Actor, (red carpets), and the reality, (waiting around on freezing cold night shoots and only being used for five minutes if at all!), takes time to sink in. People, unwilling to be open and let their soul be laid bare will at some point struggle with more meaningful text. Inexperienced actors also tend to lump all types of performance together, as a young actor myself I thought I could cover everything from presenting to Shakespeare, only through many jobs/ time did I realize as a performer where my strengths did lie. Some Actors are talented enough to work across the board but if your reading this as an upcoming Director/ Producer I would hazard a guess you don’t have the funds to attract top talent, saying that many named Actors have taken on projects due to the strength of a script. So let’s just say for arguments sake that you are working with new talent.


Prep.

Use any journals possible to advertise the casting. On receiving the possible headshots/ C.V’s organize them into who you are willing to cast. Staple the headshot’s to the C.V.’s, (they tend to separate and become a nightmare situation if you don’t), and have the Producer/ Line Producer or Casting ring round and inform them of the casting location/ time slots well in advance. Try and book somewhere quiet and make sure you won’t be disturbing anyone else around you. Ask others who are involved in the project to help on the casting days. I tend to have one person out front meeting and greeting who also handles the contact phone, (people will run late and ring you, you don’t want to interrupt someone during their audition), I also have at least one other person with me in the casting room, to discuss and offer a different point of view and be impartial. Video all of the auditions, it’s amazing after seeing 50 people how much you forget. Sometimes I have even used the performers original casting tape in the finished project. These tapes will be invaluable material for anyone who may not be able to be at the auditions, (exec producers, writers.)
Through experience, as the one who will be working with the performer, I try and get final say on the casting, it’s not always the case but the tapes can help you reach a decision that suites everyone.


The Audition.

When the performer enters introduce yourself and the panel, have a brief synopsis of the project. Personally I always ask Actors to prepare a piece of their own choice, this will give you the first clue on how the performer view themselves, they might pick some obscure text no-one has every heard of before but 9 out of 10 times they tend to choose something they feel comfortable in delivering or is close to their range. After they deliver the piece try and hold back any immediate reaction/ emotion on the delivery and go straight into asking them general questions about their acting experience. This method covers you if they are truly terrible or amazingly talented; remember if you’ve asked 100 people to turn up, it would be unfair to offer any part until you’ve given everyone a chance. It will also save you any embarrassment if someone turns up later that fit’s the part better than you could have ever imagined. It gives them a chance to impress you at a further stage; I have seen many truly bad monologues only to be blown away by further improvisation. Don’t be frightened to stop a five-minute monologue with a polite ‘I’m going to stop you there’, time is of the essence on such days and you will quickly know who is wasting that precious commodity. After some brief questions I do a quick improvisation, (with myself or someone I have brought along on the panel), Actors in general don’t get a lot of feedback on their skills, lot’s of people will say you’re a good Actor to be polite, it’s a strong person who will stand up and say, ‘Actually maybe you should stick to selling Kitchens.’ Trying to make it in such a hard profession, it’s difficult to be objective with the material you choose. Improvisation will give you an insight on how an Actor can think on their feet, (most Actors will be prepared for improv.), don’t be afraid to give direction while their performing, changing emotions and motivations will help you see how versatile they are and how they take to your direction. Try and remember that for the amount of people who are bad at delivering straight-text, the same amount will also be bad at improvisation. Your job at the casting will be to unearth all possibilities with your performers and give everyone a fair chance. Time is short when shooting, personally when on set, I like the Actors to know exactly what they are doing on the day, (rehearsals), a good Actor should excel your expectations and offer you something you never imagined possible. If you have to work with them too much on the day, it’s dragging you away from the other 1001 things you have to think about. Of course you should still be working on the performance but understanding the essence of the character should be nailed to some degree by this point. This whole process should be done within about ten minutes; treat every audition the same, I think it’s only fair to give everyone a good crack of the whip, they might have travelled great distances, changing plans to get their shot at the project. Finally find out their schedules and make sure they are available when you need them.

Finishing up.

After the audition thank them for their time, (still keeping tight lipped), if your interested say so but try not to offer anything until you’ve gone over all possibilities. When they leave briefly discuss the audition with anyone else on the panel and make good notes. Many times I thought someone was right only to be told some relevant information by the panel that has changed things. Keep headshots and C.V.’s together and start a pile of No’s, Maybes and Yes’s. Though be warned, many times I found myself re-looking at the No’s and slipping them back into the Maybes.

If you have the time, clear your head for a few days and get the tapes back. Watch the auditions and make new notes, when finished check them against your old ones, (this should give you a clear overview.) Don't cast someone on looks alone, of course you will have a pre-conceived idea of the character but being realistic about a performers ability will save you lot's of stress in the future. Make sure everyone who needs to see the tapes gets a chance to before you cast, don't offer anything out until everyone have had their say. Then you can start to phone the Actors with the good news, be prepared that they might turn you down! So have a few backup choices ready. Also contact the people who didn't get the part, it's only courteous and you might find that you need them for a project in the future. Good hunting...

This short text is only offered as a practical guide, I’m sure I’ve missed out many things. I am not trying to cover everything or preach, it represents only the basics of what I have learnt working as a performer/ Director for the past fifteen years, I hope someone finds it useful.

Many Thanks.
J.P. Bankes-Mercer
 
Last edited:
Will sticky this thread for a week or two as many of you have been discussing the topic recently. If anyone wants any ideas on improvisation scenarios or any further information about casting ask away.
J
 
Last edited:
Excellent information.

We ran our auditions almost exactly as you suggested and it made the whole process easy and a lot of fun.

Chris
 
Is it possible to have this as a perminent sticky, rather then 1 or 2 weeks. Great resource for us filmmakers, specially the ones who are venturing into doing features.
 
Do you ever have them read with someone else? For example, when would it be a good time to have a female lead and a male lead read together? What about having someone you have chosen to be the lead to read with supporting role actors?
 
I'll throw in 2 cents on this one. I was a professionally trained actor for like 7 years before getting into my current line of work. So I've seen it from both sides.

I basically NEVER want them to do a monologue. It's never done me much good to see that. For film work, I am pretty much always more concerned with how they think on their feet, and how good they are at making choices of their own as soon as they get the material. And I want to see that they are not afraid to look foolish. So I like to see how the react with no prep, can they jump in and go for it, or are they rigid and nervous and afraid to fail.

I also often have them improv, generally with other actors involved with the project. Again, mainly I want to see how much they can think on their feet, be spontaneous in the moment, and let their imaginations go with whatever situation is on hand.

But personally, for my work, I never really want anyone acting. I tend to cast the person for who they are. So mainly what I look for is that they can be who they are in an imaginary circumstance, rather than "play a character."

My 2 cents.
 
Guys
Thanks for your kind words...


DesperateComfort…
The basic approach above for me covers everything. The monologue gives you a quick insight into how they see themselves and the Improvisation gets their brains working.

If any Actors are already attached to the project, I would suggest using them to unearth dynamics and chemistry but there is a minus point to this; you could find yourself in a position where the lead Actor on the panel refuses to work with an individual for whatever reason, and begin to take on another role rather than performer in the scheme of things. You then get into uncharted territory and your personal vision of the project can be compromised at very early stage.

I too also look for the individual and try and cast as broadly as possible. Your point of imaginary circumstances vs. The Character is an interesting point I feel needs to be discussed more, fancy starting a thread on this topic?

Lipster.
It’s always a valid point to have Actors read from script that you’re going to be working on. Personally I tend to keep away from this approach as I find that in this situation, (10 min slots); their understanding of the subtext/ sections out of context can lead to a bad interpretation.

Having someone that has acted before on the panel is priceless, (saving you doing it), you want to inject positive energy into the sessions, having a Producer lamely trundling through the lines can be a burden.

I like to get the script out at the rehearsal process; If you really want to explore Actors together you need more than ten mins, the above text relates to the first casting session, making a cut and getting everyone back for a second more-in-depth day would open up this opportunity.

J.P.
 
Last edited:
jpbankesmercer,

Yeah, I would love to start another thread on that. Later though, as I am just shooting this off and have to run.

I didn't mean to say that stuff as a challenge to your aproach, but more as an addition to the conversation on casting.

And, if the actor won't work with another actor? You mean, we can't just lock them in their cages and deny them food until they do our bidding? Phshaw!!! :)
 
DesperateComfort.
Look forward to your thread, I am trying to generate more involvement in the Directing section, any additions would be greatly appreciated.

Honestly I want to generate discussion...

Actors...They are our slaves!!!...I'll try the cage approach...
 
jpbankesmercer said:
Will sticky this thread for a week or two as many of you have been discussing the topic recently. If anyone wants any ideas on improvisation scenarios or any further information about casting ask away.
J

this is a really good thread jpban. it would be great to keep it as a sticky for longer than a week or two. im sure lots will find this info useful. thanks :thumbsup:

as an additional it would also be great to have some info on how to handle callbacks.
 
Last edited:
This is a great thread, thanks!!! I was wondering though, as i hear some directors prefer not to give a script in advance to an actor. Than what ends up being the selling point to the actor if he doesn't know what film he is reading for? Is it the size of your mattbox???
Also i have heard people say that part of the dialog is taken out, or the ending or variations of that, before showing the script to actors? Does this make sense? Should the synopsis alone be enoch for someone to be interested???
 
my two cents.

In the past six months I have auditioned for a Coca-Cola commerical, and a quality budgeted 16mm dramatic short that I am directing. Prior to that, I shot 7 indie shorts, and prior to that, I was in the theater world, casting and directing plays. Prior to that I have been a SAG actor all my life (tho I don't act anymore!) and have seen the flip side of the audition process.

The first thing I found amusing when auditioning was exactly how little I knew what I was doing. I always assumed as an actor that the casting directors and director had some master plan. Hah! Usually they go by looks, which is the worst possible thing you can do.

Over time, especially with the Coke commercial I co-directed and this latest peice, I have really taken the saying "casting is 80% of your movie to heart."

My tips:

-don't get frustrated if you have to see 300 people per role. Fact is, them's the odds, if not worse.

-know, at the very least, an element of what you are looking for. The tone of your film. What it is about. If you can come up with one active word for you film. For example, my last film, I said, it's about "rebuilding." Then you are on your way.

-Then, in the first audition, forget about monologues, or any of that crap. Most actors will come in with a pre-conceived notion of what you are looking for. This can be good or bad. Usually bad, because they have some weak idea and a second rate performance to back it up, and they can't adjust. The most important thing is to see YOUR RELATIONSHIP with the performer and see if they can take your DIRECTION. After all, that is the meat of it. Even if their first read is perfect and what you want (like you know), you still should try and get them to go somewhere with you. Because that's the real point of it all, isn't it?

You'll find that most actors out in LALA land just can't adjust in an audition. They are scared, they have excuses, they have a world of jargon from an acting class to use as a verbal sheild to avoid the truth.

-I, personally, am up front with actors. I don't pretend to be extra friendly. I want them to know that this is who I am, and this is what I am looking for. If that's not what they want, then they shouldn't do the project.

-I, personally, dig into people for some real story that relates to that magic word that I am looking for. And I mean dig. They're actors, if they really are prepared to dig, then good. You know how many times I have had someone tell me some real horrific story in their life, then when they read the scene, it's fake again. They can't even tell the difference between the truth and falsity.

-The one acception to digging is real pros. Some like to dig, some don't. Digging into someones past is one technique to evoke true reactions, but some can do without it. You have to judge.

-Read up or study as many different acting techniques and theoretical examples as possible. You need to speak the many different languages of the actor. From meisner to aristotle. No matter how stupid you may feel it is, you'de better know it. Saying "do it louder" ain't gonna get you very far.

-don't take any excuses. The number one thing I hate is when an actor reads, then they pout afterwards. "Oh I just didn't feel it." Well, what if I did? Would you say that to someone interviewing you for a job? No, it's stupid. It makes me think worse of their performance. Perhaps I saw something they didn't. I usually nix people right away when they say that.


But again, must important of all, know what you want :) You're not browsing for any old car, you want that 57 chevy with the perfect engine!
 
Addendum to previous post. I always videotape everything now. I make the conditions in the audition room as close to my tone as possible. I don't take notes. I look at the video. I mantain eye-contact the whole time. Usually, for a first audition, if I can, I go in for tight close ups, and I have them sit and just talk. In call backs I add in action.

As for sides. I prefer they read something I prepared, not come in with a monologue (this differs for theater). I really don't care about the words at this point. I care about the truth. And I always try and throw them a wrench, flip their performance around, see if they can work with my direction.

And if an actor starts asking a million questions about their character (not just one or two) in an audition, and you feel that you have explained it clearly and suffciently. Then tell them no more. They are looking for a crutch. Trying to fall back on their dimestore actors training :)

can you tell I have an opinion on this matter? Well let me tell you, Coke = 300 auditions in 3 days. Latest project, I literally scoured the earth to find the perfect lead.
 
Where can i find templates for auditions? Like a comprehensive form for actor contact info, special skills, availability....

Thanx

Jon:costumed-smiley-047
 
Nice and truly helpful post zoostory

I haven't gotten into the procedure of making a movie yet, but have taken small classes on acting first and then directing, since then, I've been studying on my own by reading books and making small projects using my friends. Things will get alot more serious towards the end of this year->begining of next when will I start pre-prod. on my first short when the script is finished.


But again, must important of all, know what you want :) You're not browsing for any old car, you want that 57 chevy with the perfect engine!

I've been reading acting books lately and one that has really won my heart is: Harold Guskin's: How to stop acting

It has a really nice segment regarding auditions and how does the "preparation" work for both the actor and the director. It says alot about the actor not having pre-conceived notions of what the director wants and to- more or less disregard the outlining and instructions on the character found on script drafts, the fact that directors are people sensitive to what they see and sometimes they really don't know exactly what they want until they see it. The result of the actor's "suggestions" to the character is what can really win an audition. I find this concept quite interesting in the way I'll handle my future auditions, it really opens things up a bit in my view. But I'd really (everyone) like to hear your take on this.
 
I like both monologues and sides from my scripts. The monologue is something the actor's prepared, and may give you a window on how well they can do with something they've memorized, and how well they can get into character. I also have them read a scene from the script in the show for which they're auditioning. I give them some time to read over this before performing (most wait around for a good bit of time before auditioning, since I normally have lots of folks in for an audition), and tell them a little about the character.

I feel that this is quite important. I don't expect them to be Brando on a cold reading, but I do like to see that they have some insight into the character they're auditioning for. I've seen lots of actors who, upon doing the scene, obviously have no idea who this character is.

As for improv, it's not that important to me. Why? Because I don't want them improvising during the shoot. I give them some freedom to tool with the dialogue, but I want it mostly as written. I don't care how quickly they can think on their feet, either: I care how well they can dive into a character and make it real on camera.
 
Guys I will keep this a sticky for a while longer, I will also re-edit the original post, with additional information callbacks-reading from the script + more.
Keep adding information and together we can form a concise overview of the subject.
I originally intended this for the learning director. Please feel free to add your own experiences.
J.P.
 
desperatecomfort said:
I'll throw in 2 cents on this one. I was a professionally trained actor for like 7 years before getting into my current line of work. So I've seen it from both sides.....


But personally, for my work, I never really want anyone acting. I tend to cast the person for who they are. So mainly what I look for is that they can be who they are in an imaginary circumstance, rather than "play a character."

My 2 cents.


I have an actor friend, who is the most annoying person I know. He tries to be funny, but seldom is. He is never well kept, any I don't ever recall him to EVER have a girlfriend. He was into making films, and everyone I had ever seen was unwatchable. He has gotten slammed, at film festivals, on his films. His response is always, " I did this to force every to watch me and my stuff for the last 5 minutes!"

All that being said, I would never want "that" in my film.

This past week, I did a casting call, and he showed up.
Mind you, this guy is a S.A.G. actor. Not expecting much, I went through the normal process.

He nailed the lead character, who is charming and quite the ladies man in the screenplay. This guy became my character with no traces of his own lacking persona. That was quite a shock. He had this character down on so many levels that we are turning it into a SAG production just to use him.

For me, I don't want my actors to be themselves.
From what I have seen, the best actors generally are outcasts.
 
Back
Top