Can a Steadicam ever mimic a jib?

First, as I'm slowly making my way over from stills, I'm new here so hi everyone!

I currently use a Camcrane 200 jib with my HDSLR and it works pretty nicely. The problem is that it takes a looong time to set up and take down and, like any jib, is pretty bulky if using in tighter spaces. I also travel a lot and the crane can't come with me. I'm thinking of supplementing it with som kind of Steadicam-type stabilser (possibly a CMR Blackbird) for when time and space are a little tighter. My question therefore is: can a well balanced and skilfully operated Steadicam (I wouldn't be skilful but I know the importance of learning to be so!) get anywhere close to approximating a short jib move or is it just going to look rubbish? I'm not expecting 100% jibby loveliness but how close can it get?

If a handheld effort is a 0 and an actual jib move is 100, where do people think that a Steadicam approximation of a jib move would fall?
 
I think it can with a very limited range. A Blackbird stabilizer only lets you get the camera so low then the other limitation is how high you can raise it with your hand.

so the range would be greatly limited.
 
Back
Top