Boom Poles USELESS?

Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Well, I am getting the AT 897 for sure, maybe I will go for a cheaper boom pole instead of the gitzo and save money for a windscreen
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

[quote author=Mike_Donis link=board=audio;num=1086126687;start=15#19 date=06/02/04 at 14:30:03]It is the artist, not the brush...
[/quote]

Yeah, but some brushes really do suck.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

HAH! :)

Yes, that is true. I've told the story many times, but one of Rick Parks' most impressive artworks that I ever saw was a simple portrait he did ON AN ETCH-A-SKETCH. A real artist can make anything sing... but they also appreciate the best tools too. Storaro with an old Super 8 camera would smoke any of us with our DVX's... but how often did he shoot with Super 8? He chose top-of-the-line 35mm gear every time...
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Wasn't it more impressive in your mind BECAUSE it was on an Etch-A-Sketch and you know how hard it must have been?
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

[quote author=David Jimerson link=board=audio;num=1086126687;start=15#23 date=06/02/04 at 15:41:09]Wasn't it more impressive in your mind BECAUSE it was on an Etch-A-Sketch and you know how hard it must have been?
[/quote]

Good call...I'd agree!

But to be fair, and I'm kinda going back on the whole artist/brush thing, we DO all want the best possible quality :D

But the fact remains, you can't make chicken salad out of chicken ****! You still gotta use your stuff to its potential...
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Yes, it was definitely more impressive because it was on an etch-a-sketch. However, it was a work of art in its own right, far superior to anything I could do with pen & paper, or brush & canvas.

You need good tools, yes. But that's only like 10% of the equation. An important 10%, but not what your sole focus should be on. Give a bad tennis player a $6,000 racket, and his game won't improve an inch. Give Agassi a badminton racket and he'll still whip me. But, Agassi would never use a badminton racket -- being the pro that he is, he'd use the $6,000 racket and he'd get the most from it.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

But seriously...it is going to suck when you are in the field holding a 10 pound aluminum boom pole that saved you 100 bucks before you start shooting....would you not want a carbon fiber pole that allowed you to shoot longer...come on guys seriously..I know it is not the tools - but you don't buy a plastic hammer now do you?
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

[quote author=Barry_Green link=board=audio;num=1086126687;start=15#25 date=06/02/04 at 16:06:04]Yes, it was definitely more impressive because it was on an etch-a-sketch.  However, it was a work of art in its own right, far superior to anything I could do with pen & paper, or brush & canvas.

You need good tools, yes.  But that's only like 10% of the equation.  An important 10%, but not what your sole focus should be on.  Give a bad tennis player a $6,000 racket, and his game won't improve an inch.  Give Agassi a badminton racket and he'll still whip me.  But, Agassi would never use a badminton racket -- being the pro that he is, he'd use the $6,000 racket and he'd get the most from it.[/quote]

BiZARRE. I wrote -- and deleted -- a post about my friend who could whip me at tennis every time with a badminton racquet, but that doesn't mean he'd use one. WEIRD.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Hey Kyle,

Of course carbon fiber is the preferred pole among professionals. But 10 pounds? Come on... ;)

I've got an 8' aluminum pole here, it weighs maybe a pound. It's perfectly usable, and while a carbon fiber pole would be more comfortable at the end of a 12-hour shoot day, it's not like a night-and-day difference. If all the guy can afford is a $60 aluminum pole, it's a totally reasonable choice, and sure a lot better than a painter's pole...
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Don't feel bad for him for having to use an aluminum boom pole--I'm using a dremeled piece of pvc pipe.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

that every one here will feel good , a friend of mine that doing off bollyvood indy films in India using long bambook stick for that perpes , he carry 3 different lengh of sticks for different situations.
 
http://www.imdb.com/name/nmRe: Boom Poles USELESS?

http://www.imdb.com/name/nmRe: Boom Poles USELESS?

Boom poles are far from useless. What if you want to be on the long end of your zoom lens and your subject is 25 feet away? Your camera mic is also going to be 25' away. A boom mic is as close as your framing allows, maybe 6" or less.
What if your subject refers to something nearby and you pan your camera to get a shot of it? Your camera mic turns away too. A boom mic can stay over the subject as he/she continues to talk.

You can check out my credits at http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0128644/
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Bryan-
You held a boom for the Power Rangers rock on man!!! I used to watch that show all the time LOL!!! ;D
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Not to beat a dead horse, but...

That's just about the dumbest thing I've ever heard.  I used to be a boom man (among many other things), and for most things it's absolutely essential.  Sometimes you have to use a wireless lav for dialogue, but in general you want to avoid those because they're a little too chesty and they pick up clothes rustling.  Even with the best shotgun, you want to be as close as you can be with the mic tip right on axis with the actors' mouths, and the boom pole also lets you pivot or sweep the mic between actors during the scene.

For news gathering/doc stuff:  here's an example for ya.  I was working for Hard Copy years ago, covering Fantasy Fest in Key West.  We came upon a wedding happening on the dock just about at sunset.  There was a crowd between us and the bride and groom.  The shooter got up on a chair or something and zoomed in.  I had a very, very long boom pole, and was able to reach right over the crowd and get the vows.

Ask your friend to ask his professor how he'd get that sound without a boom pole.  Sorry, no time to go over and wire them--they're in the middle of the ceremony already.

Either your friend seriously misunderstood his prof, or his prof's a moron.

A.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

OK, Power Ranger lovers... did any of you ever watch the series called "Power Rangers: Light Speed Rescue"?

Do you remember the Blue Power Ranger named "Chad"? Well, his real name is Michael Chaturantabut (goes by Mike Chat) and he is the founder of XMA (Xtreme Martial Arts).

There was a Discovery Channel documentary on Martial Arts which originally aired last November which featured him and one of his students... http://media.whatcounts.com/century/xma/gallery/email.html#

There is also a commercial for Degree deodorant featuring him in sort of an old Kung-Fu movie spoof fashion.

I work directing and editing his DVD-based curriculum. In fact, I'll be flying to Orlando, FL at the end of June to shoot behind the scenes stuff for a documentary on XMA.
 
Back
Top