boom operator - best way to feed audio to?

matthewd5

Veteran
what do people do to feed an audio signal to the boom operator?

i mean do you feed him from the mixer and he wears hedphones?

i've seen "cable snakes" where they have headphone cable included and it seems to want to feed a headphone signal from the camera back to the mixer?

in a small shoot is the boom person also working the mixer? and where do you get the third hand grafted onto the boom operator so they can hold the boom and adjust the mixer?

in the past i ran a headphone amp off of the rca's on the dvx (www.headphone.com) and a headphone extention cable to a spare pair of sony 7506's

matthew
 
I prefer that the boom op has their own local mixer with there own headphone amp. That way their direct feedback is based upon their actions. This short path tends to give them better information on what they are doing and hence they usually do a better job.
 
but then why have another mixer after that?

i'd be afraid to introduce too many things in the connection.

too many points for failure or mistakes.

i'd love to see an inline box that passes along the audio signal untouched but let the boom operator hear the signal so they know how they are doing.

i saw some box that sort of did this but it looked like it gave the operator crude controls over the signal level.

i guess i'd rather have one really good mixer at the end of the cabling than to have other mixers/controls between the "good" mixer and the mic.

matthew
 
The consequences of the mixer are fairly benign, it is the mixer's preamplifier that is more likely to have its own characteristics. With a pre/mixer at the boom opperator's position, you can send a line level signal to another mixer (thus avoiding the second pre stage). There is a possible advantage to this technique, specifically, a line level signal is going to have less supseptability to common mode noise sources than a mic level one simply due to the difference in signal amplitudes (this will be more of an issue with longer cable runs).

What in the end will determine if this approach has any down side to it is the quality of the per/mixer at the boom. If it is good enough, then I would expect no ill effects while still providing the feedback to the op.
 
Search around B&H (or some other audio store) for headphone preamps. Simple box that cost a hundred or two and allows your boom op to listen to the signal as it passes thru at mic level onto the mixer. Some, like the SD MM-1, do amplify the signal but a straight headphone amp will just allow boom op to listen.

There are other solutions but that will probably be your cheapest one.

Cheers
 
matthewd5 said:
i'd love to see an inline box that passes along the audio signal untouched but let the boom operator hear the signal so they know how they are doing.

i saw some box that sort of did this but it looked like it gave the operator crude controls over the signal level.



matthew

That's a duplex sysetm. A duplex system is a hardlined system that has a couple of things going on. First, it sends the mic signal from the mic to the mixer (which is usually another person at a sound cart). Then, there is a return signal from the sound cart back to the boom op. The boom op wears a little box about half the size of a pack of cigarettes called the duplex box. The boom op can plug the mic and his/her headphones right into the box. The mixer back at the cart controls the volume. The mixer will have a private line of talkback to the boom op so they can communicate with each other.


-dave
 
Dave's suggestion is best, but I did this with an SD-MM1 and that worked. The mm-1 gives you mic-in, line-out, and monitor (communication / return feed)... plus stepped gain control as well as independent control over the headphone out plus monitor level... which can be used simultaneously or not. That was a cool little box and I sold it to another member here when I got a Mixpre (since I never have the luxury of more then one guy to do sound)... and about a month after he got it he bought a 302... so it's possible that he may part with it. The unit was bought in September of this year and I sold it to him for $300 (unit was brand new) and he may sell it to you for the same. Let me know if you're interested and I'll call him.

The mm-1 would allow your boom op to change the gain prior to your real mixer via a small, stepped control... but I can't believe you'd have a guy running the boom that you couldn't trust. unless you make it clear to an inexperienced boom op he might play with the levels. From my limited experience you shouldn't chase the levels as if you're trying to maintain a specific db... you just watch the peaks and averages and make minor adjustments if an actor gets out of control either way.

The benefit of the independent headphone and monitor levels for the boom op is he won't be tempted to anything stupid to get the level he wants in the phones... he can just turn play with the dials that are for him instead.

Dave am I nuts here? Wouldn't this be a good solution for a prosumer approach and also a lot cheaper then a duplex system?
 
The standard approach for a one man sound department is for the soundie to wear a harness to carry the mixer at his waist. The mixer has complete control of all audio inputs and outputs. Stereo signal is fed to the camera by a 'beta snake'. This cable has 2 XLR's for stereo and 1/8" connectors to take a return feed from the camera headphone circuit back to the mixer. There is usually a quick disconnect in the line near the camera.
The mixer has several headphone controls. One control gives stereo, mono, L/R listening. Another control gives a choice of listening to the mixer directly or listening to the return feed from the camera or cameras.
A carbon fiber pole can be one handed fairly easily for short periods of time to make minor adjustments to level. Once levels are set, most effort goes into booming and if loud noises are expected then the mic can be lifted instead of levels adjusted.
If you think that is tough, try putting 6 wireless into a bag system along with a boom. Reality shows do it all the time. But then those soundies actually have experience and know what they are doing.
 
Based on xort's post... that's why I sold the mm-1 when I got the mixpre. The only difference in my kit and the above is I use a recorder in the soundie (like that term) bag as well... and then instead of a snake to cam and return I use a wireless for guide track to cam which also lets me hear what my (usually low experience) boom op is doing. If it wasn't for the digital recorder I wouldn't be able to eliminate the snake unless I wanted to trust the wireless for everything and that isn't wise.
 
As for the wireless to camera, I use two lectro 195D's on occasion from mixer to camera and have had excellent results. I do wear headphones at camera to make sure nothing is wrong.
 
Xort,

You should check out the zaxcom stereo ENG system. It's made to go wireless bag to the camera. It's only one system, instead of two, which means one less transmitter to deal with, and the camera op will love only having one reciever on his camera. I always recommend a comtek for the wireless return. Digital drop outs sound different than analog ones, so if you get a hit, you'll know where it was.

-Dave
 
I've been using a Comtek for my boom op to monitor. I've got a bit of a convoluted setup where I can talk to the boom op (he can't talk back). While I know the boomer doesn't get perfect sound this way, can anyone think of a problem with this kind of a setup? (If you're looking to get into this type of setup, you can get used Comtek equipment from Coffey pretty reasonably. You can get an Rx and a Tx combo for about the same as Matt's used MM-1).
 
Holy Cow! Why didn't Dave say so! I thought I was doing it the cheap way! Dave's got over 600 posts, we know he's a "real member". Include prices in your advice... I think it would be more helpful and this time I'd have kept my mouth shut.

C'mon Dave... plug the store when it's appropriate.
 
for return setup you even not need the comteck , every small tx which can transmit on fm channel ( like these for ipod ) and get return on stereo fm receiver
since i use this system , i dont even use the return signal , just place the headphones on the camera operator , so if he dont like it , we work with cable , guess what answer do i get:-)
 
better then comtek you can use regullar g-2 evolution , the benefit , you have better audio( comteck cut everything above 12 khz) and you can use the same tx/rx for aditional wierless if you short on one .
comtek (small portable tx is only 10 mw) , the base station have more power about 100 , but you cant place it in the bag
 
Back
Top