Been getting more and more calls for lav plus booms together

scottfs

Well-known member
I do mainly dialog recording for docs, shorts and an occasional feature. For some reason, I have had newer directors want me to use lavs on the talent as well as a boom mic. These are indoor and outdoor shoots.

I do have both, but I hardly ever use them together. I much prefer the sound of my AT 4053b over lavs. When I use a lav, I just always seem to run into sound falling off when the talent turns slightly, or the clothes rustle when they start getting animated, etc. Am I just behind the times? Are film schools teaching the use of multiple sources, assuming every indie sound guy has an unlimited budget to mic multiple actors?
 
It's common to use both in many productions and decide later which source works best. Sometimes you'll use both. Of course in some situations only certain microphones will be used. Sometimes audio may be so important that crews may not only be capturing it with multiple mics, but may be padding/bracketing the audio levels as well.
 
This is a trend that is happening in low budget productions (or people that have been trained with lower cost productions) where there is a minimum of crew or time.
Its far easier to use multiple mics and record them all as ISO tracks and sort it out later, multi track recorders, wireless systems etc have all come down in price and it makes it easier to do this style of shooting.
In the 'old days' when there were only 2 tracks available to you then you had to make 'critical' decisions on the shoot when it came to sound.
I have on occasions done the same on commercial TVC shoots where a director wants to do it one way and I want to do it another, I will multi mic and ISO record and then say 'tell me which track you use in post production... I will NEVER reveal which track has which mic... Let them decide then come back and tell me which was used, doing it like this make the Director / Producer ACTUALLY listen to the sound and when they come back just say 'Thats the one I thought you would use'.
It confirms your knowledge of what you are doing is the right way / choice of mic.
 
I've been recording lav and boom wherever possible for decades, it was the first thing I ever learned about audio. Over the years, it has saved my bacon more than once. Boom almost always sounds best but when there are ambient issues, lavs save the day.
 
I echo the above comment. Boom mic for primary and lav as safety. If you do event stuff with a fixed mic at a podium, still lav (wireless) in case they walk away while doing their presentation.
 
Nothing makes me more nervous than recording anything with only boom or only lav. If you have issues, you have no respite. Lavs rub on clothing, booms pick up rumble, wind noise, handling noise that often cannot be heard while in the field with headphones in noisy environments. Choice is always a good thing.
 
Its far easier to use multiple mics and record them all as ISO tracks and sort it out later, multi track recorders, wireless systems etc have all come down in price and it makes it easier to do this style of shooting.

Actually it shifts the work to post. If you don't do sound post then unfortunately a lot of pict editors know almost nothing about sound and will use multiple tracks all over the place and you get horrible phasing issues (that then get blamed on the production mixer).

In almost all cases I think it is a bad practice with very few real benefits. In a few cases it is done for a reason with wonderful benefits.
 
I'll frequently have a conversation with the director and producer (and if lucky, include audio post), make my recommendation on the best way to proceed, and then do what they want. Usually, they follow my advice. Sometimes they don't; in those cases I still try to deliver the best tracks possible. And I always leave sound reports for post (including which ISO track(s) is/are boom :-), which lav).

And from a producers perspective, especially for low-budget docs and such, it can make some sense to go with lavs. Often different mixers at different locations facing different audio challenges with different equipment and different skill levels... Decent but different lavs decently placed can end up providing most consistent sound, ime.


Are film schools teaching the use of multiple sources, assuming every indie sound guy has an unlimited budget to mic multiple actors?
Basic kit usually includes a boom, two wireless, and a mixer (though often now a mixer/recorder). Charge production for extra equipment, including extra wireless.
Ya, easier said than done on some jobs...but don't drive yourself into debt and out of business by doing "favors" for clients (super-close friends are s
 
As I read the posts on this and other forums, I realize that the way sound is recorded for films has changed drastically in the last 10 years. Before inexpensive 4-6-8 track recorders, decisions had to be made and the mix between different sources was done live during the shoot.
You did it once and did it right or not at all. These days, it covers more bets and allows decisions to be made in post if there are several sources on iso tracks to choose from. I am in the middle of the dialogue edit for the micro budget indie that I recorded, and having the dialogue (and trialogue?) on both lavs and boom does save much bacon. The boom (MKH50) almost ALWAYS sounds better and more "real" than the lavs (Countryman B6 in this case), but the lavs can work better when there is lot's of ambient noise (traffic, air conditioning) and poor angles for the boom op. Oddly enough if actors are close and talking AT each other, the opposite lav often sounds better, as it's close enough to the speaker and not picking up the chest resonance that can make the lavs sound muddy. Matching the boom to the lav is tough however, and although I seem to get pretty close, it's dicey to cut between boom & lav on one actor in one scene unless the shot change supports it visually. DP's and directors don't like to stop to wire up an actor if you find the boom's not working, so just planning on both seems to be the path of least resistance and more the standard.
 
Nothing makes me more nervous than recording anything with only boom or only lav. If you have issues, you have no respite. Lavs rub on clothing, booms pick up rumble, wind noise, handling noise that often cannot be heard while in the field with headphones in noisy environments. Choice is always a good thing.

Me too... boom/lav split... almost every time... even on 1-head. Groups typically get ISO on everyone and boom to the right, or on a "hidden" channel in the ISO, while talent lavs split the LR mix.
 
I love it when non-sound people dictate how the specialist does their job, but appreciate that it's probably from a previous project when their audio was less than ideal - and the idea of 'just in case' sounds good. It's fine as long as the budget can cope with this. It's not fine to expect more kit and effort for the same money.
 
I love it when non-sound people dictate how the specialist does their job, but appreciate that it's probably from a previous project when their audio was less than ideal - and the idea of 'just in case' sounds good. It's fine as long as the budget can cope with this. It's not fine to expect more kit and effort for the same money.

Standard boom/lav split when I hire pro sound mixers to shoot simple things like single talent standups or interviews. But of course it gets more complex when you have a three camera/two person interview or a sit down round table narrative thing. When I hire pros, I leave it to them unless I want something unusual or the situation as far as blocking and or camera location is an issue. When I handle audio, it's typically either single subject interview and I boom/lav or lately I have been shooting skits with actors and non-pros and that all has to be wireless only as it's three camera and the wide shot precludes booming it. Another thing that drives my sound mixers crazy is that they invest thousands of dollars into a beautiful Sound Devices 3, 5, 6 or 8 track mixer recorder, go through all of the effort to record and separate all of the mics on the talent, carefully mix and ride gain, hand it all over to the producer and then later discover, in my line of work which has a lot of EPK, junkets, BTS on TV and film sets and documentary, I would say that their beautifully clear, nicely mixed audio only gets synced up to the video shot perhaps 20% of the time. 80% of the time, the production company uses camera audio only, they are too cheap, too hurried and too clueless to use the good audio. Drives me crazy too. When I hire a sound mixer and I edit, which is not that often, I always use and sync the multi-track audio that was recorded on a $5,000.00 recorder over the junk .99 mic-preamps and crappy, sub-par audio sections that are found on almost every video and digital cinema camera. But most producers and editors are fairly uninformed about audio and just use the camera audio because it is too much effort to sync the good stuff.
 
Last edited:
Standard boom/lav split when I hire pro sound mixers to shoot simple things like single talent standups or interviews. But of course it gets more complex when you have a three camera/two person interview or a sit down round table narrative thing. When I hire pros, I leave it to them unless I want something unusual or the situation as far as blocking and or camera location is an issue. When I handle audio, it's typically either single subject interview and I boom/lav or lately I have been shooting skits with actors and non-pros and that all has to be wireless only as it's three camera and the wide shot precludes booming it. Another thing that drives my sound mixers crazy is that they invest thousands of dollars into a beautiful Sound Devices 3, 5, 6 or 8 track mixer recorder, go through all of the effort to record and separate all of the mics on the talent, carefully mix and ride gain, hand it all over to the producer and then later discover, in my line of work which has a lot of EPK, junkets, BTS on TV and film sets and documentary, I would say that their beautifully clear, nicely mixed audio only gets synced up to the video shot perhaps 20% of the time. 80% of the time, the production company uses camera audio only, they are too cheap, too hurried and too clueless to use the good audio. Drives me crazy too. When I hire a sound mixer and I edit, which is not that often, I always use and sync the multi-track audio that was recorded on a $5,000.00 recorder over the junk .99 mic-preamps and crappy, sub-par audio sections that are found on almost every video and digital cinema camera. But most producers and editors are fairly uninformed about audio and just use the camera audio because it is too much effort to sync the good stuff.

I've gotten phone calls/emails/texts asking why the audio was so bad on the "third cam/wide shot/5D" many times... Clean two ch mix to the real cams and even timecode ISO tracks and the idiots still try to use the scratch/nats from the DSLR... Lazy stupid editors that ***** when they aren't spoon fed. Reminds me of waiters/waitresses that get pissy when they have to come over to your table and take your order. It's your job!
 
It really depends on the job. For sit down interviews I've done a boom and a hardwired lav (no need for wireless) if I'm getting paid the rental on the equipment. Other times I've gone strictly boom because lavs just weren't needed. If you trust in your boom op (or mic on a stand), then it's a non-issue.

That being said, if the client asks for lavs and booms at the same time, I'll politely say "well we only need a boom, but if you want a wireless system in there and the budget covers it we can do that". Why fight extra gear rental?

You are getting gear rental for your stuff, right?
 
I've gotten phone calls/emails/texts asking why the audio was so bad on the "third cam/wide shot/5D" many times... Clean two ch mix to the real cams and even timecode ISO tracks and the idiots still try to use the scratch/nats from the DSLR... Lazy stupid editors that ***** when they aren't spoon fed. Reminds me of waiters/waitresses that get pissy when they have to come over to your table and take your order. It's your job!


Wow, what painful editors to deal with.
 
Wow, what painful editors to deal with.

Yep. And it seems like for every good one, there are at least 3-4 bad/lazy ones.

Not an audio related story, but a great example of how bad/lazy so many of them are:

Producer calls me almost a week after the shoot and asks if we had shot our main subject interview on another card and it may be in another folder on the drive. I tell them NO, it was all on one card and in one folder on the drive and I checked the drive before they left with it AND I saw it when I did a back-up copy at home. They call back later and said the editor has looked through the bin/folder on the system several times and can't find it. I had the card with me and hadn't wiped it, yet. I pop it in the deck and check it, just to cover my @$$ and it's there, so I tell the producer it has to be on their drive. Producer grabs the original drive, goes back to their computer and of course, it's on there. The idiot editor didn't ingest everything. Producer was even more pissed than me after that, so bad that they called me just to vent about the editor.
 
Actually it shifts the work to post. If you don't do sound post then unfortunately a lot of pict editors know almost nothing about sound and will use multiple tracks all over the place and you get horrible phasing issues (that then get blamed on the production mixer).

In almost all cases I think it is a bad practice with very few real benefits. In a few cases it is done for a reason with wonderful benefits.

This is a key consideration. I read through the thread to see if it was picked up. If you plan on mixing the boom and the lav you have to zoom every take and match up the wave forms or you will get greatly diminished frequency response. It is a lot of work, and if it isn't done you're going to get honkey audio with little bass response.

If you choose one over the other, this is not an issue, only when mixing them together.

I do narrative stuff and we always do both. I like to mix them when they're both clean, but don't underestimate the time and effort.
 
Personally I boom 90% of the time and use my second camera channel to do a back up of that track at a lower volume.

I only lav when there is a need..

teacher teaching and cam swinging between teacher and learning pupils?.. lav the teacher.

tour guide talking, camera pointed at the scene in front..? lav the tour guide

I hate the rustles, fiddling inside womens tops and all the problems of lavs..
 
This is a key consideration. I read through the thread to see if it was picked up. If you plan on mixing the boom and the lav you have to zoom every take and match up the wave forms or you will get greatly diminished frequency response. It is a lot of work, and if it isn't done you're going to get honkey audio with little bass response.

If you choose one over the other, this is not an issue, only when mixing them together.

I do narrative stuff and we always do both. I like to mix them when they're both clean, but don't underestimate the time and effort.

It is very hard in a NLE to get them phase free since very few make shifting audio by less than a frame easy.

The plus side is I have had a number of people come to me in desperation because the sound is so bad and basically I just needed to clear up the phase issues to make a vast improvement. It's pretty boring work but it's not rocket science and it at least gets them doing some sound post ;~)
 
I don't worry about sound issues, really, unless it's a speech to a group of people, where I will lav the speaker (can't stop them and have them so it again). I monitor stuff really, really closely, and I'll stop an interview and adjust a lav. And I'm REALLY REALLY careful not to get myself into a clothing rustle pickle. I did once, and had an hour and a half interview ruined by clothing rustle.

If you are using a wireless lav for a feature, it's more problematic, obviously, but hopefully you have enough time to redo a take if there are sound issues.
 
Back
Top