AT897 vs. the NTG-2

balrais1

Member
I'm looking to get a shotgun mic for interviews (close range) and the like and while I'd love to get the AT4073a, I'm going to wait a little while.

What I'd like to know is, if we rate the 4073a a 9/10, what would the at897 and ntg-2 be given???

I ask cause the forums say that the at4073a is pretty much the benchmark mic for its price. Now how do the rest compare. I need to get one quickly so I appreciate your input.
 
I'm using an NTG-2 on a 16mm short atm. It's an awesome mic, highly recommend it. The only thing I can compare it to is the AT835 (which imo it is superior to.) But if you have the money, I hear the 4073a is the way to go.

A lot of sound has less to do with microphone and more to do with microphone placement.
 
Dave_Fisk said:
Between the 897 and the ntg-2, I'd go with the ntg-2.

-Dave

Dave I hope you don't me asking, but what about for having the mic on camera for run and gun, would you still go with the ntg-2. I'm interested in video journalism. thnx
 
Rasquachemedia said:
Dave I hope you don't me asking, but what about for having the mic on camera for run and gun, would you still go with the ntg-2. I'm interested in video journalism. thnx

On camera? On a scale of 1 to 10. The Rode will sound like a 2 and a Sennheiser MKH60 (best short shotgun IMHO) will sound like a 2.25. :thumbsup:

I personally have only heard some recordings with the Rode and never actually played with one yet but would recommend it over the 897.

Best.
 
wabbit said:
On camera? On a scale of 1 to 10. The Rode will sound like a 2 and a Sennheiser MKH60 (best short shotgun IMHO) will sound like a 2.25. :thumbsup:

I personally have only heard some recordings with the Rode and never actually played with one yet but would recommend it over the 897.

Best.

The Rode and the Sennheiser getting a 2 and 2.25 out of 10?? That's is quite the low score. I can tell you that I have a 4073a. I heard some tests and couldn't resist. I love it. I absolutely love the mic. However, in certain situations, its pickup pattern is almost too good. It is very directional and excellently picks up voices, BUT it can pick up the rumble of the crowd a mile away. So, I guess, it goes to show different mics really serve different situations.
 
Sorry rlm,

I was trying to be humorous in pointing to the mounting the mic on camera as the weak point. The low score was for the location of mic, not the mics themselves. :grin:

Did not mean to mislead.

Best!
 
Dave_Fisk said:
Between the 897 and the ntg-2, I'd go with the ntg-2.

-Dave

I agree with Dave. I like the Rode mics and find they have a good amount of flavor. They are a little bottom heavy (lows and mids), but they are excellent mics.

The biggest difference between these two mics, from my experience playing with them, is really simple: The name on the mics.

The other difference is the 897 I find to go more to the high end (mid and high) and NTG2 to the low end (mid and low).

I have used Rodes in the studio and love the sound, they are a great company and don't get talked about all that much in the film sound aspect.

Finally: if you have the funds, look to a higher end shotgun. The camera mounted angle is not the real route you want to go, get closer = get better sound.
 
ExileOnTheMainStreet said:
the 4073 would get 1.2if it sits behind the French flag and 2.2 if its not


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAA.. oh man. that was funny. at least I thought it was funny.

Anyway...

In your situation, I'd go with the Rode mic.

-Dave
 
Hi- I'm also looking around for a mic - I'm doing 5-10 minute art videos, and my work is often run & gun, so the mic has to be on the camera. Luckily I'm usually pretty near my subjects with the camera, so the mic is only 3-4 feet from the subject. I'm inside half the time, outdoor half the time. I was thinking the AT897 was the way to go before I read this thread & the recommendations for the Rode ntg-2. I suppose I need a good shockmount too - any recommendations? I see that evsonline doesn't carry the Rode mics - where you recommend buying them? Would the Rode ntg-2 be the best in my situation?

Sounds like the Octava 012 is too sensitive to be mounted on the camera, the 4073 is too sensitive for indoors... and I'm too poor to own more than one mic!
Any thoughts on this would be appreciated!
 
Well, I am also looking for a shotgun mic so I can dress my second camera. I don't want to spend $550.00 for another 4073a. I love this mic but for my budget, one is enough. I'd like to take any savings that I am looking for and applying it elsewhere.

I am fairly settled on the RODE mics. Just a quick question pertaining to this line of mic, what are the major differences of the NTG-1 vs. NTG-2?

Also, check out these two links at B&H.

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/con...747&is=REG&addedTroughType=categoryNavigation

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/con...806&is=REG&addedTroughType=categoryNavigation

I am having a hard time spotting the differences between these two mics. Can anyone else see it?

Is it just the SM3 - On-Camera Shockmount for Shotgun Mics? If so, is the extra $20.00 dollars money well spent?


Thanks!

Rick
 
Back
Top