Anyone switching from FCP

Yep. I tried Premiere this week and weekend. I am giving it a good try. So far I am liking it. I probably won't abandon my older version of Final Cut though. I'll just use the tool that's right for the job.

All in all I am just using all the tools I can learn. (Avid, FCP, CS5)
 
When I switched from Premiere to FCP in 2003, the main reason was because of stability: FCP 4.5 was a stable workhorse, with an excellent uncompressed 8bit codec that I could work on, and it hardly ever crashed. It "just worked". So did the Powerbook G4 I had it working on. After that, I went all Apple: Powermac G5, then Macbook Pro, then Macpro. With this came FCS, FCS2 and FCS3, all improving upon its predecessor. Introduced Prores, worked like a charm with my HVX200 P2 file system, and I could trully concentrate on improving my editing skills, my creative skills. Red Giant Software also helped immensely with Magic BUllet, first with editors, than with Looks. I could finally deliver the look and feel of what I wanted from my edit to the Davinci and Smoke professionals close to what I wanted the piece to look. Much easier to communicate with a draft that looks the part than having to do an lenghy explanation to the colorist with "I want this to look like this and that". Of course, you still need to sit through the colorist through grading, but having a guide for him to aim to is much less time consuming (and less costly) than going empty handed or wwitth a crappy looking draft.

FCPX is not ready for primetime broadcast work, this is a given. And my main problem with switching is not learning the new editors, per se, but losing the stability and robust editing environment of FCP7. I'm going to try both the new premiere and Avid out, but I really hope the nightmare of ghost frames, out of sync audio due to software vs hardware incompatibilities, etc don't return... I'll stick with FCP7 in the meantime, but I intend to go and purchase an Epic-S and am seeing myself going to Premiere because of the Red friendly workflow. I really, really hope the unstable days of Adobe software are gone... Because Avid MC 5.5 is still 32bit, and somehow feels like its still software from the FCP7 generation. It doesn't make much sense to me to invest in a software that is about to be updated...
 
Back
Top