Advise: Should I go audio?

Dmitry Kichenko

Well-known member
Hello, everyone!

I've been here occasionally for quite a while now, mostly since I started to look at film making more seriously in terms of personal interest and gear I'm using. I've always been curious about all sorts of video equipment, but lately I had another thought about it all. I've been into audio and music production as a hobby for a long time now, and I thought that maybe I can get into industry as a sound designer/composer/audio related specialist.

My observations tell me that a lot of indie film makers, first of all, spend the big bulk of their cash on the camera, and audio is where people start saving on.

I was thinking, how realistic would be to go with sound for film?

As opposed to the camera, I spend my savings on a good portable audio unit (something like a Digi 002 or maybe the new cheaper clone M-Audio ProjectMix, which will of course mean I'm buying cheaper A/D converters + Pro Tools M-Powered just in case), a powerful laptop, good mics for various applications, and some other things. With such setup I could record seperately for later mixing with the video, and also record things like SFX, foley, etc.

I just decided to post this to find out if there is indeed a demand for a dedicated audio person out there. From my personal point of view and judging from the experience I had so far working on films, it makes sense to have one on even a simple production to at least keep the director relaxed and knowing he's "got the sound covered".
 
Well congrats on evaluating your options. I will answer simply from a personal opinion and preface that by saying if you look at my 1000+ posts at least 500 of them are in the audio section. In at least half of those posts regarding sound purchase options I have always advocated the rental of equipement of the hiring of a sound person.

That being said, having the tools does not make you a sound professional. Does buying a racecar make you a racecar driving? Does buying a wooden bat make you a baseball player? Does going to college make you educated?

I think you get my point. For my larger projects (anything with a substantial budget) I will always hire a sound person. I hire people that I know or people who have a body of work that I trust. I have some equipement, so what someone brings with them isn't number one on my list. What matters to me is someone who can evaluate my audio needs and find out how they can best improve that. I want effortless audio on my behalf, I don't want to have to worry about it or be concerned about it.

I think your interest in audio needs to begin, if you are hoping to move in a professional direction, with less lofty goals. If you look at most of the people here, enthusiasts and professionals, they all started with an interest in sound. From that point they moved forward and started doing projects (normally their own) and then moved more towards the professional side after they had aquired substantial experience.

If you emailed me the kit of what you just had and no resume of experience I would not hire you for cash. I'm not trying to be rude. I'm being honest. Kit doesn't matter as much as experience.

Another thing to consider is what the budget levels of most people you are targetting is. Like I said, on any project I do with a budget, I will always hire someone. My projects with budgets are one to two a year, and for my next project I already have the sound person I'm hiring lined up (well not 100% but within the next three weeks I will).

What I'm trying to say is simple: if you are interested in moving forward with sound start putting together a kit. Network locally and volunteer on projects to gain experience. From that point build a resume and a reel of projects you have worked on. Learn your trade and then start to move forward. I have been doing sound for over a year and I know nothing. I have purchased a lot of gear, have a nice looking expensive kit, and I know each piece of equipement inside and out. I could quote specifics on every item until I'm blue in the face. I have read and own almost every book on the subject of audio. I have been on the set on professional projects and just watched the sound people work trying to learn. I volunteer at the local news station to help out with the sound people just to watch them work and learn more about ENG recording techniques. I still know nothing compared with more experienced users or professionals here.

I don't want to discourage you by any means. I'm just trying to present things realistically.
 
yankee, i think this guy is asking if he should take the plunge into the audio world, bulk up on equipment and knowledge and basically become a sound guy. i personally don't know the relative supply/demand for sound guys but if it's something you want to do for a living i'd say forget it. as far as i can tell, the best way to make money is with weddings and corporate video. and both those are more image driven.
now on the other hand, if you want to get involved in indie features, most people seem to want to be director's or dp's, sound is much less glamorous but it's just as important though neglected.
 
brianluce said:
now on the other hand, if you want to get involved in indie features, most people seem to want to be director's or dp's, sound is much less glamorous but it's just as important though neglected.

I don't know how much I agree with that comment (your other comments could be correct, in which case my very verbose reply was completely off topic... in that case I am sorry). I think that most directors/producers in the indie world think that they can do the photography, editing, and directing themselves, but they look outside for sound. There is a need for sound people, and while it may not have the glamour it is one of the most important elements.
 
Yankee - that's what I was talking about too (that a lot of film makers look out for sound people outside).

Of course, I'm assuming I will not only have the gear to offer. I will need to gain the actual knowledge, and right now there is not much I know about audio for film. My knowledge so far is more in the actual composing and editing, the "post production" side of the process. And also since the "standard" seems to be Pro Tools, I don't have any experience with it either (I personally use Cubase and Live for most of the work which of course isn't film related, it's just composing).

Gear only would, I think, help me to get into the budgetless projects which was my intention. I'm of course not expecting the gear alone to get me far.

Thanks for the valuable response. I appreciate the approach you took with it, which is what I attempt to do myself most of the time. To be realistic about things, that is.
 
Well if you are looking for a kit in general here are two threads that I would recommend:
http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=34334
http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=35667

If you are looking for general information regarding sound recording read these:

http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=32875
http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=38183

If you want to know about recording theory and information about audio read these:

http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=40410
http://www.dvxuser.com/V3/showthread.php?t=21535


These threads will take you about an hour to get through and will give you a headache with how much knowledge you will gain. These are the most valuable resources to get started with.

To say that you want to move forward with sound without any knwloedge about it is weird, to say that least. If you are serious about it contact Oleg, Ty Ford, Dave Fisk... ask them how they got started, where they got training, and what path they suggest for you.

As far as software and post production sound and composition, well that is a whole other issue. Protools is the industry standard and nothing will ever compete with a full on TDM system as far as gear lust it inspires.

BUT there are alternatives. Cubase is an excellent piece of software and the association and implementation with VST instruments is priceless. This is a good place to get started, but thats a start. Live is good, but I prefer other pieces of software.

So far it seems like you're a bit all over the place. The professionals I know, if your goal is to become a pro, are very specialized. They record and mix. They do post production. They produce music. They master. They do foley. None of them do it all. With professional status, you can be good at a lot of things, but a master of only one. You can't be a master at all. This is why you see a lot of the enthusiasts here being good at a lot of things but never saying they are masters at all

Find out what you want. I have studio experience and I can tell you mastering a mixdown, balancing channels, and creating that perfect sonic blend is an artform. Furthermore there are lots of programs available if you choose the studio route to get education in this field (I don't know how old you are or what sort of education you have to compliment experience).

I can say this though, to think that gear gets you into projects where you can support yourself finacially is just not right. I will say it again, the people I hire and turn to for projects that have a budget (I would never do this myself, I'm not experienced enough to risk my sound to my talent) are experienced. They have my trust, and trust from the director or producer is the most important thing that a sound person can bring to the table because it is built upon experience and technique.

If you are looking to get started buy yourself a mixer (a cheap Behringer will work), a hyper cardiod mic ($175 Oktava will work), and a shotgun mic (read my sub $1000 shotgun review under the Audio Tutorial thread and take your pick). Get a painters pole and just start playing around with the levels and recording technique. Then start to build to a kit, add a portable mixer, a portable recorder, shockmounts, boom poles, quality cables, wind protection, lavalier microphones, wireless kits, cardiod microphones, studio microphones, 5.1 mixing cards, software such as Sound Forge, Protools, Wavelab, Nuendo, sound blankets, audio reflectors, run bags, headphones, amplifiers, preamplication mixers, and every adapter you can purchase.

Rome wasn't built in a day and you can't master audio by not doing it. Experiment, who knows, you might discover a new way to record audio that no one has ever thought of like implanting a mic onto someone's vocal chords. See what you can come up with, but keep asking questions.

The most important thing I can say is don't take no for an answer. Don't let anything that I might have said, that anyone else might say, or anything anyone might say discourage you from doing this if you are passionate about it (then again if you are doing it just as an easy way to get into creating art, then you're saddly mistaken. Audio people are treated like crap by most people for the reasons that Brianluce mentioned). If your intentions are to learn and move forward, well then you've already taken a great step forward and I wish you the best of luck.
 
Thanks a Lot for the somewhat unexpectedly extensive amount of information, hehe.

Film doesn't interest me as a highly paid industry, brainluce. I know it sounds somewhat childish, but I would probably settle for a lower wage as long as I'm doing what I love. And those are a lot of things linked with film, sound in particular.

As to the gear, I'm not sure I want to go with a mixer, Yankee. I mean, it makes more sense to go digital right away for me, I think. It's just more convenient to have an audio unit with multiple inputs (preferably with good converters and preamps of course, but I'm not sure I can afford a Digi 002 right away) where I can plug everything in (the more balanced preamped inputs the better, I'd presume) and after recording - mix everything as I'd like to.

Of course, you can't be a master of everything. But that holds more true when you're on a big budget film, doesn't it? When you're dealing with a "free pancakes" kind of production, I think I'd be lucky enough to have someone hold the pole for me, leave alone master the audio.

As to the knowledge in general, of course I'd like to know as much as possible. My knowledge so far has only involved working with hardware and software synthesizers, samplers, and other gear, composing various music with those, and mastering it all together. I am a student, so I still have a choice of the future career. There are a number of schools which teach some forms of sound/music production (from the relatively simple even for me "Cubase+Live+Reason" at a local college to the sound design in Vancouver Film School), but they are all pretty costy. I am not sure how valuable the knowledge I'd gain at school is, but one thing for sure - I'd meet at least a couple of people as dedicated as me to work on films together with. Still yet to compare pros and cons for the school..

Anyway, thanks once again.

Joe - yeah, that's what everyone around seems to be saying :). I wish I could know for sure that I won't end up without a job on the street providing various sexual services for crack, hehe.
 
Back
Top