416 vs. AT835b

vidled

DVXuser Sponsor
I've said this before, but I still think the AT835b gets a raw deal around here.
For the money this mike really isn't that bad.

Here's a quick'n'dirty comparison between the AT835b and the 416:

http://pig.us/835b.wav
http://pig.us/416.wav

(each file about 20 seconds long; 2mb file size)

Okay, not a very substantial test, I agree, and all I wanted to see/hear (for myself up until now) was the difference in sound quality "appearance". This test does NOT include any side or rear rejection comparisons, and it was recorded in a small room.
For the money, and for someone on a budget, the AT835b really is quite an acceptable choice IMHO. The pro audio guys/gals here are a little too hasty sometimes in suggesting the $500+ options as the ONLY acceptable way to go (short of hiring a sound person).
An AT835b (or possibly other mics in similar price category) with some little bit of experimenting/practice can yield quite good results for the beginner with little money; at least FAR better than the cam's built-in mic. And then once it is outgrown (in a year or two) it can be sold on eBay and upgraded to a better mic.
I just don't see the need in investing in the BEST equipment right from the start, especially when money is tight for most who just start out.

Having said that; that 835b is long gone, and the 416 is MUCH better, naturally, but not only because the audio quality, but BUILD quality too; something OFTEN overlooked and not mentioned here at all. The 416 can handle moisture and other tortures VERY well; so much so, that I take one on every shoot.
 
Actually the only mic that is constant disrespected around here is the ME66. The rest is just getting what you pay for and everything else you said applies.

Cheers
 
"disrespected"? LOL, I like that one! :)

Actually the 835b gets beaten up also - and compared to the ME66, quite unfairly me thinks.
 
The only, But very important, drawback of the 835 is it's length...
too long for a camera mic, and if you put in in a windshield, its too big and heavy on a long boom.
 
Almost more than that, the 835 and the 835b have that LIVE AT FIVE breaking news sound signature. I have one, used it, abused it, and know the mic pretty much through and through. For filmmaking purposes it is not suitable and in an A/B test the Rode sounds better.

Still, this is comparing the Civic ($19,000) to the Hyundai ($19,000) to a Porsche ($100,000). It just doesn't make sense when people are looking for performance and quality to suggest a Civic when the Porsche is what they need.

Ultimately I believe that Audio should be 70% of the experience. Therefore if you are spending $3500 on a camera (this is DVXUser.com afterall) then you should be prepared to spend at least $5000 on audio :)

-Jeremy
 
Jeremy,

Please tell me how I can get away with only spending $5000 on audio. :-) I've probably spent twice that much already, and I still have a ways to go. And I'm not even pushing up in to the upper echelons yet...I have yet to spend $4,000-$15,000 on a recorder even. ;-)

Okay, I know, I still need to get a life...but I just bought a BDS for my bag and I'm taking out for a road test tomorrow for a project. Yay!

Phil
 
C'mon my misguided Hebrew Brotha!!!

I'm just making a point that when people come here after dropping $3500 on a camera and then ***** about a mic running them $500 I just want to take a fat $hit in my hand and then throw it in their face, mush it around a little bit, and then laugh... and then go wash my hand (I believe in evolution, so maybe there is some monkey still in me or something).

That being said, the best audio comment was made by MattinSTL when he said:

You are eating Ramen noodles for a month thinking to yourself, wow this microphone sounds amazing.

That is the world of sound... Ramen F*cking Noodles!

-Jeremy
 
Well I guess I'm on the right track then because my audio gear costs about 25% more than my video gear. I'm a writer/director first and foremost, but I've seen one too many independant films (particularly short films) with just horrendous sound. Some even sound like *gasp* they used the mic that came with the camera! Good shot composition and all other aspects of the visual side are honestly not that hard to learn. But good audio? That's what I realized would set my film apart. Well, and a good story of course.

I honestly think a desire for good audio is a sign of maturity as a filmmaker. Your typical independant filmmaker is as arrogant as all get out. They're the next Speilberg. They're the next great undiscovered talent. That may be so, but it's ultimatley all about me, me, me. Those who stay in that realm don't last long. Filmaking is about us, us, us. As a director, yes you're a leader on the film, but you must also be a servant to all as well as to the story. You have to acknowledge your own shortcomings and bring others around you who can help.
 
mmm, i dont like 835b. used em quite a bit, but they're long and newsy sounding. both points have been mentioned.

vidled, ill tell you why most people suggest mics in the $500+ range straight off the bat - it saves you money in the long run, and it gets you learning on gear that doesnt inhibit you from the start.

a lot of the pro folks here have climbed up the ladder in the way you suggest (buy cheap, sell, buy medium, sell, buy high), but I dont think there are many of them (us) that dont regret that approach.

at the end of the learning process, you have spent more than if you'd bought good in the first place, made more crummy sound mistakes that are crummy gear based, and maybe even ruined a few films because "well, azden sound pretty good to me".

i dunno, if i could go back, i would beg borrow or steal and just buy a SD442, CS3e, Schoeps 641 and some lectro's. but thats not how life works, is it?

so yeah, its not a bad mic, per se, i leave that category for azden alone, but it definately is worth what you pay for it (i guess thats good or bad).
 
I think the reason you don't hear much about the 835 is the 897 is a better boom mic for almost the same price. The concensus is the Rode is prefered at that price level but that is a choice best left to the individual.

Cheers
 
Jeremy, if you ever carry out your revenge plan for people who complain about mic $$, would you please make sure you post video of it for the rest of us?:)
 
Back
Top