10 bit 4:2:2 external recorder

4

4k2

New member
Hi,

Until now, I have been getting by with 8 bit 4:2:0 recording on my Fujifilm X-T30, but I think it is time to go for 10 bit 4:2:2 external recording (I am getting a noticeable amount of banding and compression artefacts)

Solutions for recording externally, are fairly expensive. But I believe it is because not only are they recorders (e.g: Atomos Ninja V), but they are as well monitors. So you are paying 600$ for a "300$ monitor and a 300$ recorder" They are as well standalone (no computer needed)

I frankly do not need the monitor, though. (Prices are overwhelming, for those as well)

Some options require an external computer but are fairly cheap (e.g: Blackmagic Ultrastudio mini. A new version has recently come out for just 80$) The problem with it is that is records 10 bit, 4:2:2, but only at 1080P.

Is there any other budget-friendly option for 4K external recording? (Maybe the Elgato Cam Link 4K can do 10bit 4:2:2?)

Thanks.
 
I can understand wanting to save money but honestly the Ninja V is what you should get. Maybe if you elaborate on what you're trying to do. If it's a home studio situation with proper lighting there is no need for 10bit. Things like Elgato compress the signal so it defeats the point of 10 bit.
 
Yep, but having options for under 100$ is tempting... (I use the camera for filmmaking, mostly interior scenes)
 
Get the Ninja V. You think you don't need the monitor but you will wonder how you lived without it. I have the first generation Blackmagic Video Assists in 5" and 7" and simply love my Ninja V.
 
I´ll get it then. The problem is that as far as I know, accessories cost more than the product itself!
One more question: Is there another option but just for 1080p recording? (maybe a bit cheaper :) )
 
Last edited:
@QuickHitRecord; Just got the ninja star NEW (Without the box opened and with no signs of use) for 140$. It included a 128Gb+64Gb CFast card. Works superb recording F-log 10bit 4:2:2 from my Fujifilm X-T30. It doesn´t record 4K, but for what I´ve paid I can´t definitely ask for more.
 
I'm sure you know but if not...you need to set the camera to output the 10-bit 4:2:2 in the menu...meaning it doesn't just do it by plugging the cable in.
 
@NorBro; Thanks for the heads up. Although as far as I know, please do feel free to correct me if I´m wrong, the only option in the menu that compromises whether or not a 10bit 422 signal is output is the "HDMI OUTPUT INFO DISPLAY". When turned off, videos will be output to the HDMI device in 422 10-bit format. (page 152 in the user manual)
 
If that's what it says in the manual then that's definitely how they do it.

Basically most of these lower-end cameras just need to limit or change the processing in order for the hardware to do it (or allow us to do it).

In non 10-bit Sony stills cameras, internal recording is disabled when 422 is on (still 8-bit though).
 
:D That´s the trade-off for buying low-end cameras... Although they are getting better and better each year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top