Best format to edit for FCE

K

kookooframe

Well-known member
I am about to send some of my Super 8 films away to be restored and converted either into files or mini-DV tape in HDV format. They tell me that AVI files are easier to edit than HDV files, and AVI is four times less compressed. So I was wondering if I should ask for AVI files instead of HDV? I shoot with a Canon XH-A1 so I usually edit HDV on Final Cut Express (Mac G5 non-Intel), and would probably be mixing in some of my HDV video with the restored film footage files.

So my question: should I go with AVI? I do like mini-DV as a storage medium. But is AVI worth the quality if I can get it? This company is doing a restoration to hi-def quality of my Super 8 stuff -- at least, as hi-def as they can get old Super 8 to look. Once I get the AVI files, would it be that big a hassle to put that raw footage onto mini-DV tape anyway?

One more question -- if I decide to send them an external hard drive to put the AVI files onto, any suggestions as to a good cheap one under $100 that works with a Mac G5?
 
Final Cut Express doesn't edit avi files.

In fact, all it is is a container, not a codec.

And it doesn't provide any better format for HD editing.

AVI will not work.

A QT format will work, but you need to discuss this with whomever is doing what they are because they are clearly a Windows shop.

Look at the Final Cut Express page at Apple's site to discover which QT formats are best for FCE
 
Hmm, all this worry about file compatibility...I'm now inclined just to ask for the Super 8 film transfer onto DV tape in HDV format. Can't beat tape for archiving. But would I lose that much compared to a file when it comes to compression? I don't plan on doing a whole lot of effects with this stuff, basically just want it to look clean.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top