Round 10 - DVXUser Photography Challenge

Steve_Arm said:
But take care with voting as not to run in the same problem that shawneous encountered. Try making your vote decision under 24 minutes, after that you are automatically "kicked out" from the server, due to inactivity. That's something I can't change for now.
Click to expand...
Excellent job on the system!

Just to be clear though, can we vote for some of the pictures and then come back and vote for others, or do we need to vote for all of them in 24 minutes?

Chris
 
Great submissions! I expected more entires -- but congrats to all who entered! Voting today was way more fun than the voting a lot of us will be doing tomorrow. No lines to wait in either! :)
 
all voted! really good stuff.

I was confused by two things, though, which would be nice to see addressed for next time:

1) what to do with images that had NO manipulation between the original and final. For these I decided to simply not vote on the two "processed" criteria, but I'm not sure if this was the right thing to do.

2) I noticed there were some really nice images that really didn't seem to fit the theme at all. I think it'd be good to have a rating for how appropriate to the theme the image was. As it was I simply rated these images 2-3 points lower than I otherwise would have, but it made evaluating the image more difficult.

Anyway, lots of good competition!

edit: answered my own question... voting ends Nov 10.
 
With the manipulation that is up to personal opinion.

Furthermore, when it comes to theme, if something doesn't fit the topic at all, and this is personal opinion, I would rate it a 0... Just like if something is out of focus.

Voting is personal though.
 
Great photos everyone.

Steve:
The voting looks/works great, one "issue" I had was that when I was voting I clicked on a picture to refresh my memory on how one looked and in doing that it blow out all my votes. Maybe you could have the pics next to the voting drop downs bring up a new window when clicked or not be clickable. Just an idea.
 
Nr. 1:
I think this is a flaw from the submitters, since the second entry is supposde to have some processing. Anyhow this isn't an issue since the categories are independent from each other.

Nr. 2:
I think that were a lot of entries that didn't much the theme... I would rate each image as an image by itself.


dougspice said:
all voted! really good stuff.

I was confused by two things, though, which would be nice to see addressed for next time:

1) what to do with images that had NO manipulation between the original and final. For these I decided to simply not vote on the two "processed" criteria, but I'm not sure if this was the right thing to do.

2) I noticed there were some really nice images that really didn't seem to fit the theme at all. I think it'd be good to have a rating for how appropriate to the theme the image was. As it was I simply rated these images 2-3 points lower than I otherwise would have, but it made evaluating the image more difficult.

Anyway, lots of good competition!

edit: answered my own question... voting ends Nov 10.
Click to expand...
 
jeremytuttle said:
Great photos everyone.

Steve:
The voting looks/works great, one "issue" I had was that when I was voting I clicked on a picture to refresh my memory on how one looked and in doing that it blow out all my votes. Maybe you could have the pics next to the voting drop downs bring up a new window when clicked or not be clickable. Just an idea.
Click to expand...

Yes you are right since all data in the form are not submitted and are lost. I'll open a new window.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top