Seriously considering RODE NTG-2...!

petelms

Well-known member
Hello!

I have been seriously thinking of getting RODE NTG-2 mic. That would be my first shotgun mic...so I have some questions...here they come:

1.) Does anyone have here Rode's own boompole? Is it any good? Should I get it also? And of course, deadcat also...:) Anything else I need? Here's a link for that boompole: http://www.rode.com.au/?pagename=Products&product=BoomPole_-_December_05

2.) Is it "possible" to use this shotgun mic also indoors? I mean, I have to do some indoor interviews soon, so would it be ok to use this Rode shotgun in that kind of setup? I have read that shotguns are mainly used outdoors...is this true? Or is it best to use lavs always in indoor interviews? Is shotgun picking up too much sound of the room space?

Thank you! :dankk2:
, Pete.
 
Hey Pete...

1. I don't like Rode poles. I don't like how they expand and they don't seem to be very durable. A buddy of mine picked one up as part of a kit when he got an NTG1 and the pole is just garbage. After a couple of uses the locks became worn down and now if you have it tilted it slides. I prefer the Gitzo poles but a lot of people here prefer the Lightwaves. Beyond these brands you're talking serious cash.

2. This has been discussed ad nasseum. You can use a shotgun inside, but you will not get good sound from it. Use a hyper cardiod mic for interiors. The shotgun will capture a lot of reflection because of the directional pickup pattern and will cause a reducation in the sound quality you are working hard to get.

The NTG series is a good microphone and I consider it a good choice for an entry level shotgun. I prefer the NTG to the AT897 but don't rank it in the same ballpark as the 4073a or MKH416. Ultimately you are going to get a looser pattern, more emphasized low end response, and not as solid rear rejection.

This does not mean it is a bad mic, in fact I like mine a lot, but I only use it for high risk situations.

Sound quality wise though, the ME66 is a better sounding and more useful shotgun microphone, it is also almost twice the price, but that should give you a pretty fair benchmark for how the NTG series ranks. The only reason I rank the ME66 higher is the rear rejection and tighter pattern.

That is the only really big problem with the NTG series, the loosness of the pattern and the rear rejection is pretty bad.

It is a good mic, but something you will outgrow quickly.

-Jeremy
 
Hey, Jeremy. :)

Thanks for your comments, really helpful. I know I should have done more searching. I was lazy amd tired. :(

Now, I think you changed my mind about Rode...hmm...You said it well: "It is a good mic, but something you will outgrow quickly." I'm now thinking of getting the Sennheiser 416, although it's much more expensive. But, I am dead serious when it comes to the audio stuff, I have a home studio, but don't know so much about the "sound for the video" yet. The thing with Rode was that it's so cheap, and I need mic soon...I think it's better to wait and get the Sennheiser...damn, it's going to be expensive, but...

Yep, then hyper cardioid is the way to go for interiors. Please, could you tell me some examples of good hyper cardioid mics? I know, I know, you hate this question, I read it from another topic, but I really don't know more than one hyper cardioid mic at the moment: OCTAVA MK 012. What people are using? What is for example comparable quality hyper cardioid mic to shotgun mic Sennheiser 416? TOP-5 hyper cardioid mics sticky would be so cool! :Drogar-BigGrin(DBG)

At the moment I have RODE NT2-a, and it is cardioid also...so is there much difference between Hypercardioid and cardioid?

, Pete.
 
Last edited:
hey pete,

the 416 is way better. "its so cheap" generally turns into "i hate this stupid thing" in a couple of months, sometimes even after one shoot! :)

top 5 hypers would be a bit tricky, because the majority of people use the oktava (in amateur/semi-pro sort of jobs) or the schoeps cmc6 mk 41 (which is what the pro's use - very good, but very expensive, more than a 416). then there are the few odd people who use the akg or sennheiser modular systems with hyper capsules, but i really think that number is getting less and less as people discover how kick ass the oktava is.

ill put this in perspective for you: on M:I 3, the sound team used primarily schoeps mics. but for action scenes there was a risk of expensive mics being damaged. so what did they turn to? the oktava. cheap enough to be expendable to a big budget film, but also good enough for less critical work on a FEATURE. so its a really cool mic.

do some research into polar patterns and you'll see there is quite a difference between hyper-card and card mics... mainly rear lobing, and directionality. but im not the best person to tell you the tech on polar patterns, yankee is good at that.
 
Technically Matt is great at patterns as well as Wabbit. I hate looking at charts and just use my ears.

I've been talking with one of my good friends lately about my mic situation (as it ties in with some personal issues) and I'm rethinking my entire sound kit now. For me personally, I have a lot of microphones because I enjoy hearing the differences in the quality of each microphone. It sounds weird, but I get a kick out of listening to the differences and it matters to me.

Three days ago I have 2 MKH416's. Hopefully by tomorrow I will have none (I'm down to one right now). While I love the 416 for what it is, a great sounding, highly directional, tight mic... What I love more than anything about the 416 is the name: Sennheiser MKH416. It screams professional (to me at least). The problem for me is that the Sennheiser is twice the cost of the AT4073a and the difference isn't that significant.

As I have stated and shown in A/B tests, the 416 has a tighter pattern, slightly better rear rejection, better off axis rejection, and a more neutral tone. This sounds like a lot, and could and does very well justify the difference in cost. The problem with this is that at the end of the day the sound quality difference when fully mixed just isn't there fore me. At this point, thanks to some advice from a friend, a lot of soul searching, and a login to Bankofamerica.com I have decided to stick with the AT4073a as my personal shotgun of choice.

OK, enough of me rambling...

Now onto the bigger issue. Hypers.

There are a couple of hypers out there that could work for your specific situation:
Oktava MK012
AKG Blueline
Sennheiser ME64/K6 (technically not a hyper)
AKG ULS
Schoeps

These are listed in order of price. Now, from my ears, here they are in order of quality for application:

Sennheiser ME64/K6
Oktava MK012
AKG Blueline
AKG ULS
Schoeps

Wow, the Oktava at the bottom?

Well why do we all use it? Pure and simple, the Oktava is not at the bottom at all, it is a mile ahead of the ME64, an inch behind the Blueline, a foot behind the ULS, and a yard behind the Schoeps.

It sounds great plus it is cheap. What more needs to be said about it? It is the little mic that could... and it does.

The simple truth is that I had the Blueline system and loved it. I loved being able to change it from a hyper to a shotgun and just run with the system. I invested time into it, tested it a lot to get to know it, and then because of some technical issues got an Oktava to hold me over.

I never looked back on the AKG and sold it and bought my first AT4073a.

That simple.

The Oktava should not sound or perform like it does, yet this is the mic that can do it all. It works great, sounds great, and just keeps on ticking. It really is the perfect microphone for almost any use and I live and die by mine. I use it outside, inside, in reverb concrete rooms, and for foley work. It is the first thing out of my kit and the last to go back in. I have thousands of dollars worth of other mics and the Oktava is my swiss army mic. It does it all...

There are other things that work for certain situations better... but this does an amazing job.

OK, enough rambling, do what you will.

-Jeremy
 
Jeremy & timapter,

Thanks for your comments again, this is getting really really really intresting! :) Comments from the guys who know these stuffs, yeah. First when I started this topic, I was almost ready to get that Rode in a hurry. Now I'm seriously thinking of getting that Sennheiser 416 and a pair of Octava MK-012. Thanks goes to you. :dankk2: I'm so glad, I started this topic. I think I'm going to get the Oktavas first because I need them first when I'm doing the interviews soon...so cooooool! Can't wait! :love4:

Guys, is this the right model of the Oktava, if I want to get a pair of those mics: http://www.oktava-online.com/shop/view_prod.php?id=8

Does this kit include everything I need?

"The set consist of: 2*microphone preamps, 2*cardioid capsules, 2*hypercardioid capsules, 2*omnidirektional capsules, 2*-10 dB pads, 2*mic holders, wooden box."

The model for the pair seems to be called: MK-012 MSP6. Do you recommend of getting the pair at the same time? I want to start learning the stereo miking also! So, I think this would be the right way to go now with matched pairs?

Here's one pic of the Oktava pair...:

10oiosy.jpg


Thanks, once more! You guys are amazing. :dankk2:
 
Last edited:
That has all the caps... I use my hyper cap 98% of the time and cardiod cap 2% of the time.

Some people are real believers in matched pairs, but I just don't buy the hype. I would just buy two of the $175 mics with hyper caps, but that's just me.

Good choices though.

-Jeremy
 
ill second that.

i only EVER use my hyper cap, the whole matched pair thing is only important in very sensitive accurate work (sure as hell not a film set or home studio), and you can get the way cooler black oktavas (bella negro) if you buy individuals.

i think buying two is a great thing you are doing. im thinking of getting a schoeps later this year, but i still want another oktava just because they rock the pants off most other mics.

Now, dont want to burst your bubble, but the mics arent the only things you need.

You also need shock mounting, and a wind protection system.

Shock mounting is NOT an optional extra, you really really need it or you get loads of rumble on your audio (even you are just holding the mic - sometimes you can hear your bones creaking without a shock mount!).. people will recommend many different models, but I use a rycote pistol grip (note: not neccessarily the best choice, i just already had one). on the plus side, oktava and 416 have the same diameter so you can swap the shock mount when you get your 416 and save some cash.

read the baby ball gag post thats active right now for info on a wind screen.. but i just use the foam screen that is an extra with the mic because i only use mine indoors - even this practice is maybe a bit dodgy.

cheers
 
Thanks, mr. Timapter. :) Yes, you are totally right, it's not only the mics...

ORDERED! :Drogar-BigGrin(DBG) I ordered 2 black Oktavas matched pairs...I got pretty good deal, so I decided to go with this and got all the 6 capsules and 2 spiders also. I know, like you said, I'm probably going to use the hyper most of the time, but it's not a bad thing to have the other capsules also...right? :)

Guys, what do you think of this Oktavas own spider shock mount? Is it useful? Or do I need to get some better?

10pzy87.jpg


Timapter, do I need windscreen also when recording indoors? You said: "but i just use the foam screen that is an extra with the mic because i only use mine indoors"...Is some kind of wind foam coming with the mic or...?

Cheers!
, Pete.
 
Octavas, being basically studio microphones, are quite sensetive to wind, even just moving them around too fast is a no-no. I solved the problem by cutting the main part away from a shotgun foam windscreen I did not need anymore. Looks funny but it works.

Getting a pair (at a good price) is a splendid idea, now you can also try stereo recordings (not video, too complicated). I even made a modified Jecklin disk for the omni pair.
 
Back
Top