Sennheiser Evolution EW112P-G2 or EW122P-G2

OBM

Member
Hello all. I'm new to this forum, and new to videography at all. I decided to go with Panasonic DVC30 and to get wireless lavarier mic. BTW, I shot product presentations (on different expos).

I've decided to go with Sennheiser Evolution G2, and I was click away to order it but then, I noticed that there are two models. One is EW112-G2 and the other one is EW 122-G2. The first one (EW 112) comes with ME2 omni-directional lavalier microphone, and the second one (EW 122) comes with ME4 cardioid lavalier microphone.

So, which mic is better? What is the difference between these two mics?

And the second questions is what frequency should I go with: A (518-554MHz) , B ( 626-662MHz) or C (740-776MHz).


Or would be Sony UWP-C1 (66) better choise overall?

Thanks in advance and Happy Holidays!


OBM

 
OBM,

There have been a huge number of discussions around the G2's, but let me start by saying that generally, you have not given us enough info to directly answer your questions.

What are you going to be shooting? Can the mic be visible or does it have to be hidden (i.e. sit down interviews vs. narrative movies/tv)? Etc. Etc. Etc.

So, in terms of the mic, you would probably (again, guessing) be better with the omni. But, truthe be told, it really doesn't matter. You most likely will want to replace the mic anyway. The mic's shipped with the G2's are not great sounding. I'm purchasing 3 mics right now for my 2 new G2's, and I'm getting a Countryman B6, a Countryman EMW and a Pin Mic. Each one has different characteristics, different uses, and if you search the archives, I'm sure you will find the discussions on these.

As far as frequency goes, that depends on your location. I think Sennheiser has a frequency chart on their site (I know Lectrosonics does, but not sure how their blocks correspond to Senns). Check out which frequencies are generally available in your area.

I don't know the Sony, so I can't comment.

Phil
 
hello.

i have both the g2 / second generation and the original version.

what is the exact magic word to look for as i too wish to order a b6 contryman to try out with my sennheiser wireless transmitters?

matthew
 
Hi Matthew,

You can go to the Countryman Web site -- they have a full compatibility list. But, here's the model I'm going to order from B&H (unless I can just order direct from Countryman -- they're about 10 minutes from my house...)

Do a search for this part number: COB6SDB

It will bring up the one. It has a 3.5mm connector. As far as I can tell, it will work with both the G1 and the G2 (I'm not entirely sure the first model was actually called G1, that's just what I've always called it.)

Phil
 
Hey Ptalsky,

Thanks so much.

So here is additional requested info:

Well, I need wireless mic cause I shot product specialist showing their products on music expos. Those places are crowded and pretty noisy. While product specialist talk, I have to point camera at the product, so, onboard mic, or even shotgun can’t help. Mic doesn’t have to be hidden at all. So I guess this wireless lavarier would be good for what I need.

Best

OBM
 
for the situation you described the wireless should be perfect.

i would play around with the sensetivity settings as that should help you cut down how much noise you get from the crowd vs. the presenter.

matthew
 
It really depends on how close/far away you are, and whether you can have a mic connected to the camera. You really don't need wireless, you can go with a wired lapel which will save you money. And, you can get a better mic that way (a Sanken COS11 set up for wired will cost less than a G2.)
 
Ptalsky, do you mean this one http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home?O=productlist&A=details&Q=&sku=350616&is=REG&addedTroughType=search would be better than Sennheiser Evolution G2.

I'm not that far from the specialist who make presentation while I'm shooting the video, so maybe you are right. I can save few busk and get even better sound.

Do you think I'm going to need some extension XLR cable like this one http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home?O=productlist&A=details&Q=&sku=158244&is=REG&addedTroughType=search


You guys all rock! Thanks for your help.

BTW do you think Panasonic DVC30 is good choice for what I do. I was thinking to go with Sony PD170, but I don't know if I need that much.

OBM
 
It really boils down to (and I think it was Yankee or Matt that reminded me of this) wireless and lavalier are two different issues.

It does not sound like, to me, that you need wireless, though it would probably make things more convenient for you. If you go wired, you will undoubtedly need extra XLR cable. As far as cable goes, I would recommend Star Quad cables, as they tend towards less interference. I have learned to stay away from Hosa products, even though their cheaper and convenient (you can get most Hosa components at Guitar Centers, etc.) but the only time I've ever had problems with connectors it was with Hosa products. Neutrix (sp?) connectors and Canare Quad cables are the ones I use.

As far as the Sanken goes, I have never used it personally, but there was a very recent thread that was strongly recommending them. I believe you can also get Countryman lav's in a wired form (I have used Countryman and love them).

I don't really know much about either of the cameras you're talking about (though I do know that a Court TV show called I, Detective was shot with a 170.) If I had my choice, and unlimited budget, I'd either get a Varicam HD or a Cinealta. (Yes, I do live in a dream world sometimes. ;-)

Interesting side note: I did some acting on the new Will Smith movie Pursuit of Happyness (and no, that is not a typo), which they were shooting on 35mm, but the behind the scenes stuff was being shot on a Cinealta. Must be nice to shoot with a real budget. ;-)
 
i don't know, in a crowded venue with lots of people wandering around watching demo's I sure as hell wouldn't want to have a mic cable to worry about running from the camera 15-20 ft with all those careless people to trip over it??

i would use a high quality lavalier with the plug on transmitter. i rarely use my sennheiser wireless mic. i use their plug on transmitter with a better xlr lav.

matthew
 
On the other hand, matthewd5 you are completely right. So what wireless setup would you suggest me, but not too expensive!?

Thanks

OBM
 
Get sennheiser EW112P-G2. I have two sets. I also use them to my k6/ME64 and MD421.
 
Hello All,

First, I wish you all the best in New Year! Less work – more money!

Thank you guys for all your posts, I am very happy I found this forum, and your comments are very helpful.

I purchased three days ago Panasonic DVC-30, still wait to be delivered, and shotgun Rode NTG-2. As soon as I receive it, I’ll order Sennheiser EvolutionEW112P-G2 and bracket 1 with Quick Plate – Wireless Receiver Mounting Plate for Bracket 1.

I still think of Sanken and Countryman B6 lavalier microphone. If microphone on G2 sucks big time I’ll go with one of these I mentioned above.

Best to all of you.

OBM
 
OBM, you can also split the difference and try a Countryman EMW. I just bought a B6 and an EMW for my G2 kit (I will test and report as soon as they arrive). But, the price on the EMW is about half the cost of a Sanken, and lots of people have said good things about the EMW. (BTW, Dave, Fabi did a great job of helping me out with my purchase...just thought I'd pass along the compliment). And to everyone else, while I gain nothing from this endorsement, I do want to strongly endorse Coffey Sound for your purchases. Dave is always very forthcoming with information and support for this forum (yes, he benefits too, but still, none of the other "retailers" visit here as regularly) and Dave mostly does provide very unbiased information. ;-)

A question for everyone -- has anyone done A/B comparisons of lavalier mics like Ty Ford's tests on shotguns and hypers? Ty, if you're listening, this might be a great new project for you (since I know you have copious amounts of spare time. ;-)
 
Back
Top