Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

Dan_Lahav

Well-known member
Someone I know is selling a CMC5 and MK41 unit for $800. Is this a good deal? I'm thinking about selling my sanken cs-1 and getting one of these. How does this mic compare to MKH416 or other "industry standard" shotguns (and yes i know this isnt a shotgun)? I can only afford to keep one of these mics... What do you guys think?
 
Re: Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

The Schoeps is mainly an indoor mic... but it's in a class of it's own. If you get one you MUST get the Rycote BBG/Jammer, or even a FULL zepp system. The BBG/Jammer is under $200, but factor that in. You don't want to get the ultimate mic and then use anything less then the BBG on it. A BBG alone is like $120 and it SMOKES standard foam... you only need the Jammer if you decide to start using the Schoeps outside... and I certainly would.

I gave a far more detailed reply of what I like about the Schoeps over at dvinfo... so rather then repeat it here you can read it there... it's kind of long and boring... but if YOU'RE the one getting the Schoeps you may find the thoughts helpful in making a decision.
 
Re: Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

i use 541 for years without problem , for better boom work the cut 1 or cut 2 is kind of must , sometimes get noicy in high humidity , if it fals on the capsul you sometimes can say buy buy, working very nice indors , very flexcible desighn with cable and swivel , dont think that is good for someone who ownes one mike only, the trew audio have few 2nd hand shcoeps Rycotes
 
Re: Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

so how is the off-axis rejection and reach compared to something like the mkh416?
 
Re: Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

Click HERE to see the Schoeps mk41 polar pattern and frequency response.

What you see here is that the mk41 has dead flat frequency response and perfect polar pattern. This is what I was trying to explain at dvinfo. Take a HARD look at the polar pattern... see how tight and symetrical it is? That means that sound striking the mic from ANY angle is uniform in character and only changes in VOLUME. THAT'S an amazing trick!

Okay, now a perfect pattern in structure doesn't mean it's the perfect pattern for EVERY use.

Click HERE to see the Mkh416 polar pattern and frequency response.

What you see here is a reasonably flat frequency response with a rising presence. This is a common (desired) trait with shotgun microphones because as distance increases by double you get one fourth the power of signal... and since treble frequencies are the weakest... shotgun manufacturers almost always engineer a rising treble. Look at ANY shotgun frequency response... 95% of 'em have rising treble. Below that and throughout the vocal range FLAT is desireable.

Now looking at the polar pattern for the 416 we see that inside of 30 degrees each frequency band begins to peal away like an onion. The highest frequencies are at full power on direct axis... and lower and lower frequencies gradually fall away. It's THIS characteristic that makes shotguns directional.

The narrower the front bubble of the polar plot is... the more directional the mic is.

With shotguns a narrow pickup is DESIRED because you want a shotgun to be selective in what it hears.

Click HERE to see the most narrow shotgun pickup available... a 4071a.

A truly PERFECT shotgun pattern would look like an upside down drip of water... an tall oval with a pointed bottom... with ALL the frequencies nested together into one line. That doesn't exist... but the closest thing to that is the Mkh70. Click HERE.

In actual use a Sanken CS3e is supposed to have ultimate reach (so I've heard) and the CS1 has really good side/rear rejection... but not as much reach as it's bigger brother. I'd bet that an Mkh70 in an A/B "reach" test would be eye-popping in the Sennheiser's favor.

2 mics that are legendary for their long reach are the Sennheiser 816 and Neumann 82i... but both of those don't have unusually good polar patterns... it's just a combination of qualities PLUS the pattern that give them the good reach... but even still I'll bet the 70 would take it.

Sorry for getting a little off topic here... but I want you to fully understand why a Schoeps is so unique and great... but also why it's NOT a shotgun. Indoors a shotgun is almost NEVER needed... but outdoors a shotgun can come in handy a LOT. That's not to say the Schoeps won't work marvelously in many outdoor situations... but people don't buy a Schoeps because they need REACH... they buy it for perfect sound in controlled environments.

PLEASE Oleg... tell me if I'm wrong! Dan, Oleg has a crapload of experience with ALL of these mics. I've owned some of them and used others... but not for YEARS like Oleg has! ;)
 
Re: Schoeps CMC5 + MK41

Matt, as always you've answered my questions above and beyond what i was expecting. Thanks a ton for writing all that out for me. Wow, we have some incredible pple on this board...
 
Back
Top