n00b audio question

samrwamr

Active member
Hey-

I feel pretty confident with my standard DVX100a right now, but I will be shooting my first big project over spring break next year.

So - I don't want to skimp on audio, obviously. What would be a high quality microphone that I should buy? Should I go boom? On Camera?

My budget is probably around $500, no more than $1,000.

Also, a new tripod is a must for this new project. Would a crane be worth it too?

Again - I was thinking about getting the Redrock Micro M2 35mm adapter. Would that add a lot to my production?
 
fine. i'll answer. whatever.

Microphone: Oktava MK012a for interior stuff. definetly on a boom. (Just make a pole)

Tripod: Bogen 503 head on the cheapest bogen sticks you can find. don't worry.

redrock 35mm: won't add anything more than a softer image and DOF tricks the camera can do on it's own

Whew. there. not hard.
 
Hans Moleman said:
fine. i'll answer. whatever.

Microphone: Oktava MK012a for interior stuff. definetly on a boom. (Just make a pole)

Tripod: Bogen 503 head on the cheapest bogen sticks you can find. don't worry.

redrock 35mm: won't add anything more than a softer image and DOF tricks the camera can do on it's own

Whew. there. not hard.

Gotta disagree with you Hans, almost across the board. The Oktava is a good mic, but depending on shooting situations it may not be the ideal mic. The best points for the Oktava is that for $175 it acts like a $300 mic, but if you put it up against the AKG there is a night and day difference. Depending on what you are planning on doing with this project, the Oktava might not be the answer, but it is a good starting point. The other thing, you're suggesting a boom set up leaving out the most important elements of a boom set up: wind protection, shockmount, cables, and headphones. Furthermore, let's say that he is going to be shooting exclusively outdoors, then he would need a shotgun. In general though, the boom is a good suggestion.

For the tripod, the 503 is a good recommendation, it is what I have, but suggesting the cheapest tripod, that's not good. The sticks are what are going to be supporting your thousands of dollars in investment, plus I have seen people go with cheap garbage sticks and their shots aren't level. Invest in a good set of sticks, because they will last you.

Now, regarding the 35mm adapter. The DVX will not get the shallow DOF that you can get with an adapter. You said that it will do it on it's own, that aint gonna happen. If you want a very film like look, 24p is a good place to start. Post is a great place to finish, but a 35mm adapter is a great middle ground to firmly establish that. It is not necessary, but it is a nice thing to have. To completely write it off as unneeded is just wrong. It is a good tool and very useful for certain situations, or obtaining a certain look.

In the DIY & Hardware sections there are at least 100 threads of 35mm posts.
In the hardware section there are at least 50 threads on tripods and heads.
In this audio section there are at least 50 threads that start with 'what mic should I buy' or something like that.... hence why I said do a search, because it has been covered, but I had to chime in, because what you are telling him isn't exactly correct, no offense.

I'm not trying to bash you, but you're suggestions I just disagree with.
 
Amazingly, for once in my life I (sort of) disagree with Jeremy (The Yankee). It's in regard to the 35mm adapter.

While I agree that the 35mm adapter is a slick add on to the DVX, and that it can add to that ever sought after "film look", I'm reading a bit between the lines and thinking that maybe this isn't the project for SAMRWAMR to try it.

"SAM" already admits that he's a noob at audio. Also that it's his first big project. I think that the key to having the most success is to adhere to the KISS principle (Keep It Simple, Stupid).

Running one' s first real project leaves a lot to be attended to-shot lists, continuity, problems with actors, shooting sites, equipment, etc. (and we haven't even hit the record button yet). Most initial ventures are "under crewed" both in numbers as well as depth of experience. That means the principle shooter (SAM) may have to function as the DP, director of lighting (yes, lighting is important in getting a "film look", too), as well as staying on top of audio issues.

So, since I think that you can get a good result without a 35mm adapter I think that you should leave exploring that for future projects. Instead of adding to the project, you may just be adding headaches by using it.

Now if you have an experienced person to run the audio, a knowledgeable lighting person, someone to act as producer and handle the behind the scenes stuff, and an experienced assistant camera operator to pull focus with that adapter, then I'm wrong, and you should go for it. But if you're heading into this project as most of us have done, then I'd leave the 35mm adapter for now.
 
i atleast wouldnt get the redrock micro35, not worth the price to practice on. Go for a letus35 or another assembled 35mm adapter that will cost you under 400. You should only use a 35mm adapter if you feel limited by your cameras regular lens in terms of field of view v.s Depth of field.
 
I got so excited when I read Joe's first line. My eyes openned wider, I leaned forward in my chair, I was just ready. Then once I read his post, I agreed with the whole thing.

This is what I was saying: Regarding Sam, I told him to run a search. His questions do not need a custom response because they are asked daily and the last thing any of us who frequent the audio channel need is another 'what mic should I buy' thread (who is not recovering from the infamous: no more BS thread).

My response was regarding what Hans said in his post. I found almost every single comment to be misleading. The truth is for Sam's project he doesn't need a $1000-$10,000 audio set up, a 35mm adapter, or a dolly.

My post was regarding directing someone without a lot of experience down a track where he is not going to get the results he is looking to achieve by making blanket statements.

I think Joe and I are talking the same language. Wow... I'm getting up there in post numbers... need to make each one of these start to count or something.
 
Hey thanks for the response.

I think I've settled on the Oktava MK021 for now, because this project will be mostly indoors. Plus it is a great price for the sound I'll get. I'll pick up a Sabra-Som shockmount, Gitzo 8.7' Boompole, and not sure on the windscreen yet.

If/when I do want shotgun, I think one of the Audio Technica's should fit me well.

Boom question(s): What do you think is the maximum distance between the audio source and the mic to still get good pickup? I know it probably depends on the microphone, but with the MK021? just curious.
Are pretty much all mics workeable on a boom? What are some rules/regulations on working with them?

Dollies are not crucial for this project, along with the redrock Micro 35mm. I can definetely do without. (I'm a sophomore in HS, so I'll try and get some funds from my school's video department!)
 
TheYankee said:
(who is not recovering from the infamous: no more BS thread).
Hahaha, I just read that WHOLE thing yesterday. Woke up today and I STILL have a headache. [Paraphrased] "OK, you gave me a comprehensive list and recommendations for all different types of situations, but can you just rack your brain a little more and narrow it down?" Ugh.
-Ryan
 
I got so excited when I read Joe's first line. My eyes openned wider, I leaned forward in my chair, I was just ready.

Sorry. Any of my relatives could tell you that at my core, I'm boring as all get out.

This is what I was saying: Regarding Sam, I told him to run a search.

Wouldn't the world be a better place if everyone tried that?

I think Matt from St. Louis said it best a while ago when he said something to the effect that no one believes the information that's given (even if it's exactly the same information) unless their name was attached to the thread.

Maybe if we had a sticky at the top that listed several threads in different categories for people to check out, e.g.,

For microphone selection
thread x
thread y
thread z

For boompoles
thread a
thread b
thread c

For Mixers
Thread d
thread e

For comprehensive inexpensive kit
thread x
thread n

etc.

Naw... it still wouldn't work.
 
No one will every believe anything unless they personally have it answered, but I think that is why we have a PM function. That no more BS thing just got way out of hand. Here is a perfect kit list, but what about this? Give me a break, just kept going and going until some people started to have a melt down.

Regarding the Oktava, the number 1 goal in sound is to get the mic as close as possible. A professional sound person will fight for every single inch in order to get a better sound capture. An amatuer will just try to keep it out of frame. Keep reading that sentence until it clicks and then you will know more about sound than half the people who have $2000 kits.

The maximum distance that you can get good sound from the Oktava is a simple answer, .00009" above where the frame ends. You always want to get the mic as close as possible. I would say in general the Oktava has a nice 36" bubble, but that doesn't mean that 36" is where you want it. You want it 6".

Sam, the kit looks nice, cheap, and effective. The other option for you, and I make this recommendation all the time, but the best solution for you is to look at your microphone budget and forget buying anything and just hire someone. A pro (or even enthusiast with experience) will provide significantly better results and most likely be cheaper.

True, you don't own anything at the end of the shoot, but you will have sound that is better.

No one likes when I make that statement, but it makes so much sense.
 
<quote>"The maximum distance that you can get good sound from the Oktava is a simple answer, .00009" above where the frame ends."</quote> :)

Maybe it's just today, but that hit me just right. Thanks for a laugh.

Larry
 
TheYankee said:
No one will every believe anything unless they personally have it answered, but I think that is why we have a PM function. That no more BS thing just got way out of hand. Here is a perfect kit list, but what about this? Give me a break, just kept going and going until some people started to have a melt down.

Regarding the Oktava, the number 1 goal in sound is to get the mic as close as possible. A professional sound person will fight for every single inch in order to get a better sound capture. An amatuer will just try to keep it out of frame. Keep reading that sentence until it clicks and then you will know more about sound than half the people who have $2000 kits.

The maximum distance that you can get good sound from the Oktava is a simple answer, .00009" above where the frame ends. You always want to get the mic as close as possible. I would say in general the Oktava has a nice 36" bubble, but that doesn't mean that 36" is where you want it. You want it 6".

Sam, the kit looks nice, cheap, and effective. The other option for you, and I make this recommendation all the time, but the best solution for you is to look at your microphone budget and forget buying anything and just hire someone. A pro (or even enthusiast with experience) will provide significantly better results and most likely be cheaper.

True, you don't own anything at the end of the shoot, but you will have sound that is better.

No one likes when I make that statement, but it makes so much sense.

I think it makes perfect sense.

I would love to higher a sound guy, but I have absolutely no idea where or who to go (or how to pay him, for that matter) to for that. My city isn't extremely resourcefull when it comes to this kind of stuff. Plus, I would love to have something of my own to use and experiment with, because I want to learn this stuff. I don't know, am I being stupid?

I want to learn every aspect of filmmaking. It's what I want to do, obviously. Specifically, I would love to go into film scoring - a whole different animal.

Sam
 
Back
Top