Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

Collink

Well-known member
Anyone use a Microdrive with the Marantz or otherwise? Are they dependable? Seems to me that standard CF cards would be more robust (no moving parts). And the cost is usually about the same per GB. There is the added convienence of not having to switch cards mid-shoot. Anyone care to share experiences or opinions in this regard?
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

I use a PMD-670 but not with a Microdrive. I prefer CF card. I already had one plus not having to switch cards mid-shoot is no big deal - most of my takes are less than 30 min. anyway.
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

I use a microdrive in my Nikon D-100, but that is because it was the badest available at the time. Stick with standard CF cards now that they have good capacities and no moving parts.
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

That's kind of the direction I'm heading. I figured the "no moving parts" issue would play into longevity and dependability. Hopefully two 1Gb cards will give me enough space to get in a days worth of takes, foley, and sound beds.
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

How do you like the PMD670? I'm thinking of getting one and haven't found many real reviews yet.

As far as Microdrives go, I will quote a friend of mine who used to work for IBM Storage Division and Hitatchi (makers of most Microdrives) -- "I would never consider storing valuable data on it, maybe a back up but that's about it". He managed a QA group at IBM...so my guess would be go with CF (I know that Fry's here in Silicon Valley has 1GB CF for like US$40 (after rebate).
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

I am interested in Marantz PMD670 as well,
can somebody please write a review on this?

or any experiences with Fostex FR-2?
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

I'm writing a review now I'll post it here in a few days.
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

Ok, sorry for the delay, but here's my take on the PMD-670.
I'm using it with a (Kingston branded) 1024Mb Compact Flash card. (no microdrive) Upon first inspection the overall construction is about as good, although not quite as robust as the older PMD series recorders from Marantz. The upside here is that the (mostly plastic) construction makes the unit light and easy to carry around for long periods, but I'm seriously considering a padded case (like the Porta Brace) to protect it. I definitely get the feeling that one drop from chest high onto tile or cement would cause instant, possibly catastrophic, damage. Strangely, there are consistent little scratches next to every recessed switch hole in the outer case. It looks like the tooling machine that cuts those holes "drug" across the surface as it went from hole to hole, it's not obtrusive, you really have to look to see it, and it doesn’t affect the usability of the unit at all, but it is a very mild cosmetic issue, and speaks to the overall build quality. I'm powering it with 8 AA Energizer batteries, and despite putting about 3+ hours on it, the battery meter has yet to drop down from full charge. Nice.
I initially tried the built in mic. It sounds like you would expect a sub-miniature enclosure-mounted mic to sound: tinny and thin. Great for intelligibility, but poor sounding. Would only use the internal mic maybe to record interviews or lectures for my own use, NEVER for broadcast. Then I plugged in a Sennheiser ME-66/K6 shotgun condenser. The sound quality improved dramatically. After fiddling with it for some time and then finally giving up and going back to the manual, I figured out how to change record settings and have them stay that way. The menu driven changes to record settings are not a huge issue because I think most people would set it and forget it, but they aren't very intuitive, and the manual isn't a very big help. I kept trying to setup the record option to 16bit, 48Khz, mono PCM from the left XLR input. And while I could assign this in the menu, as soon as I saved the menu setting, the recorder defaulted back to Stereo. Very frustrating, the manual didn't really ever come out and specifically say it, but in order to select mono you have to define that with an input mode button on the top of the unit before setting it up in the menu. Now with that ugliness behind me I can say that I'm very happy with some of the recordings I've captured. The unit has some level of noise that I had to watch out for. You pull the gain up really high and you can hear it, but for dialogue and sound effects (foley) gathering it works like a charm. My library of killer foley pieces and sounds is about to explode. The quality of sound you can get with this thing using a good mic (like the ME-66/K6) and the uncompressed PCM setting is excellent. The shoulder/neck strap is not long enough for me (although my location audio guy likes it that short) and the strap is narrow and unpadded, it can get uncomfortable. That's yet another reason to consider a quality padded bag for it - better strap. There are 2 compression settings MP3 and MP2 and they DO sound compressed. Honestly if you have a DVX, you are better off using audio off of the camera (with an outboard mic) than anything compressed from the 670. But the 670 shines in uncompressed PCM 16/48. Dropping to the PC couldn’t be easier- you can attach a USB 2.0 cable and the 670 looks like a USB drive, or just plug the compact flash into a card reader and, bingo, same thing. I think the CF card reader was faster than the USB cable through the PMD. Much faster than the SD cards I have for other cameras.
Bottom line is this thing does a great job for what it is. It makes a decent location sound recording solution for those with less than $2K to spend on one. If you have the money look into the Sound Devices 722 ($2700) or 744T ($4300) They are supposed to be really good for the money. But if you look at the other offerings in this product category The PMD-670 is the MOST cost effective solution. Most other location sound solutions cost 4-20 times the cost of the PMD. Even a decent DAT recorder till set you back 1000+, and then you have linear capture issues. There's the Sonifex Courier for about $2800, the Nagra V2 at $8900, the Fostex PD-6 at about $10,000. and of course the primo multichannel solutions like the HHB Portadrive for $14,000, and the drool inducing, mother of all recorders the Aaton Cantar X ($15,000.)
Bottom line is that if you are doing run and gun indie production on extremely low budgets, and renting is not all that viable and you, wont/ cant/ would rather not, deal with audio straight from the DVX this is the option right now.
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

Hi Collink,

Thanks for taking the time to write up a review on the PMD-670. I am considering the purchase of one myself but have no means to check one out before purchasing. You've provided some great information here.

Thanks,
Dan
 
Re: Marantz PMD670 and Microdrives

awesome,
finally a real review on PMD670!!

I hear the battery life drops dramatically if you use phantom power from PMD670, but I guess if you are using ME66, that does not matter.
nice review, sounds like you are happy with the sound quality.
about the menu setting, the recorder defaulted back to Stereo, according to the menual, I think you can secure it by the input lock switch.

thanks alot collink! :D
 
Back
Top