making a quality sound mix

c.g._eads

Veteran
I've never done an 'official' sound mix. But everybody says that a good sound mix costs a lot of money. Why is this? My understanding of a sound mix is that it is dialogue, score, sound effects, foley, all mixed together on a bunch of tracks. As a comparable audio file is about a tenth (estimating) the size of a video file, I don't see why this is so difficult to do. Don't you just need a computer and program that can handle putting a bunch of these tracks together at the same time? I'd assume that any computer that can do video editing can do this with ease. What am I missing?

c.g.
 
Re: making a quality sound mix

It's expensive to be done propperly because it depends on talented people, not equipment (Although true mixing stations for film work can get quite expensive). It's a hard science, and by selecting wich sound effects/foley/music/dialogue, and by adjusting each one so they all sound good (and from the same place) is difficult. Say, just mixing dialogue is already a *****, because if in one shot you have your actor a little off-axis, his voice will sound different and will have to be equalized to the rest of the picture. This as all the rest, is much easier said than done. AS in a film, where the cinematography sometimes only come toghether after the grading, the soundtrack only comes toghether after mixing.
 
Re: making a quality sound mix

Real mixing is very involved, and you have to know what you are doing. It's more than just adjusting levels. There may be a lot of EQ involved, and a lot of creative decisions, especially when music and fx start to fight each other. I've spent entire days on mix stages where they were doing dialogue pre-dubs, and over the course of an 8 hour day, they may have only pre-dubbed 30-40 minutes of dialogue. I have spent two days doing a final mix on a 20 minute short.

It's hard to explain if you don't really know what's involved, but needless to say, if you are doing a project that you expect to show in festivals, or theatrical release, get someone who knows what they are doing to do your mix for you. You will be very happy that you did.

-Dave
 
Re: making a quality sound mix

I spent days working on the sound for a 4-minute movie because there were audio issues (mechanical noise in BG). Even if I'd had clean dialogue, everything else would still have taken me hours to work on. C.G., your understanding of a sound mix (dialogue, score, SFX, and foley) sounds about like what I've heard, but to me that sounds like a lot. Hardly something that just having a good computer and software will get you. As has been said above, it's the talent of the engineer that makes it. I'm just barely getting started on this, but I can already see how someone who knew what they were doing would have turned my pathetic sound into something useable. Don't underestimate it. :)
 
Re: making a quality sound mix

Normally I would write a much longer post on this but I'm barely conscious after being released from the hospital with food poisoning...

The problem with mixing audio is more complicated that just playing a bunch of tracks at the same time at different volumes.  It is getting all those tracks to sit together in such a way that they all have their own space in the mix, so that they don't step over each other and become mud.

You listen to a recording of a rock band and you hear a bass and drum.  They are both panned center.  The bass drum and the bass guitar have overlap in their frequency range.  If you leave both in their natural state, you will wind up with a muddy sound without much punch.  So... an audio engineer will cut certain frequencies with eq, and compression and do whatever else is necessary so that both of these sounds "sit in the mix".  This is just to get two instruments to play together nicely.  A film is even more complicated.  The good thing is that it's easily learned (putting that knowledge into practice is something else however). Some folks have a certain gift for it - I'm not one of those, but I do ok.  But ANYONE can learn the basics and then some you just need to educate yourself.  A couple of weeks ago I posted some about some books that are decent to start with, you might want to check them out.  

Again I know this post isn't that helpful, but I can't think too straight right now maybe tomorrow...  There have been some posts already that address this though so maybe a search of the forum would help.

Best,

Matt
 
Re: making a quality sound mix

One other thing. For all those interested in this stuff I would recommend subscribing or getting MIX magazine. There is always a section on mixing for picture and those articles can be quite insightful.

Matt
 
Back
Top