how to record like an amateur...

olsonbock623

Active member
I have a Rode ntg-2 shotgun mic and a dvx. I am no professional. I'm looking to throw together a recording of my friends' band so I can make a music video. They have played together just a couple of times and we are all highschoolers and they have no recording equipment. We're not trying to make them famous. So we tried recording the drums, and I placed the mic stand behind the drummers back as high as it would go pointing down at the drums. Even when the levels aren't in the red, there is distortion when he plays loudly. Again, I know this mic is made for recording dialogue, but is there any advice I could get to get a passable recording of drums and electric guitars with this mic without spending any more money? Should I move the mic somewhere else? I'd love advice, and feel free to let me know if this really isn't going to work, but please don't say... "to get professional results, you need a $2,000 mic and a mixer etc. etc. cause obviously I'm not looking for professional results and I don't have money). thanks.
 
place 2 telephones in the middle of the room and you get ELO classic sound
to make it metallica - place the cellulars
to make it armature spend 50 $ on 2 chiniz dynamics , place them in the middle of the room with 90 degree each over other
now you have armature xy recording
for the first 2 you need aditional mike to record the other side of the conversation in the next room -everything go :-)
 
Are you using any kind of attenuation? sounds like the drums are overloading the mic circuit. Try using a 10dB pad to lower the drums a bit. It could maybe also be the room.

Ive done what you are trying to do on film sets as a "next best thing" type solution, and have got it to work just fine.

Heres a tip for your mic placement: Remember that ultimately, the kick drum is the most important drum as it roots the rhythm and syncs it to the bass. Try place the mic so the kick has enough punch relative to everything else.

Also, george is, as always, right. Try picking up some pseudo-crasppy dynamic mics and experimenting with two or more of them - you can actually get some pretty cool sounds. Not pro, obviously, but its still fun to screw around with.
 
Move the mic far enough away that it stops overloading, and hit record. There is really no combination of drums, electric guitar and one mic that is not going to sound like "bad garage band recording". Even something insanely lo-fi like The White Stripes "Fell In Love With a Girl" isn't this lo-fi (but it's close).

Try asking this queston in a music forum.

Good luck
 
A couple of things...First, I've never recorded music, but every concert I've ever been too, they put the mics in front of the drumset, not behind. This might help some. If you're worried about blow out, record to both channels, and set one channel 25% lower than the other.

Second, I haven't used the NTG2, but I have used the NT5's (cartioid pattern). I think the NTG2 is a shotgun, and it will have a longer, narrower pickup pattern than an omni or cartioid, so you have to allow for this in your placement. Pull it back (away from the drums) by 2-3 feet and this may improve your recording. But, remember, the reason shotguns are not (generally) the preferred mic for interiors is (among other things) you will get a lot of bounce and reverb, unless you're working in a really dead studio environment.

You might want to look on eBay for a cartioid mic. You can pick one up for fairly little money (can't swear to the quality on these low-priced mics) but again, having the right pickup pattern should improve things a bit.

Hope this helps...good luck with your project.

Phil
 
Check into the Behringer B5 - it's like $89 and does a great job at micing drums and guitar. It has a -10db pad to help attenuate high levels from drums etc. I wouldn't recommend this mic for vocals but if you use it that way, position it farther from the vocalist or it will pop quite a bit.

My recommendation would be to have the band play their song together once and record that. Then put that on a CD or ipod and have each person play their part while listening to that (this will take a little practice). Record each part seperately and combine in post. This will eliminate bleed from each instrument and allow you to sweeten in post. I would not recommend recording drums in a garage :) It is such a small place the echo is such to muddy up your recording - like haveing to much reverb... Find a more open room with some stuff in it (furniture does a lot of dampening believe it or not) or better yet see if you can borrow an auditorium for an hour or two.

This will take some work, but the sound will be immensely better. Audio is key in any video work and especially a music video you can be proud of - it's tough to really enjoy visuals if your ears are being assaulted ;)
 
I like "Exile's" recommendation of two dynamic mics situated 90 degrees to each other (each would end up 45 degrees to the stage). Experiment until you find a "sweet spot" (usually mid room) where everything sounds fairly balanced. Try to record without an audience, as recording this way with an audience will preferentially pick up the crowd nearest the mics. If you want crowd noise/reaction, then record a second time (preferably in the same venue) and mix it in in post.

Shure SM 57's are now $79 each (after $10 rebate) at B and H with free shipping:
http://tinyurl.com/77tx2

That's a good deal on a good dynamic mic. If you can't get that much together, then hit e-bay.
 
I didn't see Robert's post while I was out shopping for a good deal on the 57's. His way (recording each part separately) will indeed give you a better recording to work with.

I didn't recommend it because, as he points out, it takes a degree of skill on the musicians' part that I don't think most high school bands possess. But if they can do it, then that's the way to go.
 
Guys,

The suggestion to use SM57's as an XY stereo pair is terrible advice. He would be much better off buying a couple of <insert cheap Chinese condensor> for < 100$ each. Dynamic mics are best suited for close mic application.

I thought the author made it pretty clear that he didn't have any more money to spend anyway.
 
so the original plan was to record the drummer first, who would be playing to a metronome through headphones, then put the drum part onto an ipod and have the guitarists play their parts while listening to the drums, then put it all together and have the vocals done while listening to the rest of the instruments. Basically what Bobert was saying. I think the musicians can handle it, we'll see. There's a chance I could spring for one other mic or maybe borrow one. I'm guessing it wouldn't be too hard to find a dynamic mic (those are the most common handheld type right?) to borrow.
 
Back
Top