Disgusted with Marantz PMD-671

Monglane

Well-known member
I posted here a couple of weeks ago regarding my surprise when I found out that the so-called Marantz "Professional" solid-state PMD-671 recorder generated hiss, rumble and, more generally, a fairly audible amount of white noise-like garbage.

I couldn't quite believe it, so over the following weeks I carried out a series of tests, exchanging XLR cables, dynamic and condenser mics, and trying out all the available presets, switching off my computer and even my fridge, recording in the middle of the night in my already very quiet house, in empty, reverberating rooms, in my car in the garage, and even under the duvet... All in all, I must have spent a good ten hours doing tests and... much as I hate to say it, having forked out a hefty amount of cash for that machine... well, the PMD-671 sucks !

I have come to the unfortunate conclusion that the mic preamp is responsible for the noise, and is definitely not up to what I would call "professional". Heck, the sound section on the DVX100A is a lot better in that respect : blissfully noise-free, even though the sound it produces isn't as "rich" and clearly defined in the mid- to high-range.

When I bought the Marantz, I hoped to have found an easy way to record quality sound and, if only that, to be able to record voiceovers in a manner more practical than having to use my camera. Now, I merely hope I'll find someone else to buy the PMD-671 second hand, although I'm not comfortable with the idea of passing it on to a fellow filmmaker...

So my advice to you guys is this : do NOT buy the Marantz PMD-671. The DVX100A does a much better job, even if that means extracting the sound track from the .avi in Audition (or another piece of software) and fiddling with the graphic equalizer a bit.
 
I don't think you'll have a problem selling it. I've never heard of somebody being so unhappy with one of the Marantz units. Are you sure there isn't something wrong with this particular unit... or a setting?
 
MattinSTL said:
Are you sure there isn't something wrong with this particular unit... or a setting?
Matt, I sure as hell hoped that was the case, initially... The settings are complex and many adjustments can be made, and I thought "I MUST be doing something wrong...", so I went back to factory defaults (noisy) and plowed my way carefully through the settings, taking notes as I went (still noisy).

I have never been able to find a way to make the situation better, no matter what I tried. Like Thisiswells says, the earlier PMD-670 had been criticized for the lack of quality of the mic preamp, but then that had supposedly been "dramatically improved" on the new PMD-671... Well, don't trust everything you read...

Now, if you or anyone more knowledgeable than me in the sound department (or even possibly another Marantz owner) comes up with a brilliant idea, I'll be more than willing to try it out and to admit loud and clear that I was wrong about this product ! Unfortunately, it doesn't sound (no pun intended) like I am.
 
That's odd. I hang out in r.a.m.p.s and don't recall anyone ever saying anything bad about the Marantz products (other than being 16 bit...except for the newer 671).

Coem to that, there have been a lot of posts here, too.

Dan
 
Monglane said:
So my advice to you guys is this : do NOT buy the Marantz PMD-671. The DVX100A does a much better job, even if that means extracting the sound track from the .avi in Audition (or another piece of software) and fiddling with the graphic equalizer a bit.


It's too bad the Marantz didn't work out. You might consider just getting a standard DAT machine to record on versus the portables. in comparision, I found that the DVX sound setup is very good for what it is. Just to let you know I recently videotaped a friend's band at Key Club in LA and he had the clubs sound mixer record a CD/DAT copy for him right off the mixing board. He then compared the sound from the board to what I recorded from the DVX. He concluded the DVX was a lot cleaner. My friend works at MAudio and worked many years as a manager for a record company to sign bands. During the show, I set my settings using DVrack to avoid clipping (-24db) in order to handle the unusual peaks and it came out flawless. I recorded it to the minidv tape. The dynamic range was clean and I'm currently using wavelab 5 and Sonar 4 to edit it. I then plan to finish it off in Vegas 6 for DVD production using Architect 3.0 for distribution. PS. I also hooked up my camera to a line conditioner (tripplite LC-1200) for a consistent power supply and to reduce noise suppression.
 
I have not heard any hands on experience with the 671 yet (except Monglane). I heard the bad pre-amps in the 660 and 670 but they were suppose to have been improved. There was a recent recall on some 660 because of their pre-amps.

"On 4/26, a Marantz VP posted to acknowledge that there is a problem with the PMD660 mic pre-amp circuit, and to announce they have a mod to address it. Contact Marantz at 866-405-2154 to arrange to have your PMD660 serviced."

Perhaps some "faulty" pre-amps made their way to the 671. I would give them a call. At the very least they should take it in for testing.

If they are not copertative with you, you might want to point them to this site/thread and show them that they are getting some serious bad publicity from an unhappy customer.

Good luck!
 
Tks for your advice, Wabbit. I'll try and give them a call tomorrow. Do you know where in the US they are ? It does matter because, being in France, I'm 6 hours ahead of the Eastern seaboard and 9 hours ahead of the Pacific coast.
 
I would contact the place you got it from and see if they can walk through a couple of things with you to make sure you have everything set up right.

Did you try coming line level into it? That would be my next test.

-Dave
 
Dave_Fisk said:
I would contact the place you got it from and see if they can walk through a couple of things with you to make sure you have everything set up right.

Did you try coming line level into it? That would be my next test.

-Dave
Dave, the people I got it from are box-pushers from Brooklyn. Good prices, but no point trying to ask them anything--didn't think I'd need to, it's not like I was buying a DVX.

Your line-in test is a good idea. Never thought of it, as I would never use the Marantz for that, but I'll give it a try. Thanks for the suggestion.
 
Just called Marantz at the number Wabbit gave me. They claim they haven't heard about the problem with respect to PMD-671s (I expected that). They told me my only option is to return the unit to the retailer who will, in turn, send it back to them for inspection (I expected that, too).

Seeing that I'm in France, I'm not sure I wanna deal with the hassle and the week-slong (if not months-long) wait...

Dave, I did the line test : no audible hiss/rumble through the headphones except at very high levels on the amplifier and the listening level and I don't think the Marantz is reponsible for that because, in Audution, the blank space betweeen two CD tracks is perfectly flat--no noise.

So it looks (didnt daresa it sounds) like the mic preamp's the culprit...

Still, I would hjave loved to have some feedback from another PMD-671 owner on this forum, but it looks like I'm the only one...

I uploaded a sort .wav file (2.18 MB) for you guys to listen to. This represents the best result I managed to coax out of the Marantz, and it's still quite noisy. The mic was a Sennheiser e865 condenser : http://perso.wanadoo.fr/cinedv/best_test.wav.
 
An awfully low level there. Peaking at a tad over -18, averaging around -30. Not surprised you can hear the noise floor if you normalize it to -3. (I can't hear the floor without normalizing it).


NB: listening through my Audigy 2 & Logitech speakers, not a reference system

Dan
 
Yeah, those levels are pretty low. So low, I couldn't even make out the words ;)

Seriously though, the audio on your file is too close to the floor to make an accurate judgement. Can you record a file that is closer to -12dbfs average?
 
Monglane said:
Dave, the people I got it from are box-pushers from Brooklyn.


Well, if they can't help you with something this simple, then you shouldn't be buying from them.

-Dave
 
Probably. But what's done is done, and frankly how could I expect this sort of trouble with the "professional" line of a manufacturer of good repute, and with a unit with no moving parts ?

Anyway, I uploaded another sound file for you guys. The levels on the previous one were intentionally low, in a hope to keep the background noise down as well. This new one has been recorded at a higher input level : normal speech, the peaks are at -3 dB (3.14 MB) ==> http://perso.wanadoo.fr/cinedv/sound_test2.wav.
 
this might not be a suggestion you want to hear, but i thought i'd throw it out anyway-
have you considered picking up a sound devices mixpre or something similar to connect to the 671? the cons are obvious- it costs about the same as the marantz, and it about doubles the size of your package. the pros are- the pres are way better than the pres will be in any recorder in that price range, you'll get better monitoring, flexibility (for recording to other devices,) and really decent limiters, which the marantz unit doesn't have. it seems like the jury is out on whether the pres in your unit are faulty or if marantz just used crap pres in the 671. but the pres in the mixpre are better than any pres that marantz have ever put in anything. sending a line-level signal from the mixpre to the marantz will sound better than using the marantz's pres, or the pres in any low-budget recording device.

sorry if it sounds like i'm suggesting that you throw good money after bad. i guess i am, but it's an idea to think about.
 
Tks for your suggestion. I thought about that too, but it sort of defeats the purpose of portability and simplicity... It means one more box, more power supply problems in the field, more cables to trip over, more settings and controls to worry about... I'm thinking more and more about dumping the Marantz to buy a Fostex FR2, but I feel I've been had and it's not a pleasant feeling ! I wish I'd had the wisdom to stay away from the wretched thing...
 
Back
Top