Jacques_Meov
Carbonite Member
Well, here goes....
Saw the post with the holographic microphone and went to the link. $6k for that? A glorified metal L'Eggs container with eight electret mics inside. So you drop six large, then what? Oh, yeah a really expensive 8 track mixer/recorder!
A bit of my background. I have designed medical products using "simple" electret microphones. You know, the cheap $1.49 kind from Radio Shack; the kind that are in a $5 phone from Wally Wolrd! I have also tken apart some shotgun mics that I bought on feebay that were broken. On dis-assembly was I shocked (not hardly!) to find, that one brand that shall remain nameless, but costs about $300 new, using an electret microphone that was THE SAME TYPE OF ELECTRET MICROPHONE USED IN MY DAUGHTERS BROKEN MICKEY MOUSE PHONE!
You see, I'm not surprised because unless your using a ceramic, or even carbon mic, all electronic microphones use electrets.
Here's why:
1. They have the best dynamic range, typically in the 20-20k hertz range. Remeber, the human ear can't hear below 30 hertz, and by the time you're 40, or have gone to your fifth Metallica/Pink Floy concert, you generally can't distinguish sound in the 50 hertz dynamic range. THere is very little sound above 12k that is functionally useful, but the range of 12k-20k gives a sound envelop "ambience"/or fullness. (This is kind of subjective, but any sound pros know what I'm trying to say...It's like a background timbre that "fills" out the sound.)
2. They consume little power, in the 10-150 mA range, and use 1.5V per electret.
3. Their output resistance is typically 1.5K ohms. This output resistance matches almost all op-amp ICs, eliminating the need for resistance matching...additional components and additional cost, and additional noise!
4. While they are omni-directional, meaning they pick up in a 360 degree field, they can be made unidirectional by insulating the back of the electret cartridge. They also can be pick up sculpted by lensing the input area. (Like barn doors control light output, this also works in reverse for sound entering the electret)
So, that's the reason even your fairly expensive shotgun mics, boom mics, lavs, etc., all use electret microphone cartridges. Remember also, that these cartridges come in different grades also...in terms of output, harmonic distortion, etc.
(A quick BG on the electret mic cartridge. It is an aluminum case that is punched out of a sheet of AL with a tiny hole in the center. Imagine an opened tuna can with a hole in the center of the remainign lid. Then a stretched peice of AL-Tn milar is stretched over a thin shim gasket. This is placed inside the canister. A VERY SMALL FET--field effect transistor-is soldier to the edge of the can, to the milar film and to the back of the printed circiot baord. Typically two wire leads are all that are sticking oiut the back of an electret cartidge. The aluminum can is crimped on the edges sealing it up. This works in that sound enters the small hole causing the mylar metal film to vibrate. These vibrations are amplified by the FET and sent out the leads. The FET amplifies and also lowers the output resistance to 1.5K ohms. I have measured the output resistance with the FET, it is 100Megohms, a hundred million ohms, to high to be worthwhile unless runnign through a FET)
So, what am I posting this for? TO show my superior intellect, ROFLMAO, hahahaha, NO.
I want to design a new microphone system, but need some input from you that are pros/prosumers/amatuers. Am also looking for some try-er-outers too!
Questions:
How long of lead from mic head unit to camera? This is critical becuase longer leads create all kinds of problems. Long leads also mean designing in a power-amp booster at the mic head.
Does having a simple two stage mixer at the end oif the boom arm make sense? (I figure that a good set up with two mics would have one high on a pole, and one "shot-gunned" at mid-range, on or off the camera.)
XLR pins? I'm envisioning that it will be self-powered because XLR phantom powers 48V...WAY TOO MUCH for what I'm using. (I can step it down, but is an additional power supply to the mics that much of an incovenience?)
What type of pick up characteristics do you want? Full, rich timbred sound, or narrow, focused sound? (These two are not mutually exclusive BTW!)
Do you want a stero mic?
Finally, does that hologrphic doo-hickey for $6k excite anyone? (I can build one with 5 mics for like 200 bucks, no XLR outs though...)
Will you be using DAT/MD/on-board camera for the sound recording?
How long a pole?
Weight requirements?
Like I said, am wanting to build a new mic system for a few reasons:
1. To show tht it can be done for a lot less than current.
2. I want a better system!
3. Advance current state of the art.
Oh, if you want to email me direct: nushuz1@juno.com
Saw the post with the holographic microphone and went to the link. $6k for that? A glorified metal L'Eggs container with eight electret mics inside. So you drop six large, then what? Oh, yeah a really expensive 8 track mixer/recorder!
A bit of my background. I have designed medical products using "simple" electret microphones. You know, the cheap $1.49 kind from Radio Shack; the kind that are in a $5 phone from Wally Wolrd! I have also tken apart some shotgun mics that I bought on feebay that were broken. On dis-assembly was I shocked (not hardly!) to find, that one brand that shall remain nameless, but costs about $300 new, using an electret microphone that was THE SAME TYPE OF ELECTRET MICROPHONE USED IN MY DAUGHTERS BROKEN MICKEY MOUSE PHONE!
You see, I'm not surprised because unless your using a ceramic, or even carbon mic, all electronic microphones use electrets.
Here's why:
1. They have the best dynamic range, typically in the 20-20k hertz range. Remeber, the human ear can't hear below 30 hertz, and by the time you're 40, or have gone to your fifth Metallica/Pink Floy concert, you generally can't distinguish sound in the 50 hertz dynamic range. THere is very little sound above 12k that is functionally useful, but the range of 12k-20k gives a sound envelop "ambience"/or fullness. (This is kind of subjective, but any sound pros know what I'm trying to say...It's like a background timbre that "fills" out the sound.)
2. They consume little power, in the 10-150 mA range, and use 1.5V per electret.
3. Their output resistance is typically 1.5K ohms. This output resistance matches almost all op-amp ICs, eliminating the need for resistance matching...additional components and additional cost, and additional noise!
4. While they are omni-directional, meaning they pick up in a 360 degree field, they can be made unidirectional by insulating the back of the electret cartridge. They also can be pick up sculpted by lensing the input area. (Like barn doors control light output, this also works in reverse for sound entering the electret)
So, that's the reason even your fairly expensive shotgun mics, boom mics, lavs, etc., all use electret microphone cartridges. Remember also, that these cartridges come in different grades also...in terms of output, harmonic distortion, etc.
(A quick BG on the electret mic cartridge. It is an aluminum case that is punched out of a sheet of AL with a tiny hole in the center. Imagine an opened tuna can with a hole in the center of the remainign lid. Then a stretched peice of AL-Tn milar is stretched over a thin shim gasket. This is placed inside the canister. A VERY SMALL FET--field effect transistor-is soldier to the edge of the can, to the milar film and to the back of the printed circiot baord. Typically two wire leads are all that are sticking oiut the back of an electret cartidge. The aluminum can is crimped on the edges sealing it up. This works in that sound enters the small hole causing the mylar metal film to vibrate. These vibrations are amplified by the FET and sent out the leads. The FET amplifies and also lowers the output resistance to 1.5K ohms. I have measured the output resistance with the FET, it is 100Megohms, a hundred million ohms, to high to be worthwhile unless runnign through a FET)
So, what am I posting this for? TO show my superior intellect, ROFLMAO, hahahaha, NO.
I want to design a new microphone system, but need some input from you that are pros/prosumers/amatuers. Am also looking for some try-er-outers too!
Questions:
How long of lead from mic head unit to camera? This is critical becuase longer leads create all kinds of problems. Long leads also mean designing in a power-amp booster at the mic head.
Does having a simple two stage mixer at the end oif the boom arm make sense? (I figure that a good set up with two mics would have one high on a pole, and one "shot-gunned" at mid-range, on or off the camera.)
XLR pins? I'm envisioning that it will be self-powered because XLR phantom powers 48V...WAY TOO MUCH for what I'm using. (I can step it down, but is an additional power supply to the mics that much of an incovenience?)
What type of pick up characteristics do you want? Full, rich timbred sound, or narrow, focused sound? (These two are not mutually exclusive BTW!)
Do you want a stero mic?
Finally, does that hologrphic doo-hickey for $6k excite anyone? (I can build one with 5 mics for like 200 bucks, no XLR outs though...)
Will you be using DAT/MD/on-board camera for the sound recording?
How long a pole?
Weight requirements?
Like I said, am wanting to build a new mic system for a few reasons:
1. To show tht it can be done for a lot less than current.
2. I want a better system!
3. Advance current state of the art.
Oh, if you want to email me direct: nushuz1@juno.com