Boom Poles USELESS?

Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

I can't say I watched Light Speed Rescue, not knowing what it is :P

I stopped watching Power Rangers after they started changing up the cast and megazords and the like...

But regardless, that's awesome Terry! Good luck with the shoot in Florida!
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

I think I may have watched Light Speed Rescue but I don't really remember. I haven't seen that show in like 10 years.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

The original Power Rangers TV show, with the original DinoZords and -- what was the bad gal's name, Rita? -- that was some good TV. But there's something wrong with the IMDB rankings when "Power Rangers Turbo" is only #17 on the "Bottom 100" list. People are trying to say that there are 16 movies in the world that are worse than that? :o
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

One of his professors said this to your friend? Professor of what? of 'Not knowing WTF he is talking about' 101?

Sorry, I just discovered this thread; there is not much to sya except, yes, that is asinine.
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

Somebody created their own boompole (he also used the AT897). You can see it at this link (sorry for linking to another forum, but I thought this information would help out):

http://www.dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?s=d93171c190a35afe819120b85c58fc0a&threadid=22263



The comments were both positive and negative, but some other guy that also created the homemade pole had this to say in response to the negative:



"First let me comment on this common misconception about "home depot" fiberglass poles and their weight.

More than once I've seen people say : "Too heavy for serious use."

The recommended 15 foot home depot fiberglass pole is OUNCES LIGHTER THAN THE EQUIVALENT LENGTH GIZMO "pro" boom poles.

Rather than speculate or give misleading prejudiced information, I looked at the actual specifications of the Gizmo poles at B&H, then weighed my Home Depot pole on a digital scale. Mine's lighter.

****

We shot a feature this spring using this pole and an ME66, and got ZERO handling noise.

Tape down your cables and use some common sense. If cables are threaded iinternally then you have no control over any internal cable rubbing, and this could very well be much harder to control noise then external cables.

****

You can grip this pole anywhere and get from 1 foot to 15 foot usable length. To change the angle of the mike- rotate the pole in your hand-- it will go 360 degrees. In four months of shooting, there wasn't a single mike position we couldn't get by telling the boom operator to move his feet or hands.

****

I like the new contribution of the threaded coupling-- thanks!

****

The pole is not totally laser beam rigid-straight at fully extended length of 15 feet, but certainly close enough and not an issue as this rarely came up. Shorter extensions were just fine, as would be the full extended length.

I think often people (but not all) poo poo a cheaper DIY alternative without really knowing the facts or having used the alternative, or used the wrong alternative. It's a prevalent prejudice and belief that the more you spend, the better your project/equipment will be. This is the biggest myth of all.

It's using your head with whatever you've got that's always been most important, equipment comes next and is always secondary to creativity. The people with real experience and the real money know this as well.

My pictures at:
http://www.neilslade.com/Papers/pole.html"



There's actually some pretty cool projects at his site. In fact, I have the materials to create this pole (along with the AT897) so I'll probably give it a try and test it all out this weekend. :)
 
Posted by Bryan Cahill

Posted by Bryan Cahill

POSTED BY BRYAN CAHILL            
       

                       Thanks for the welcome.  I was also a Putty Patroler one day when we were short a stuntman and did flips off of a mini trampoline!
Back to the subject of boom poles:  I own 2 carbon fiber and two aluminum poles.  If I'm working in really heavy winds or in very harsh conditions, ie. water, mud, etc... I will use an aluminum pole.  It is heavier but is stronger and cheaper.  Heavy winds can actually bend a carbon fiber pole to the point of breaking.  
I believe Wilcox Sound still sells a long aluminum pole called a robo pole for about half the price of a carbon fiber equivilant.  The company owner, Blake Wilcox, was the Sound mixer on Beverly Hills 90210.  I'm not endorsing the co. but do own a robo pole that was given to me and find it serviceable.
 
You can also make a boom pole out of the poles used for cleaning pools.                          
 
Re: Boom Poles USELESS?

As a cameraman for BTS (behind the scenes) documentaries, I assure you that boom poles are NOT useless. On the most recent production I was shooting for, I had a soundman with me, and we went wireless between us, so that we could seperate and he could get as close to a shot as possible, and I'd shoot from a distance, allowing natural conversation to continue. Sometimes I'd get a production feed from the Sound Mixer, especially for during takes. The ONLY time I ever used an on camera shotgun was when space was way too entirely on a premium, and the only way to get any EPK/BTS shots was to only have me in there, one-man banding it, sans soundman.
 
It's a silly point!!! your friend must misunderstood / misinterpreted something. not using a boom pole is like using a digital zoom in a consumer model camera.you'll get crap!
Right now I'm working on a 16 episodes of 45 minute drama being aired on National Tv and I'm doing field audio for it. We never dreamt of not using a boom (except in constrained locations-for example inside a car) The main secret is "the closest you can get to your sound source - the better". Mounting a gun mike on board your camera will produce a very close ratio between ambience and dialogue which you can never adjust in post. Positioning your mike as close as possible to your talent will produce a high ratio of dialogue compared to ambience. Another good point to bear in mind when booming is to point the mike to the opposite direction from where unwanted noise is being emmited/reflected. i.e boom actors from overhead with mike pointing downwards to the silent floor. you'll be offmike from echoes of the same dialogue reflected by the ceiling, especially when you're indoors in a high ceiling room. the third good point is -Always record a minute or two of ambience (in perfect silence). This will be very helpful in post. Especially when you have dialogue between 2 or more actors. you can lay a bed of ambience underneath your dialogue to diminish the changes in sound when you cut from one actor to the other.
 
Or, maybe you could save some money up and add it to the 400 bucks, and get the stuff you really want. Another solution to the heavy boom pole is to just build up more upper body strength. The chicks will dig it, and you'll be able to hold that boom pole for a long time.
 
useless professor

useless professor

"My friend in college said that boom poles are useless. He says that his professors even say this"

If a professor said this then he is the useless item in the production world. I'd love to know what university he teaches at. Is he at U Colorado with Ward, Mr. Plagarism, Churchill?
This prof should be outed, lots of kids (parents) are paying top dollar to be fed BS.
 
Where you shootin'?

On a sound stage, you won't need a boom if you can place multiple mics all over the place.

But, generally, we're not the folks who record 24-channel sound, so...yeah a boom is a good thing to have. ;)

Dan
 
Ptpiz said:
My friend in college said that boom poles are useless. He says that his professors even say this. Is this true?


Your friend is talking out his @$$. If his profs are teaching a class related to cinema, they should not be teaching, because that is one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. Saying a boompole is useless is like saying the steering wheel in your car is useless.



By the way....ADR stands for Automatic Dialogue Replacement. Putting Additional Dialogue Recording on your final will be marked as incorrect.

-Dave
 
"By the way....ADR stands for Automatic Dialogue Replacement. Putting Additional Dialogue Recording on your final will be marked as incorrect."

Not by his moronic prof...
 
More importantly, this thread was started back in June of 04. I think he might be graduated by now. :)
 
xort said:
"By the way....ADR stands for Automatic Dialogue Replacement. Putting Additional Dialogue Recording on your final will be marked as incorrect."

Not by his moronic prof...


This could be very true. I remember on my final in college I put "Additional Dialogue Recording", and it was marked incorrect, so that is something I'll never forget.
 
Back
Top