ADR question

ProfessorChaos

Active member
How much percent of professional film and TV shows(indy or hollywood) is rerecorded with ADR? Someone told me that 90% if not all the dialogue and sfx recorded on set/location will end up being replaced with audio from ADRing. Is this true? If not, what is the realistic percentage?
 
Well the quick answer is that it's time and labour intensive and therefore expensive. So it's a neglible cost on a Hollywood feature, and very high cost on an indy film or TV show. But assuming the budget is there, there is also an artistic side to it. Many actors and directors hate ADR as they always struggle to reproduce the vocal performance that naturally occurred when they were on set. Also, matching the ambience with the location in the film is an art in itself.

In Hollywood features, where commercial audience audibility is king, 90-100% is not unusual. In France, where the purity of the performance may be considered more important, features often have little to no ADR at all even if they have the budget. That doesn't mean they don't have foley or sfx though, as these just don't normally sound right on a set
.
Of course, films can vary anywhere between the two extremes. And in some noisy locations or ones with lousy acoustics, you may have no choice but to ADR.
 
The quote of 90% - 100% is possible for some commercials, but not for most feature films or episodics. The use of lavs and highly directional mics allows for good usable audio on a lot of shots. Exterior shots certainly run the risk of environmental sound issues more than say, shooting on a controlled sound stage, but even then, you can have perfectly good dialog.

In the end, quoting a percentage is likely just guess work as it will depend upon the talent, the environment and many other factors, but good, modern location sound can get very good dialog a decent percentage of the time.
 
khmuse said:
The quote of 90% - 100% is possible for some commercials, but not for most feature films or episodics... In the end, quoting a percentage is likely just guess work as it will depend upon the talent, the environment and many other factors, but good, modern location sound can get very good dialog a decent percentage of the time.

Yes. I was saying there's a full spectrum of possibilities between the extremes, but khmuse made it clearer. Agree talking about percentages is probably not all that accurate or helpful! I stand corrected.:grin:
 
Back
Top