Active noise reduction headphones?

Andy

New member
Costco in Canada is selling Altec Lansing AHP-712 "active noise reduction" stereo headphones, advertised for use in; airplanes, video games, MP3, CD and PC.

Specs are: 40 mm neodymium drivers, 3.5 mm and 0.25" plugs, frequency response 20 Hz- 20 kHz, impedance 32 ohm, noise reduction >19 db from 40 Hz - 12 kHz.

Are these any good for sound monitoring?
 
These are actually active noise canceling devices. These devices attempt to reduce the infiltration of external noise sources by actively extracting (by differentiating) the noise source by adding its antiphase counterpart. A reduction of 19 dB is a considerable (nearly 10:1) advantage so even if it doesn't fully live up to that claim, it could be useful. The only down side (other than requiring a power source - battery) is there will be some amplitude anomalies based upon the nose canceling technique.
 
If I understand you, these headphones do two things;
they transmit the sound you're trying to listen to,
and they detect (by a tiny mic?) extraneous sounds
(which are then dampened by opposite phasing.)

Therefore, in a quiet film-recording environment,
there'd be no extraneous sounds, no antiphase, and no anomalies?
 
Your understanding of the mode of operation is correct. If there are no external noise sources, then the active noise canceling stage will be mostly inactive (with the exception of the self noise contribution).
 
How accurate do you need the monitoring to be? I would not recommend them for critical listening but for general purpose monitoring they would probably be fine.

Steve
 
Thanks.

Then forgetting the noise reduction option,
this headset has the 40mm neodymium drivers,
response range 20 Hz-20 kHz, 32 ohm impedance,
closed ear cup with padded headband & leatherette ear pads.

How good is this compared to other monitoring headsets,
and how good a deal is it at about US$75?

Also, is this the correct jack size? (3.5mm, 0.25")
 
Sorry Steve, I posted above before reading your response.

It's for a low budget drama feature hopefully for theatrical release,
so I can't afford to lose anything due to inaccurate monitoring.
 
I sure wouldn't use noise canceling headphones for monitoring anything. Spend an extra $20 and get a pair of Sony MDR 7506.
 
Yeah, noise cancelling headphones are just begging for trouble. While you want to reduce any extra noise that will creep n the sides of the headphones, noise cancelling will also eliminate noise that is going on your track that you willl be blissfully unaware of.

Headphones specs are pretty much meaningless. Do like tigeba said and spring the extra couple of bucks for the Sony 7506, same headphones used on all your favorite Hollywood movies :thumbsup:

Cheers
 
Andy, you can do your sound editing with headphones, but if mixing for a feature that you hope to get in theatres, I highly recommend you edit as best you can and then take this to a sound facility to get mixed. It will be very difficult to get a true sense of the mix via headphones. Think about what a theatre will sound like compared to them. I suppose if you are just trying to get a cut of the film to show potential financers who you hope will front the money for a final mix than maybe you could get away with mixing in headphones for now, but not for a final mix.

Steve
 
Back
Top