AA Battery vs. Phantom Power

Phil H.

Active member
I did some tests with my DVX100B and a few different mics that have a power module requiring a AA battery.

I tested the audio level using a AA battery (phantom power off), then took the AA battery out and tested the mics with phantom power on.

I was monitoring the sound visually on the LCD and with a set of MDR-7506 headphones.

Last thing to note is that I used new disposable AAs and fully charged rechargeble AAs for my test.

Results:
To my surprise, the audio levels were about 40% higher with phantom power than any of the AAs I tested.

Conclusion:
I now have an alternative to using the -60db setting in situations where I can't get the mic close to the source. The -60db setting, while increasing the level significantly, also adds a considerable amount of background hiss.

Questions:
Is it typical for most mic/mixer/camera setups to have higher audio levels when using phantom power vs using a AA battery in the power module? And if so, why use the AA battery module?

:dankk2:
 
Some microphones accept either low voltage from batteries or 48v phantom power. They perform better with higher voltage (the best mics use 130 volts from separate supplies), like your experiment showed. Higher levels mean usually lower backround noice.

To use battery:

a) if the recorder/camera has no phantom power or you use a cheap radio transmitter which supplies no phantom power. I have kept my ME66/K6 because of this even though I have a better phantom powered shotgun also. For minidisc, Sennheiser G2 plugon module, TRV900 etc.

b) you are desperate to save camera batteries, as powering the mic eats current. Using batteries on the mic you can shoot longer.
 
Yeah, I understand the conservation of power. Not knowing that phantom power was actually much better, I was using the power modules. I don't think I'll EVER use them again if I don't absolutely have to now. Would have saved some headache on the last few shoots I've done as well.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top