Barry_Green
Moderator
Oh, and not related to the HPX, but could you please describe your hard drive setup and workflow? Were they RAIDed? Did you download through the HPG20 or through Cardbus reader and Mac? Were the drives bus powered USB or eSATA? Etc...
I don't use the Mac; Kevin did though. Kevin can fill you in on what he did; as far as I understand he used either the camera or the P2 Portable as the slot reader, through USB, and copied footage using ShotPut Pro onto two separate USB drives.
For my workflow, I used either the Windows laptop to copy to a single USB drive, or I used the P2 Portable to bus-power and offload to a single USB drive. Every few days I executed a backup onto another drive. I came back with three drives' worth of footage, about 1.25 terabytes, and a second copy (another 1.25 terabytes).
No RAID involved, just $90 drives from Best Buy, I used Seagate FreeAgent drives, three 500's and three 320's. Kevin used WD drives, I believe they were USB.
Kevin would offload footage during the down time between drives. I would offload footage right in the van, using the P2 Portable or the laptop, right in the field. Every few days we'd "reconcile" footage, so that footage he had that I didn't, he'd copy to my drive; footage I had that he didn't, he'd copy off my drive. So we both left there each with a copy of the footage, and I actually had two copies.
Really, P2 management was almost nonexistent. I'd say that probably 80% of the time we didn't even offload in the van at all; we'd shoot all morning and then Kevin would offload during naptime. Occasionally we'd find so much good stuff to shoot that we'd start to make progress into our second 32GB card, and at times like that I'd pop out the first card and let the P2 Portable offload it. It took about 10 seconds of my attention: "Here, can you offload this card? Sure, hold on... press copy... okay, hey, look at that warthog!" So we'd shoot the footage of the warthog for 10 or 20 minutes and then I'd hand him the card back. It really was no big deal, and I don't think I ever had to offload more than one card per game drive.
But at night, we'd both have instant immediate access to all the dozens or hundreds of gigabytes of footage. I used EDIUS 4.6 (since upgraded to EDIUS 5!) and P2 Viewer. He used Calibrated's MXF plug-in for Mac, and also Raylight. We both had instantaneous access to the footage. He spent some time cutting a highlights reel as we went, during the downtime.
I didn't do any editing during the safari, but when we got back I used P2 Viewer to scan through all the footage and mark text memos on the in/out points of footage that I wanted to keep. I also marked the "shot mark" on those clips. Then I used P2 Viewer to filter all my virtual clips down to only show those with shot marks, and copied them all to a P2 card (one click). Then I put that P2 card in the P2 Portable and used the "view text memo clips" option to show where the text memos were. On each clip I would export the text-memo'd portion to the second card slot. The results were that I got a seamless, frame-accurate, first-generation copy of only the in/out bits that I wanted, all in the original codec. No rendering, no computer involved, just exporting subsets of the clips. I then sent that card on to Jan so she could show footage in the original raw codec at the press conference, and I used a few of the clips of that footage to make the clips you saw here.
Workflow was easier than any P2 project I've been on yet. The cards were large enough (and 1080/24pN mode gives you 25% more recording time!) ShotPut Pro makes offloading effortless, including verification, as does the P2 Portable (especially because it bus-powers huge drives). And EDIUS supports the native AVC-I footage, as does FCP with Calibrated.
Last edited: