mkh 70 exterior and MXL 604 interior?

mlemaudit

Member
Hi I already have an mkh 70 and I am wondering about an hyper cardioid for inside shoots. I have seen in the previous post that an MXL 604 is comparable to an Oktava MK012 who everybody in this forum trust. Do you guys think it's even better to use an MXL 604 instead of an MKH 70 for interior?

I am just concerned about how much this mic will match in terms of the quality level an mkh 70 is.
 
dont care to mutch about matching - not important at all .
dont familiar with the mxl , but oktava is quit good to start with
if you have few more bucks the mbho or akg uls are much better option .
 
by the way mxl is cardioid pattern , you need hyper what is usually better for film use .not that cardioid is not something useful as well
 
My ideal would be an mkh 50 for interior, but I need to buy a good boom pole, windshield and a recorder before that... So I guess I will borrow the Oktava from sa friend until I have the budget for something better. thx
 
I agree with Oleg, you need a hypercardioid.

Oktava would be just fine, or sure, spend more.

The shotgun will not be good in any kind of interior that has refective surfaces (even though it is a much much better overall mic).
 
I had never even heard of the mxl 604 but looking at it it might be worth trying for $100 IF you can get a hyper cap for it. It could also be crap and then you would wish you would have put that money towards an Oktava or one of those Peluso knockoffs.

I would not use the mkh70 as your sole outdoor mic. It is EXTERMELY unforgiving and unnecessary for most exterior work. If you only have one outdoor mic I would get the mkh416 or 60, or the Sanken cs3e. Considering the amount of dust my 816 (same as mkh70) collects I often consider selling it. Most situations I would have used it in the past I find wireless to be a better fix.

Cheers
 
"My ideal would be an mkh 50 for interior"
I checked this mic on bhphoto it says it is super cardioid.
Is super cardioid the same as hyper cardioid?
If it is ,is MKH 50 the best for interiors?
Thanks.
 
wabbit said:
I would not use the mkh70 as your sole outdoor mic. It is EXTERMELY unforgiving and unnecessary for most exterior work. If you only have one outdoor mic I would get the mkh416 or 60, or the Sanken cs3e. Considering the amount of dust my 816 (same as mkh70) collects I often consider selling it. Most situations I would have used it in the past I find wireless to be a better fix.

Cheers


The thing is that I already own the MKH 70, do you suggest selling it before I get the windscreen kit for it because it is a longer mic and it will be a waste if I buy shorter mics later. I heard that the Sanken is not so good for exterior but more often use on interior film set because of it's great back reflexion capacity. Also the Sanken seems to be very fragile with humidity levels...
 
Last edited:
I am not going to say it is a waste to keep it; other mixers use their long mics a lot but if it a choice between owning only a long or short gun I would definately go with a short. A used mkh70 will sell for enough to buy any of the shorts (except Schoeps) new and will give you some pocket change if you buy a 416 used.

Other people can speek better to the Sanken as I have only experimented briefly with it. At the time I was not impressed one way or the other by it but with people like Oleg singing it's praises I will gladly pass on their recommendation.

Good luck
 
mlemaudit said:
The thing is that I already own the MKH 70, do you suggest selling it before I get the windscreen kit for it because it is a longer mic and it will be a waste if I buy shorter mics later. I heard that the Sanken is not so good for exterior but more often use on interior film set because of it's great back reflexion capacity. Also the Sanken seems to be very fragile with humidity levels...

i "heard "you don't know what you are talking about :-)

i use sankens on every location , not to mention it the best shotgun for overall work

back reflection - i am just my way to the beach to see some back reflections .
humidity - sorry i am in the desert with 85 of
 
what oleg means here is that the sanken is more likely ONLY used on exteriors, and works great in high humidity.

and how are you using an mkh70 outside if you dont have a wind kit for it?
 
Oleg 2 said:
i "heard "you don't know what you are talking about :-)


Here is one source of where I "heard " bad feedback from users of a Sanken on Usenet:

User 1:
>I purchased a new CS-3e, receiving it just before leaving town to work
>an HD feature, so this was the first time I had used the mic.
>Besides the fact that I really like my COS-11's, I chose the CS-3e
>based on positive reviews and many thumbs-up offered here previously.
>However, I had been led to believe that the CS-3e was not susceptible
>to high-humidity problems. Not so. Twice during production, several
>hours into night shoots with admittedly very high humidity, the CS-3e
>began making continuous, low-frequency rumblings, which I'm quite sure
>was humidity related (the mic performed flawlessly during low
>humidity). I was forced to use my K6/ME-66 (yes, I know its an ENG
>quality microphone) as backup just to get through the night.
>
>I have heard that both the Sennheiser MKH-416P48 and MKH-60 are free
>from such humidity problems. Can anyone confirm this through field
>use? I need to purchase a quality short shotgun mic that I can be
>sure will not go down on me under such conditions. Any opinions/help
>are welcomed and appreciated. Thanks.

User 2:

I had the same problems during last year ,it happened few times ,each time
for short period,twice it happened in very hot summer day and ones inside
sport gym .I I never found the problem sins it gone by it self until the
next time,eventually that mike died 2 weeks before his first birthday and
did travel to Japan to factory reaper ,I never got the reason for its
collapsing from sanken.I can try to check it again with the local dealer.The
mike was returned in July and sins then worked about 50 days without any
problem in day and night shots,the humidity here in summer can be around
85%.
All the times that it happened I was powering the mike from sd 442 .
If it will die surprises in near future ,please email to the group,cines
that Sunken sars looks to be very interesting to our work.
Its wonderful mike and I didn't found anything that gave me better sound in
hard locations but like I sad few topics down ,if you have only one mike in
your arsenal it better with "416 " on its logo .The 416 its like Subaru you
coming in the morning and it is going .
>
 
Last edited:
timapter said:
what oleg means here is that the sanken is more likely ONLY used on exteriors, and works great in high humidity.

and how are you using an mkh70 outside if you dont have a wind kit for it?

I was renting equipment before and now I am building my own kit the mkh70 is a recent purchase...
 
oh ok. by the way, the user 2 you have quoted there is actually oleg! ha ha! so i'm sure he'll have an interesting response to that.

i know he had a cs-3e that mysteriously died very young - sanken replaced it and he hasnt had problems since. i believe that recently oleg sold his 416, so obviously the sanken has since proven itself beyond doubt.
 
mlemaudit said:
Here is one source of where I "heard " bad feedback from users of a Sanken on Usenet:

User 1:
>I purchased a new CS-3e, receiving it just before leaving town to work
>an HD feature, so this was the first time I had used the mic.
>Besides the fact that I really like my COS-11's, I chose the CS-3e
>based on positive reviews and many thumbs-up offered here previously.
>However, I had been led to believe that the CS-3e was not susceptible
>to high-humidity problems. Not so. Twice during production, several
>hours into night shoots with admittedly very high humidity, the CS-3e
>began making continuous, low-frequency rumblings, which I'm quite sure
>was humidity related (the mic performed flawlessly during low
>humidity). I was forced to use my K6/ME-66 (yes, I know its an ENG
>quality microphone) as backup just to get through the night.
>
>I have heard that both the Sennheiser MKH-416P48 and MKH-60 are free
>from such humidity problems. Can anyone confirm this through field
>use? I need to purchase a quality short shotgun mic that I can be
>sure will not go down on me under such conditions. Any opinions/help
>are welcomed and appreciated. Thanks.

User 2:

I had the same problems during last year ,it happened few times ,each time
for short period,twice it happened in very hot summer day and ones inside
sport gym .I I never found the problem sins it gone by it self until the
next time,eventually that mike died 2 weeks before his first birthday and
did travel to Japan to factory reaper ,I never got the reason for its
collapsing from sanken.I can try to check it again with the local dealer.The
mike was returned in July and sins then worked about 50 days without any
problem in day and night shots,the humidity here in summer can be around
85%.
All the times that it happened I was powering the mike from sd 442 .
If it will die surprises in near future ,please email to the group,cines
that Sunken sars looks to be very interesting to our work.
Its wonderful mike and I didn't found anything that gave me better sound in
hard locations but like I sad few topics down ,if you have only one mike in
your arsenal it better with "416 " on its logo .The 416 its like Subaru you
coming in the morning and it is going .
>

my dear i own that mic for 3 years since it came from factory repair in japan and it works fine with all the humidity , still dont know what happend and iam quit sure it wasnt humidity at all , and i own another 2 ( yep i have 3 ) and they dont seems have any problems , cs-3 e had some problems years ago ,the new ones seem to be fine , by the way - i didnt pull 416 for last 2 yeas and i dont intend to do it , i keep 2 for my rentings for these who live in the dark adge :-)
the other guy from england had serial number very close to my firs so i suspect that the problem was indentical ,
 
my dear , ialso dont write under pseodonims you can use my name -
before you hear something check with your ears
user 2
 
wabbit said:
I had never even heard of the mxl 604 but looking at it it might be worth trying for $100 IF you can get a hyper cap for it. It could also be crap and then you would wish you would have put that money towards an Oktava or one of those Peluso knockoffs.

I would not use the mkh70 as your sole outdoor mic. It is EXTERMELY unforgiving and unnecessary for most exterior work. If you only have one outdoor mic I would get the mkh416 or 60, or the Sanken cs3e. Considering the amount of dust my 816 (same as mkh70) collects I often consider selling it. Most situations I would have used it in the past I find wireless to be a better fix.

Cheers
hey WABBIT I see you dont make allot of beach movies - the 816 is the onlything that works there
 
its bettetr - a bit wider then oktava hyper cardioid -6 times more money
for the price of that you can get allot more mics - the difernce would be very little for dialog
 
Back
Top