Colorista or FCP?

Lake Films

Veteran
Ok, which is better, or are they the same programs, colorista or FCP's 3 way color wheel? Is colorista worth the $199?
 
Colorista is a definite improvement over the 3-way color corrector in FCP. Not only does it seem to handle color changes a lot better (i.e. not trashing your image when you start doing heavy corrections), it also gives you power window functionality, meaning you can choose to correct only certain parts of an image. You can stack multiple instances of Colorista with different window masks and really get a lot of control over the color in your images, just like the pros. It's a very cool piece of software.
 
I'd say master FCP's built-in color corrector first. Colorista is a great added tool but color correction is a tricky skill to learn.

Noah
 
The only advantage I see with colorista is the ability to use what are called POWER WINDOWS. The ability to add a secondary level of color correction that can isolate certain areas of the screen. Drawback is that you cannot keyframe it for shots with camera movement.

Learn the 3-Way. I use it to color broadcast work.
 
Yes I agree, I just installed FCP 5, got my color correction book from amazon specifically for FCP, and I'm on my way! The more I work with their CC tool, the more I realize how good it can be. Thanks guys.
 
I find lots of my students in my Adv FCP class, where we cover CC'ing, are not happy with FCP's 3-Way CC'er. But when we start doing the training, they all go, "Oh, wait, that's not what I was doing! I never even looked at the scopes!" When we're done, they're impressed.

Colorista, from what I read, is very good. Can be a tad more subtle in changes than FCP, and has Power Windows. But there's also no secondary CC'ing ability.

I've begun to experiment with Conduit in FCP, and find it to be even better than Colorista.

I'd have bought Coloista, but the demo I had placed so much noise on the image, I couldn't judge the quality of the grading I was doing. If they'd have put a watermark on it, that would have been more logical. To cripple your demo by introducing NOISE in a plug-in that does Color Correction, what's up with that?

Point is, Colorista is nice, but not worth a fireworks display over.

Get the APTS Advanced Color Correction book, learn to do it correctly FIRST. Then invest in whatever tools you need. Cause FCP's 3-Way CC'er and Colorista are only a small part of what goes into getting the look you need.
 
A while back intial users of the demo were reporting that Colorista was crashing their systems. Has that issue been taken care of? I thought I'd give the demo a try but it's certainly not worth it if there's any chance it will cause problems.
 
BenB said:
I've begun to experiment with Conduit in FCP, and find it to be even better than Colorista.
quote]

BenB,

I've noticed other positive comments you've posted about Conduit, but after a visit to DVgarage's website, I am still not sure what the benefits of the plugin are. The "features" page on website talks almost exclusively about the nodal interface, but provides little else in the way of details. Is the interface what you like about Conduit, or is their more to it than that? I have Colorista, but find it has some shortcomings, like the absence of separate reset buttons for each color wheel and, on my system at least, the undo command does not apply to color adjustments in the color wheels (unless this is just the GUI not updating, which I have also noticed).

Thanks for any feedback.
Kevin
 
I've heard people mention that they CC in Motion or Shake? Anyone else hear or try this?
 
Last edited:
BenB said:
...the demo I had placed so much noise on the image, I couldn't judge the quality of the grading I was doing. If they'd have put a watermark on it, that would have been more logical. To cripple your demo by introducing NOISE in a plug-in that does Color Correction, what's up with that?
BenB, based in no small part on your feedback (which echoed that of may other demo downloaders), Red Giant has changed the demo from the annoying noise overlay to something else. I think that new version is what's on the site now.

I hadn't experienced the noise first-hand before we shipped, and once I did, I was in complete agreement with you—it's terribly annoying!

-Stu
 
I have FCP ver 5.0.4 I wish it (Colorista) supported it as I wanted to play around with the demo version. Oh well...Time to update I guess..
 
In response to the question of "which is better," FCP's 3-way or Colorista, I won't say that Colorista is better (that's for you to decide), but I can show you why I decided I needed it. Remember, I don't design plug-ins out of some attempt to get rich or "fill a market need," I design things that I feel I need in my arsenal in order to get my work done.

Watch this movie and you'll see how FCP's 3-way responds to the kind of color correction that I often do, and then the same basic moves performed in Colorista. I even go back into the 3-way to try to make the blacks richer, but I can't seem to bring them down once they're heavily tinted.

I hope that helps you see how the two tools behave differently, and helps you make an eductaed decision about whather or not Colorista is right for you!

-Stu

PS: Credit where credit is due—I didn't invent the way Colorista does color, I copied it from the greats; Da Vinci, Lustre, Final Touch, Scratch, etc.

Update: I blogged this.
 
Last edited:
Stu-I have Colorista and think it is a terrific product. I have redone some of the tutorials in the APTS Special Effects and Color Correction book using Colorista instead of the 3-way color corrector, and was struck by the results. I wonder, however, if there is a work-around for the following bug. When one makes a color adjustment by dragging the handle in one of the color wheels, the plugin seems to treat the move as a series of very small incremental changes. The result is that when you try to undo a change you just made, the handle moves back toward where in started in tiny steps until you run out of undo commands without the handle returning all the way. The undo works fine if you move the handle by clicking elsewhere in the color wheel, but I doubt too many people work this way. (At least I don't.)

In any event, I would put this on the requested features wish list for the next version, together with separate reset buttons for each color wheel and secondary color correction.

Thanks,
Kevin Wolff
 
Interesting, I had never noticed that kwoff! I'll ping RGS about it immediatly. Thanks for the great sugestions.

-Stu
 
Oh ok thanks. I just got 5.0 updated to 5.0.4, and apple wants another 99 to get 5.1+, money money, lol....Thanks again.

Oh that side by side you did was pretty good and sort of 'eye opening'.
 
Hi kwoff, just wanted to let you know we feel your pain. The undo thing is a problem in FCP confirmed by Apple that hopefully will be fixed in the next version. Pretty annoying I know.

The separate reset for each color wheel is really more of our issue I think, though this too was somewhat caused by what was available in FCP. Our work around for now is clicking on the color swatch arc in the upper left corner of each color wheel. Not ideal, but clicking there brings up a OS X color dialog, and you can set the RGB values to all white as a reset for that wheel alone. We'll look at a more reasonable method in the future.

Hope that helps, thanks.


Micah Sharp
Red Giant Software
 
Defiantly Colorista is better all the way. But it would be even better if you were to do all of your post work (outside of editing) in After Effects. The render engines are better than Premiere, Vegas and FCP combined.
 
Back
Top