Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Atomos Ninja2 with HMC150?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Atomos Ninja2 with HMC150?

    Is anybody using this combo to extend the life and quality of the 150? Can I use the Ninja to record 1080p 60? Pros and Cons?

    #2
    I'm curious as well.
    I'm don't think you can get 1080 60p because unless im wrong, neither the camera nor the recorder can do it.

    I'm curious if it helps significantly with keying.
    And secondly improving a little detail in wide shots in 1080, as well as giving a little more latitude to push the levels in post.

    Comment


      #3
      HDMI doesn't do 1080p60, AFAIK, which is fine because the HMC doesn't do 1080p60.

      I have a HMC150 and Ninja 2 and I have used them together... pro is that you can bypass AVCHD compression and record in 422 color space (which should help keying and grading), con is that you've got an extra bit of encumbrance. The Ninja doesn't seem to affect sharpness and detail levels. The combo doesn't get used together very often because I simply haven't needed it.
      Pudgy bearded camera guy
      http://mcbob.tv

      Comment


        #4
        Thank you. Does it help on those wide shots that tend to get mushy and when there are a lot of pixels changing like an outdoor scene with trees blowing and steam? Didn't know if that's an AVCHD thing or simply the resolution limits of the camera.

        Comment


          #5
          Yes, it does alleviate some macroblocking problems on high detail, high movement shots
          Pudgy bearded camera guy
          http://mcbob.tv

          Comment


            #6
            Great. Thank you, mcbob. I was already planning on getting one, and you answered what I was still wondering.

            accelv, I'm sorry it doesn't accomplish what your original post was about - accomplishing 1080 60P.

            Comment


              #7
              Thanks. The other advantage is that it records to Pro Res so there's no ingest and (I assume) you can run a simultaneous backup on AVCHD. So to get 1080p60 you need to record HDSDI?

              The JVC 650U records right to ProRes or XDCAM and offer a 23x lens, WIFI transmission and live streaming,and dual slots. Time for a change?

              Comment


                #8
                No. Short answer -- you can't record 1080/60p on any external recorder yet, that I can think of. It doesn't exist. It can never happen over HD-SDI, as HD-SDI doesn't have the bandwidth. It would require 3G-SDI. The Ninja, the Samurai, the Pix, the Nano, the Shuttle, none of them can record 1080/60p at all (unless I'm mistaken).

                The Odyssey7Q could record 1080/60p but it's not out yet. Even then, you'd need a camera that can output 1080/60p. Not many can, and those that do, as of now, only do so over their HDMI ports.
                ..
                The AU-EVA1 Book - The DVX200 Book - The UX180 & UX90 Book - Lighting For Film & TV - Sound For Film & TV

                Comment

                Working...
                X