PDA

View Full Version : Alternative P2 Workflow machine



ViennaMedia
01-24-2010, 05:31 AM
I got lucky and had access to a 4 year laptop with XP Professional loaded.

There may be other Windows XP machines around you that will provide a P2 card offloader.

What I found in a closet was a HP Compaq nx6325 put out in 2006. 64bit dual-core AMD processor. But, what made it work was that it has a 6-in-1 card reader (MS, Pro, SD, MMC, xD, SM).

That's where I discovered that my P2 card fit.

I installed the Panasonic Driver for the File Manager utility at their website mentioned in the forums here.

I definitely Write-Protected the P2 cards with the external pin switch before inserting them. If I inserted a card it would be recognized as an external device immediately.

If I was going to remove the P2 I did a device eject first and confirmed its removal as a mounted drive.

The only drawback to storing internally is a 60 g hard drive on this model. I only had about 38 gigs of free space on this model I used for my test.

Of course I could offload to an external drive instead of the internal drive. This laptop has a Firewire 800 port. But I first wanted to test the CardBus to internal hard drive speed in the transfer operation. It was fast. I didn't put the stopwatch to it but my impression was it copied the P2 files in a third of the time of USB 2.0 from the camera. Definitely comparable to the Duel Adapter to MacPro laptop method I had been using before Snow Leopard OS X.

It was the multi-format card reader installed on the side that made this Windows machine P2 transfer possible without any adapter.

So, you should look around for older Windows machines with the card reader -- they may be completely free to you or be considered giveaways to someone who will take it.

The reviewer whose post I read from 2006 said his machine lasted 4 hours and 26 minutes on battery. I only use this one with a power adapter.

I was able to transfer the files at over a gig per minute using the Ethernet cable method back to a Mac.

I fired up Final Cut and the files are perfect.

As Barry Green has suggested you should use the Panasonic utility downloadable at their website for managing P2 files because it will verify the files it copies and even perform little fixes on the fly. I only used the P2 Card Manager utility that I installed on the Windows machine.

Spartacus
01-24-2010, 03:31 PM
Are you saying this is an alternative to this http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showthread.php?t=137738
or were you just not aware that P2 uses the PCMCIA connection/slot?

ViennaMedia
01-25-2010, 02:23 AM
Hi Spartacus, my "Alternative P2 Workflow machine" post was a continuation of discoveries over the past few days, including a few exchanges with Barry Green, after getting caught in the Snow Leopard update issue where the update disables the Duel Adapter. I had been using the Duel Adapter in my Macbook Pro 17" machine that had an Express Slot but no card reader that could take the P2, hence the use of the Duel to bridge the P2 and the Mac together for Panasonic MXF file transfer.

If the Macbook Pro had simply included a full-scale input instead I would not have needed the Duel Adapter.

It was only after reading at Creative Cow and here at DVXUSER about the possibility of throwing a Windows laptop into the mix that I looked around and found a laptop with the complete card reader and that my P2 cards fit.

However now I will have to choose between taking an old Windows laptop and external hard drive along when I shoot out of town or my Macbook Pro. And because of flight limitations if I am going to a production I will have to leave the Macbook Pro at home, all because the Snow Leopard upgrade killed my Duel Adapter as a P2 offload device.

wgzn
01-25-2010, 06:40 AM
why dont you just buy an old copy of leopard (well under $100 in most places) and reformat your macbook pro? then your duel adapter will work again and all will be fine.

NoahK
01-25-2010, 08:14 AM
It's not hard to open up the PC laptop and swap out the hard drive for something much larger...even a nice 256GB SSD would be useful.

Noah