J.R. Hudson
08-03-2007, 07:39 PM
This was really fun and a lot less time consuming than the usual fest.
There were 6 standouts in my viewing; I tried approaching this from the perspective of somone who would be looking for the winning ad for my campaign
Doug Spice - Bravo bravo bravo
My vote for winner.
Looked every bit of professional grade and a great concept; your choice of dutch on the wide shot sold me. Very nice.
Macgregor
Visually nice as always but the overall lack of concept left me bored. Another car commercial is what it felt like; but visually, mastery of image and enough to hold my attention.
Solomon Chase
Wow. I'm impressed. Had me from the get go. Awesome job. Felt like a small clip from a film; the lack of attention on the water bottle logo distracted me a bit.
Karl151k
Possibly the most creative one of them all. I loved it. Simple and effective . But left me without our love of visual communication and our cameras.
martin
Another solid professional grade effort. Felt like a Nike ad, looked stunning and had enough concpet to keep me hooked. I can't complain about anything.
Zoidoid
Really really had fun watching this. The concept, the invented product was real enough for me and still fun. Could have been my favorite of the bunch but the voice over that was lacking some impact. - A simple redo on that element would slam this one home for me.
Anyways, awesome. Inspiring. Everyone
Doug Spice is the winner in my mind; not a single element that left me distracted. Every single shot and frame sold me.
There were 6 standouts in my viewing; I tried approaching this from the perspective of somone who would be looking for the winning ad for my campaign
Doug Spice - Bravo bravo bravo
My vote for winner.
Looked every bit of professional grade and a great concept; your choice of dutch on the wide shot sold me. Very nice.
Macgregor
Visually nice as always but the overall lack of concept left me bored. Another car commercial is what it felt like; but visually, mastery of image and enough to hold my attention.
Solomon Chase
Wow. I'm impressed. Had me from the get go. Awesome job. Felt like a small clip from a film; the lack of attention on the water bottle logo distracted me a bit.
Karl151k
Possibly the most creative one of them all. I loved it. Simple and effective . But left me without our love of visual communication and our cameras.
martin
Another solid professional grade effort. Felt like a Nike ad, looked stunning and had enough concpet to keep me hooked. I can't complain about anything.
Zoidoid
Really really had fun watching this. The concept, the invented product was real enough for me and still fun. Could have been my favorite of the bunch but the voice over that was lacking some impact. - A simple redo on that element would slam this one home for me.
Anyways, awesome. Inspiring. Everyone
Doug Spice is the winner in my mind; not a single element that left me distracted. Every single shot and frame sold me.